Newbie 1367: Maestro's Newbie Newbie (SCUM WIN!)

[jmo16mla]

Sadly, I feel esquire could be town now.

Kslam, why wouldn't MM be killed last night? Or me? Or you?

We are all powerful and experienced players, why wasn't it one of us?

Votecount 2.01 - Saturday, May 18th @ 10:23 PM EDT

TheEsquire -

2

^[L-2]

- jmo16mla, Cabd
Cabd -

1

^[L-3]

- Klazam
TheIrishPope -

0

^[L-4]

Lazurial -

0

^[L-4]

jmo16mla -

0

^[L-4]

Klazam -

3

^[L-1]

- Ms Marangal, Lazurial, TheIrishPope
Ms Marangal -

0

^[L-4]

With

[7]

alive it takes

[4]

to Lynch or No Lynch.

Not Voting:

TheEsquire

Deadline is in ... (expired on 2013-05-28 01:45:00)

Activity Check:

Fine

[TheIrishPope]

Klazam, it's a little thing called scumhunting. Learn to do that.

[Klazam]

That's the point. But specifically- cabd was being aggressive yesterday- doing the most for the town. Why shadi over him?

In my experience- the most protown players often is not.

You're neutral to me, mm was neutral-scum ish, and I was being crappy, tunneling town-shadi.

[Klazam]

Pope. Really? Role fishing is scumhunting? How the fuck is it scumhunting?

[TheIrishPope]

It was a reaction test. If I did it to you, it would give positive for scum.

[Maestro]

OP and pagetop updated with Votecount.

[jmo16mla]

Oh
UNVOTE:

I forgot to do that.

[Klazam]

It was a reaction test. If I did it to you, it would give positive for scum.

jesus youre really that bad arent you.

[Klazam]

ok
im home.

READING

[TheIrishPope]

You're saying I'm bad because:
1. I am voting you,
2. I ascertain you are scum, and
3. You are at L-1.
You are just butthurt.

[Cabd]

Cabd-why? Too confident by far. After d1, he's the most scariest player in the eyes of scum. I was fully excepting him to be nk-d. But no- it's shadi. (Tangent-why the hell would I kill shadi? Think about it) alarm bells go off for me whenever it happens. I know "but it's wifom!" But, in my experience, scum doesn't give a shit about wifom, cause nobody subscribes to it, honestly.

While I appreciate the "most scariest" comment, I was no more aggressive than you were. Actually, if anything, I was slightly more passive than you were. How would you have an insight as to who scum thinks/thought was a threat? Oh yeah, because you're scum.

Tangent: Once again you're speaking in absolutes as to what scum this game is doing. Could just as easily have been you killing your tunnel chocie for free townie points. Only you (and your partner too I guess) knows.

That's the point. But specifically- cabd was being aggressive yesterday- doing the most for the town. Why shadi over him?

In my experience- the most protown players often is not.

You seriously trying to "too townie" here? Seriously?


Make sure your next post, in addition to containing a real case against me, if you have one, contains a role claim, because...

Intent to Hammer

[Klazam]

I'm vt.

My case is what i mentioned.

Also- i was aggressively tunneling one person and being utterly wrong about it. you were jumping on EVERYONE. I always put myself in scum's shoes, and from that POV, you're the threat, not me.

I keep on giving people free passes for being townie. i keep on being wrong. So i stop now.

Irishpope- your play itself is pretty mediocre. My play has been terrible, granted, but at least i dont have mafia theory entirely wrong like you.

[TheIrishPope]

I'm vt.

My case is what i mentioned.

Also- i was aggressively tunneling one person and being utterly wrong about it. you were jumping on EVERYONE. I always put myself in scum's shoes, and from that POV, you're the threat, not me.

I keep on giving people free passes for being townie. i keep on being wrong. So i stop now.

Irishpope- your play itself is pretty mediocre. My play has been terrible, granted, but at least i dont have mafia theory entirely wrong like you.

Great, policy lynch go go go
You admit to tunneling, which is what scum does, and agree that Cabd is being objective and looking at everyone, which is a towntell.
Tell me in what I am wrong. How is my play mediocre, if I have just found the scum?
Also, tell me who your scum partner is.

[Cabd]

I'll let everyone else evaluate klaz's case and claim before I hammer.

If anyone objects to this lynch, speak now.

[Klazam]

lol.

Tunneling is not a scumtell.

IMO, the best players i know all tunnel.

you have mafia theory terribly terribly wrong.

and im still town.

[Klazam]

Cabd
why are you delaying?

serious question?

is it because you want to be able to go BUT my hammer was sanctioned by everyone D3?

[Klazam]

One request.

upon my death- EVERyONE evaluate cabd's role in all this.

please.

[TheIrishPope]

I'll let everyone else evaluate klaz's case and claim before I hammer.

If anyone objects to this lynch, speak now.

I happily do not object to this lynch.

lol.

Tunneling is not a scumtell.

IMO, the best players i know all tunnel.

you have mafia theory terribly terribly wrong.

and im still town.

For me, tunneling is a scumtell.
You cannot use other player's playstyle to justify your own. There is a logical fallacy for that.

Appeal to authority: You said that because an authority thinks or does something, it must therefore be true or acceptable.

Point out what is wrong about my mafia theory.
Also, theory is irrelevant since you are scum.

Also, tell me who your scum partner is.

Still waiting on this.

[Klazam]

YOU FUCKING ROLEFISHED. THATS SO BAD.

I'm not appealing to authority there. I'm saying that my best "rolemodels" tunnel so im emulating that play style, because i sincerly believe that it works.

IM NOT SCUM.

[Cabd]

Serious answer, because we have 9 days left and there's no rush?

Last thing I want to happen is somebody has a huge post coming and they don't get to post it before day ends.

Do you have any idea how annoying that would be?

I'm hammering regardless, so no, I'm not particularly seeking out approval so much as allowing people to make a post prior.

[Klazam]

I accept that statement.

[TheIrishPope]

YOU FUCKING ROLEFISHED. THATS SO BAD.

I'm not appealing to authority there. I'm saying that my best "rolemodels" tunnel so im emulating that play style, because i sincerly believe that it works.

IM NOT SCUM.

I'm not liking your tone, Mister.
Rolemodels are authority to you. You follow their play. You have committed a logical fallacy, which is worthy of a lynch.
Yes, you are. Stop telling me lies. I ask one more time.
Who is your scum partner?

[Klazam]

i'm so pissed here.

lynch me if you want. theres nothing i can do anymore.

Just look deeply at cabd.

I think irish is just misguided

Laz is town

esquire is town

jmo is null

MM is scummish.

thats all, right?

[Cabd]

Irish please stop, you're asking the same pointless question over and over again. It's playing against his win con to answer that if scum, and pointless if he's townie. (Which I don't believe he is but yeah)


No matter what, you're not gonna get a truthful answer, so stop wasting your keystrokes.

[Klazam]

Cabd
Anyone

Any questions you want me to answer?