Newbie 1371: Max Steel, Max Finished!

[PhDScar]

@PhD: Well i'm not one for saying my reasons straight away unless i'm making a case, mostly so i know who can see what i'm seeing, and so the one i'm going against doesn't change their attitude to solve the issue and appear more town to me.

But why didn't you present your case when people were accusing you of being scum for having no reason?

[Sakura Hana]

1. I did bring my case before that happened.
2. I did say the reason for voting you was because of the reasons specified before, tho the reason for wanting to add pressure, didn't want to add my reasons for that at the time.

Why do you keep attacking me so much, am i that scummy to you?

[patzer]

For some reason I remember putting Patzer in my town pile. Why?

He's neutral at best to me now.

your reaction doesn't surprise me, but what am I expected to do? I have to say something... if I don't have any major reads Ill just say so.

[Does Bo Know]

It's not what you said recently about no reads. When Majiffy said some of your posts weren't good I agreed, but then I tried to remember why I had you in a town pile in my catch up.

[anorway]

Stressful exams are over, I'm going to catch up now, and then I'll post my reads when I'm done.

[anorway]

I spent almost two hours reading this thread? Wow. I'm testing some spoilers and links so this post may be a bit messy.

Patzer:

Spoiler:

Don't have too much to say about Patzer. Posts #114 and #133 looks very townish, but I don't think that PhD was changing subject in #139. But I do find it peculiar that you find PhD suspicious during the most of the game, but find him neutral after the PhD wagon dissolves. I don't view that as a strong read though.

Patzer is slightly scum to me, one day he's leaning scum and one day he's leaning town, but as for now he's leaning scum.

They May Take Our Lives But They Will Never Take Our Freedom To Have Ridiculously Long User Names

Spoiler:

I like that TMTOL have been trying to get answers from a suspect (#167 & #228). Haven't done anything particularly scummy, so looking town.

PhDScar:

Spoiler:

This may have been mentioned a few times but posts #48 and #53 do contradict with each other. And why do you think that Majiffy is town #156 and later seem to contradict in #174. I agree with what Bo said on this.

Also in #156 you also show that Sakura is your only suspicion. You also say that Sakura is your biggest suspicion later on (#203 & #215) and in #215 you also mention that "Sakura is scum no doubt", yet you never, never, never voted her again after #185. In post #201 you say that you only vote when you are 100% sure that Sakura is scum, but you say she is scum, again in #215. Why don't you vote her if she is "scum no doubt"?

This don't make any sense. Scum. No doubt.

Sakura Hana:

Spoiler:

If I'm not mistaken, your voting TMTOL by PoE in #181? She had bandwagoned, but others have bandwagoned (but not that obviously) too so that is not a big tell. I feel her posts make more sense than PhD's, but I don't understand her reasonings for her votes though. I've usually encountered the "pressure"-thingy when scum gives explanations for voting (RL and in Newbie 1353 if I'm not mistaken).

Slightly scum.

Majiffy:

Spoiler:

Gives good explanations (eg. #116, but extremely weird explanations for his votes. Feels like town.

freezing-hell:

Spoiler:

Having a bit of troubles reading freezing. His actions look towny, but I can't put him in a scum or town category. Neutral, I guess?

ArcAngel9:

Spoiler:

No comment.

[anorway]

... And I forgot Bo. Sorry about that. I'll take that tomorrow. My brain can't handle more reading.

[anorway]

Oh, and

VOTE: PhDScar

[Sakura Hana]

Your post links are incorrect btw, you should prob. ask the mod to fix them

[anorway]

Yeah, that was kinda meant to happen.

[anorway]

@Mod: When is the deadline? Do we even have a deadline?

[PhDScar]

@Mod: Any what's going on with ArcAngel9?

[PhDScar]

@Mod: Any what's going on with ArcAngel9?

Why do i always leave out words?! Any *idea what's going on with ArcAngel9?

[Majiffy]

Yeah, that was kinda meant to happen.

You intended to have links going to the wrong places?

[TMTOLBTWNTOF]

@Mod: When is the deadline? Do we even have a deadline?

Deadlines are set at three weeks and extensions will only be given in the most extreme of circumstances.

Game started May 6 so we have a solid fortnight remaining

They May Take Our Lives But They Will Never Take Our Freedom To Have Ridiculously Long User Names

lololol

Also, how do you access the activity check for this game? I remember that I clicked it once, but I don't remember how to get back to it.

[Majiffy]

Right underneath the page numbers; "Activity Overview"

[patzer]

It's not what you said recently about no reads. When Majiffy said some of your posts weren't good I agreed, but then I tried to remember why I had you in a town pile in my catch up.

that is more sensible. I had assumed it was talking about that most recent post because when I've said things like that in other games people have behaved like you did.

[PhDScar]

I'd be willing to go for Patzer if you find yourself with a PhD town read. Seen some posts by him I didn't particularly enjoy.

Why do find Patzer suspicious? I too have a bad feeling about him but I doubt it's for the same reason, similar maybe but not the same.

On page six Patzer harassed me repeatedly over the issue of "lying". A fact I argued with him over for basically the entire page. In one of his more recent posts he did a completely unexplained 180 claiming I appear neutral on page six.

I reread the thread from page 6.
Now PhD is looking neutral. His posts have been natural, and I could easily see him being town. slight FoS on Sakura, she has said some things that may be coming from a scum point of view, but not certain by any means. I'm not sure what to do now, I don't have any major reads and from my past experience here that is regarded as a scumtell...

This appears suspicious to me. Pazter seems to be using weaker arguments to jump onto my wagon, only to claim I was neutral when the wagon fell apart.

Also what's your opinion on a Patzer/ Sakura scum team?

I could see a possible Patzer/ Sakura scum team. There's been barely any interaction between the two, and pazter barely commented on Sakura in the first place, despite a wagon forming on her.

[Sakura Hana]

I could see a possible Patzer/ Sakura scum team. There's been barely any interaction between the two, and pazter barely commented on Sakura in the first place, despite a wagon forming on her.

I could point quite a lot of people that didn't comment on my wagon, from that logic tho, Patzer could have been someone enjoying the show watching a Towny mislynch, but that's kinda doubtful too, otherwise he'd have hammered me. Unless he is throwing WIFOM?

[PhDScar]

I could point quite a lot of people that didn't comment on my wagon, from that logic tho, Patzer could have been someone enjoying the show watching a Towny mislynch, but that's kinda doubtful too, otherwise he'd have hammered me. Unless he is throwing WIFOM?

Who could you point to? Everyone has made comment on your wagon. Except for Arcangel who hasen't been here for two days.

I also agree that him sitting back and watching a town mislynch instead of hammering is unlikely. But I don't get how that shows you are town this kind of action seems far more likely from scum partners.

[Majiffy]

I'd be willing to go for Patzer if you find yourself with a PhD town read. Seen some posts by him I didn't particularly enjoy.

Why do find Patzer suspicious? I too have a bad feeling about him but I doubt it's for the same reason, similar maybe but not the same.

If I decide to go with a Patzer push, I'll give you a case. Until then, I'm a lazy man.

[Does Bo Know]

I could see a possible Patzer/ Sakura scum team. There's been barely any interaction between the two, and pazter barely commented on Sakura in the first place, despite a wagon forming on her.

I could point quite a lot of people that didn't comment on my wagon, from that logic tho, Patzer could have been someone enjoying the show watching a Towny mislynch, but that's kinda doubtful too, otherwise he'd have hammered me. Unless he is throwing WIFOM?

Patzer-scum could be looking for towncred by not being on a mislynch.

[patzer]

I'd be willing to go for Patzer if you find yourself with a PhD town read. Seen some posts by him I didn't particularly enjoy.

Why do find Patzer suspicious? I too have a bad feeling about him but I doubt it's for the same reason, similar maybe but not the same.

On page six Patzer harassed me repeatedly over the issue of "lying". A fact I argued with him over for basically the entire page. In one of his more recent posts he did a completely unexplained 180 claiming I appear neutral on page six.

Back then, the lying was my main argument for you being scum, although there were other arguments too. In that recent post two things made me reduce my suspicion of you: the fact that others were not bothered about the lying issue, suggesting it was unimportant, and me noticing a strong similarity between your posts and mine in previous games.

[Sakura Hana]

I could point quite a lot of people that didn't comment on my wagon, from that logic tho, Patzer could have been someone enjoying the show watching a Towny mislynch, but that's kinda doubtful too, otherwise he'd have hammered me. Unless he is throwing WIFOM?

Who could you point to? Everyone has made comment on your wagon. Except for Arcangel who hasen't been here for two days.

Oh nvm, i got confused for a momment with another game i'm in. Patzer is looking quite suspicious to me at this point. I'm gonna go look at everyone's ISOs, I'm also wondering about ArcAngel's dissapearance, has anyone confirmed whether she's posted in other games?

[ArcAngel9]

I apologize for the inactivity, i have been busy with work and stuff.. will catch up today or mostly by tomorrow.