Xenoblade Mafia (Game Over)

[Cabd]

Errr... Mafia spy. Not traitor. Whatever the role is that appears town until converted into being a wolf.

[BeautyAndTheBeast]

5/15 isn't bad, but 14/3/3 is more likely IMO. Particularly with heavy PRs on all 3 sides. Expect an informative role on each scum team, plus a protective role for one, a roleblocker for another, maybe a strongman-type for each side, and a slew of PRs for town.

Multiball isn't *standard*, but it's pretty typical for larger games.

Balancing Multiball is actually a lot easier than you think. The only thing that sucks is being a mod who made a multiball game and watching town rip all the teams apart...

p-edit: if it's just one team, I would expect 5 scum, yeah.

[Cabd]

Interesting, but sadly we could speculate for hours and never get anywhere. Can you explain to me why you find rach town? I'm finding it very hard to read her and I really don't get why everyone finds her town with so few posts and so little content.

Also, if keyblade could answer my question that would be great.

Keyblade:

You have no opinion about Orc, Nacho, or 2?

Like, the three most active players?

[BeautyAndTheBeast]

Because Rach is an incredibly awkward scum and I'm not seeing awkwardness. I'm seeing someone who cares about the game and is trying to figure it out. That's TownRach, and she bleeds it when she's town.

[Cabd]

I guess I can see that, I dunno. I sucked at reading her in our newbie game too, I thought she was scum when she was town doc.

What do you mean by "awkward" though?

[Cabd]

Also, sorry if I missed it, but I remember reading you saying 2 made a huge scumslip. What exactly was it? I find 2 scummy for other reasons and to be honest I don't remember any major slip...

[Cabd]

Errr... by you I mean your slot, I dunno which head.... Yeesh hydra's are confusing sometimes.

[Andrius]

Babe I'm ok with lynching Andy if you're still feeling it. I could compile a fairly strong case.

Let me guess:
1) Not posting as frequently as he does in other games
2) Not being as useful as he is in other games
3) Sheeping Nacho moreso than in other games
4) Not doing his own individual thinking as much as he should
5) "Flirting" with mollie (or being REALLY condescending, depending on how you take my post)
6) "Lurking"
7) Thinking TD is town because she provided reasoning for one of her votes
8) Thinking that BROseidon is scum and then changing my mind after Nacho prompted a relook

In other news, I just made it to Eryth Sea. I forgot how beautiful this place is.

[Metal Sonic]

read half an hour ago


half an hour later i forgot what i wanted to post


i just have a message for 2

buldermar, please dont be prejudiced and denounce me scum

even your partner does not have such strong feelings, ffery could you help me a bit here to explain to b thanks

[borkjerfkin]

In other news, I just made it to Eryth Sea. I forgot how beautiful this place is.

Damn you are truckin' along

[²]

Haven't paid much attention to Orc or 2,, but Nacho literally always plays the same from what Ive seen. So nulln o him

He's way more dedicated to this game than what I'm used to. How far are you in your read?

- b

he was pretty dedicated in pj

Well why don't you ask him of his opinion, then?

- b

[²]

I also strongly feel this is multiball. Mollie is still unsure.

I could see it going either way, not like it matters this early on.

I actually think it especially matters this early on. Multiball allows for scum to do legitimate scum hunting, which in turn makes it more difficult for town to identify scum.

- b

[²]

If an SK exists, it's Nacho. But Nacho seems pretty towny, so I'm leaning towards two teams of 3.

I'm pretty sure f would have picked up on Nacho being a SK and I feel like I would too.

- b

[²]

Personal modding experience on sites not named mafiascum.

Usually 20 man games are 5/15 (or 4/16 if scum has super good power roles) from everything I've seen before.
But like I said, I'm much newer to the site than the rest of you, for all I know multiball is the standard here. From a mod POV I just find multiball so hard to balance properly, it's a nightmare.

Your personal experience may not translate very well that of others. I wouldn't say that multiball is standard here, but it is not unheard of.

- b

[²]

i just have a message for 2

buldermar, please dont be prejudiced and denounce me scum

even your partner does not have such strong feelings, ffery could you help me a bit here to explain to b thanks

Show me an example of a game in which you pretended to have read pages you didn't actually read and made up reads you couldn't actually have had at the time as town.

- b

[Metal Sonic]

b

show me an example of a game in which I have played that has 2240 posts within the first week.


we adjust to the times bro! you cant meta like that, its unfair comparison

[²]

Why were you acting as if you had read the pages that you clearly had not read?

- b

[BeautyAndTheBeast]

If an SK exists, it's Nacho. But Nacho seems pretty towny, so I'm leaning towards two teams of 3.

I don't think so. multi-ball has a distinct feel to it and this isn't it. if it is I would be surprised.

[BeautyAndTheBeast]

I thought she was scum when she was town doc.

Do you have any idea how many games this describes?

By awkward I mean she stumbles all over herself and generally makes herself obvscum.
And the scumslip must have been Mollie's half.

Babe I'm ok with lynching Andy if you're still feeling it. I could compile a fairly strong case.

Let me guess:
1) Not posting as frequently as he does in other games
2) Not being as useful as he is in other games
3) Sheeping Nacho moreso than in other games
4) Not doing his own individual thinking as much as he should
5) "Flirting" with mollie (or being REALLY condescending, depending on how you take my post)
6) "Lurking"
7) Thinking TD is town because she provided reasoning for one of her votes
8) Thinking that BROseidon is scum and then changing my mind after Nacho prompted a relook

In other news, I just made it to Eryth Sea. I forgot how beautiful this place is.

1) Nope.
2) Nope.
3) Nope.
4) Nope.
5) Nope.
6) Nope.
7) Nope.
8) Nope.

If an SK exists, it's Nacho. But Nacho seems pretty towny, so I'm leaning towards two teams of 3.

I'm pretty sure f would have picked up on Nacho being a SK and I feel like I would too.

- b

You should read the second sentence you quoted there.

b

show me an example of a game in which I have played that has 2240 posts within the first week.

we adjust to the times bro! you cant meta like that, its unfair comparison

Are you admitting that you actively lied about reading? Because that's what this looks like.

[²]

You should read the second sentence you quoted there.

If an SK exists, it isn't Nacho, which is what you suggested. Why should I read the second sentence when it's not relevant?

- b

[²]

Are you admitting that you actively lied about reading? Because that's what this looks like.

Please don't interfere with my scumhunting.

- b

[BeautyAndTheBeast]

You should read the second sentence you quoted there.

If an SK exists, it isn't Nacho, which is what you suggested. Why should I read the second sentence when it's not relevant?

- b

Because... it is relevant?

Herp derp?

Are you admitting that you actively lied about reading? Because that's what this looks like.

Please don't interfere with my scumhunting.

- b

Are you fucking kidding me right now with this?

[BeautyAndTheBeast]

Babe I'm ok with lynching Andy if you're still feeling it. I could compile a fairly strong case.

Let me guess:
1) Not posting as frequently as he does in other games
2) Not being as useful as he is in other games
3) Sheeping Nacho moreso than in other games
4) Not doing his own individual thinking as much as he should
5) "Flirting" with mollie (or being REALLY condescending, depending on how you take my post)
6) "Lurking"
7) Thinking TD is town because she provided reasoning for one of her votes
8) Thinking that BROseidon is scum and then changing my mind after Nacho prompted a relook

In other news, I just made it to Eryth Sea. I forgot how beautiful this place is.

hi andy

hi

I was wondering when you would get around to talking to me

cos I want to talk to you

so let's chat and enjoy a sunny day well I am just loving this breeze what do you think. let's get close. let's get real close. like I want you to push my limits.

fwiw I didn't think you were being condescending. oh and I don't like tea that is why I am drinking an iced latte. so what do you think of my posts so far? what did you think of that big long one I made to varsoon? it was kinda nice doncha think? I think I have some good points in there. so are you going to sheep nacho? what do you think of my list of 2 and aj? if 1 of them is scum why would you want to lynch off of varsoon's list? cos didn't you like that post I made about the head before the ass? so why are you wanting to munch on the ass?

I will sit here while you go inside and grab answers for that. I will wait for you. I will wait.

[BeautyAndTheBeast]

You should read the second sentence you quoted there.

If an SK exists, it isn't Nacho, which is what you suggested. Why should I read the second sentence when it's not relevant?

- b

Because... it is relevant?

Herp derp?

Are you admitting that you actively lied about reading? Because that's what this looks like.

Please don't interfere with my scumhunting.

- b

Are you fucking kidding me right now with this?

^trolled

[²]

Because... it is relevant?

Herp derp?

No, because Nacho can't simultanously be SK and town.

- b