In post 186, DoctorPepper wrote:As for my answer to sword.
1) that post was an answer to Ghost asking us to comment on his argument with Pope. Hmm, Indid mention the possibility of a town v town in another post I think (not sure). 1) how is it that I already have in mind that one of them will be lynched when I havent voted for either of them. So theyre saying one of the other is scum, I don't see anything wrong with me looking at who is scummier from either of them.
It was the whole tone of your post that I didn’t like… You were subtly painting them both as scum saying “I can’t tell which is scummier” , (in a sense giving your approval to lynch either one) all without taking any official stance...painting both of them as scum but refraining from voting can help start/fuel a wagon yet keeps you free and clear of any mislynch…And now you say that you thought at the time that it could have been TvT? if you thought it was TvT then why would you argue about how you can’t tell which one is scummier? That doesn’t even make sense… Instead of pointing out how you can’t tell which of the two is worst, wouldn’t you just say, hey guys, “I think it’s TvT?”
DrP wrote: 2) I think we're out of RVS when someone makes a serious vote, me and Ghost asked about it and he confirmed, so yeah there. Also I was talking about the filler of a) asking the mod non game related questions when we are out of pre game and b) "d-d-d-d-d-double post"
I call bullshit… the problem with this statement is that it was unclear of whether or not Bac was voting Pope seriously at the time Pope laid his RVS vote down. For you to say that it was clear we were out of RVS when at the time you yourself were unsure (as you even asked the question) is BS. Bac didn't confirm his vote on Pope as serious until after Pope placed his RV.
DrP wrote:
3) i read TNE as null because there was little contribution, cquse of V/LA. So the fillers came in pre game. And she also is suspicious of Ghostlin.
TNE was doing his share of fillers after official game start and before his v/la..and he gave little to no reasoning for his suspicions of Ghostlin at the time either… i found it odd that there was no mention of TNE at all in your posting, considering you even called me out for being quiet.
DrP wrote:
4) if you think my case against Ghostlin is stronger, it doesnt automatically mean I should too.
Fair enough.
DrP wrote:
5) i've made more posts, not just 112. Inthink like a few posts later I gave my reads too.
Yes, you did…mainly Ghost/ Pope which was a recap of your #112 with a side of Bacde scum…
Although I still don’t really know if you think Ghost/Pope is TvT, One and One, or both Scum?
DrP wrote:
6) the weirdest thing I've seen from your post is the fact that you vote for me cause I assume that one is scum, where as PimHel voted fo me cause "he doesnt get the feeling that I am suspicious of either player" so major dissonance on the wagon on me there. You say his 132 mirrors your post, but you two have completely different reasons. Uhm, lolwhutt?
Pim pretty much explained it already…I had it worded differently..his #130 says your post seemed fake… I voted you because your post did look fake…to me, you came across as opportunistic scum…in that you subtly tried to painted both players as scum without actually taking a stance... you now reinforce this with your “I thought I had mentioned somewhere that it could be TvT” which makes absolutely no sense to me then why you would say “I can’t tell which is scummier” if in fact you thought that.
