Could you elaborate on this further?
In post 348, goodmorning wrote:I personally found it fairly useless after the first couple responses, but that's because it's Stone you're arguing with
In post 356, Mr E Roll wrote:
Just out of curiosity if you found Syndrome’s behavior “troubling” and it didn’t sit right with you why didn’t you vote for him? Are you going to follow your own advice and withhold your vote until a viable lynch option materializes even if it’s not one of your strong scum reads?
I’m beginning to like your bandwagon more and more.
Nah. Finding something troubling isn't amounting to a vote, it's more an icky feeling about a post that ticks me off.
Sorry, I have trouble communicating my feelings :/ Or any articulation at all actually.
I'm not going to vote anyone I don't feel is scum, and I am generally slow to vote. I have WIFOM going through my head about all the possibilities and just kinda decide against it until I'm 100%
In post 356, Mr E Roll wrote:
2 has been my most consistent town read, their posts have shown a willingness to engage that seems townish to me.
Uhuh, I didn't really like the ETL reads progression and them slowly confirming each other as town, it seemed planned to me. I could see it coming from the beginning of their interactions, what did you think?
In post 356, Mr E Roll wrote:
I think both scum can be found in some configuration of TNE, Syndrome and A_Stone. Individually each one has looked scummy. I just don’t know which combination is most likely.
I don't really agree with this, when we add the fact that I'm town, that leaves those guys. nothing really pinged my radar from either of them about being a team other than tne accepting the gut read explanation instantly, although that was explained. They do seem to be playing alike though, although soat seems more demotivated and bored. Which probably means he's figured the whole game out in his mind and can't see why the others can't see what he sees.
tl;dr They could both be scum, but I'm doubtful of a scumteam.
If it is then well done them for pulling the wool over my eyes.
In post 376, Mr E Roll wrote:
I thought you were going to flake after these posts. And these posts are a big part of my scum read on you. In my experience a lot of people prefer to play town so have a hard time getting into games were they are scum.
Yet he didn't flake, he's just demotivated. Which isn't a scumtell.
I'm working on improving my grammar
Hopefully I can stop using so many damn commas soon
-----------------------
Mer Thearts
2 really kicked up a big fuss about that Rach thing, I thought it was obvious she said it in a joking manner. Although Buldermar probably didn't get it for a similar reason about why he didn't get my space joke.
GM's posting is over-cautious, if you could out your thinking then we could comment on it, if you leave your thoughts in the air then it's easy to go off on your own tangent. I still find GM townie though, I can't really see posts like #350 coming from scum.
tl;dr I do get your reasoning for keeping us in the dark, but I find it unreasonable.
-----------------------
My heart goes out to you Rach.
In this town, we don't lynch bad guys, we just make them feel really really bad about themselves and give them free access to pills. ~ Detroit 9000/Cub Daigoro