WWE Believe in the Shield

[PeregrineV]

I read the dead section and saw D1 killed, and figured that was the lynch.

No lynch day1?

2 scumteams, each on different game phases.

24 players, each team is 3 or 4, small chance of uneeven teams. Nice.

Any confirmed town?

Who was the almost-lynch for day1?

[Nexus]

Votecount 2.4:

MonkeyMan576 (6)-

Mac, Mutleyddmc, Ravenpaw, penguin_alien, ArcAngel9, The Goat

Mutleyddmc (1)-

MonkeyMan576

Darthe (1)-

xMALCOLMx

Jebus (1)-

ferretlover

Not voting (10)-

Jebus, Darthe, TheEsquire, PeregrineV, Desperado, Amethyst Actor, Fuzzyman, petapan, Nero Cain

Amethyst Actor has been prodded.

Searching for petapan and Fuzzyman replacements.

With 18 alive, it takes 9 to lynch. Day 2 will end at 8PM BST on Wednesday 5th June 2013.

[Nero Cain]

Yes, these Dumbo's no lynched on d1.

In the end our day 1 bolied down to it being a goat vs. mutley match. Basically Malcolm unvoted Mut and then a bunch of other players followed him onto Goat. Today rolls around and Despo was blaming Malcom for the unvote.

And apparently I'm not even voting for Desp so I need to fix that.

vote:Desp

[Desperado]

Yes, these Dumbo's no lynched on d1.

In the end our day 1 bolied down to it being a goat vs. mutley match. Basically Malcolm unvoted Mut and then a bunch of other players followed him onto Goat.

Today rolls around and Despo was blaming Malcom for the unvote.

And apparently I'm not even voting for Desp so I need to fix that.

vote:Desp

Which Malcolm has since claimed to have done on purpose. So why are you voting me for blaming someone for causing the NL when...they deliberately caused the NL?

[Nero Cain]

errr....that bolded unvote should be no lynch. ESQ, peta and Darthe were responsible for their own votes. Stop pretending like Malcolm was the biggest contributer 'cause he wasn't.

[Desperado]

errr....that bolded unvote should be no lynch. ESQ, peta and Darthe were responsible for their own votes. Stop pretending like Malcolm was the biggest contributer 'cause he wasn't.

Please tell me more about how we still have a NL if malcolm never unvotes. I've done more than enough to support my assertion that Malcolm is most to blame, while you've done nothing but scream NUH-UH!

[Nero Cain]

Mutleyddmc (9)- Desperado, Ravenpaw, MonkeyMan576, Amethyst Actor, penguin_alien, Skullduggery, The Goat, Nero Cain, Doctor C. Niall DeMencha

That was his day 1 wagon after Malcolm and Mut unvoted. 2 of Darthe, peta, esq and whatever morons were not voting could have easily hammered.

[Desperado]

Essentially he's saying "yeah Malcolm is scummy but it wasn't totally his fault and what about all these other people that let it happen, where was the town motivation there?" as if I disagree with him and didn't already say that myself. He just doesn't like us specifically lynching Malcolm over esquire, peta, and others because our assertion that malcolm is most responsible for the NL is "a load of bull (citation needed)" when, in my opinion, Malcolm is CLEARLY the most at fault for the NL when you consider that the Doctor hydra voted Mutley back to L-2 a whopping 50 minutes after Malcolm unvoted, and a mere 30 minutes after Mutley followed suit. Malcolm never unvotes, Mutley never has a reason to get off his own wagon after campaigning for his lynch, Demencha hammers mutley and this conversation never happens.

[Mac]

chaps, what are your thoughts on Monkey? (directed at Nero and Desp)

[Desperado]

chaps, what are your thoughts on Monkey? (directed at Nero and Desp)

I feel like I got linked to a game that he played where he flailed like this and was town. Let me see if I can find it.

[Desperado]

Yeah it was "you could be anyone mafia"

Here's his iso:

http://forum.mafiascum.net/viewtopic.ph ... er_sort=Go

Obviously I wasn't part of this game, and a read based solely on meta is inherently weak, but I just read that game like a week ago and the last couple pages reminded me so much of his reaction there that I didn't see anything worth pursuing.

My main issue with your case is that you think he's "scum feigning stupidity" but what was scumMonkey hoping to gain from that? What benefit did feigning ignorance pose for him?

[MonkeyMan576]

I did not fail. Mac is misrepping like OJ Simpson's laywers.

[Desperado]

Try =10332&user_select[]=0&user_select[]=0&user_sort=Go]this instead.

[Desperado]

God damnit.

http://forum.mafiascum.net/viewtopic.php?f=56&t=24130

@monkey: you are definitely flailing right now. Your "I didn't know, I was just speculating" retroactive rationalization is flail. Anyone paying even cursory attention to the thread and player deaths was already aware that SHIELD is responsible for the daykill. IMO there is no disputing that there's inconsistency between your first post-death post and your 2nd post-death post, I just don't think it's inherently scummy, and your reaction to the subsequent pressure has you leaning town for me.

[Nero Cain]

chaps, what are your thoughts on Monkey? (directed at Nero and Desp)

meh, I think Monkey says silly things regardless of alignment.

You have town read on despo?

[The Goat]

God damnit.

http://forum.mafiascum.net/viewtopic.php?f=56&t=24130

@monkey: you are definitely flailing right now. Your "I didn't know, I was just speculating" retroactive rationalization is flail. Anyone paying even cursory attention to the thread and player deaths was already aware that SHIELD is responsible for the daykill. IMO there is no disputing that there's inconsistency between your first post-death post and your 2nd post-death post, I just don't think it's inherently scummy, and

your reaction to the subsequent pressure has you leaning town for me.

Interesting. His reaction is one of the main reasons that my vote is still on him.

[Mutleyddmc]

Agree with the goat. I hated monkeymans reactions to it. I could have easily moved off it but his reactions for me have been worth the vote being kept on.

[MonkeyMan576]

Mutley, Arc, Raven, and Goat were all on my scum list before the wagon began. This is the most OMGUSy scum wagon I've ever seen. The fact that the rest of the players are letting them get away with it is atrocious.

[Mutleyddmc]

Except I wasn't to against you until the second day kill!

[Jebus]

Vote: PeregrineV

[xMALCOLMx]

Not gonna be back until tomortow.

[Mac]

Vote: PeregrineV

WHYYYYYYYY

seriously this needs lynched or vigged so bad. Fucking hell.

[ferretlover]

Jebus hasn't contributed anything this game.

I'm not sure if the above sentence is hypocritical or not

[Amethyst Actor]

Peregrine, it was Muttley who was the almost lynch, Muttley or Goat.

Now excuse me while dad tries to make sense about what you guys have been doing.

[Nero Cain]

Why is Mac not telling me his Despo read?