Open 500 - Popcorn Mafia: Game Over!

[Wisdom]

What reaction test are you talking about?

[Fegelein]

The one where I pretended to be drunk.

[Human Destroyer]

Mod Note

Bert has been prodded.

[Wisdom]

The one where I pretended to be drunk.

And why did he get a townread from that?

[Fegelein]

I just liked his reaction to it.

[Wisdom]

And that meant he's town?

[Fegelein]

As I said, it was a weak town read.

[TheIrishPope]

I'm thinking Wisdom is scum...
Shoot me? Seriously? The guy who has made the most posts after you?
Anyway, if you want to see my scum game, view my first game here

[Wisdom]

What? When did I say that they shoot you?

[Wisdom]

And how is postcount of any importance btw? I am usually the top poster as town and as scum alike.

[Wisdom]

What? When did I say that they shoot you?

should*

[TheIrishPope]

Talking to Oil, sorry
I'm just saying that he should reconsider his target.

[Wisdom]

Oh, the way you said it was like the first sentence was explained in the second one

[Wisdom]

Why do you think I'm scum then?

[TheIrishPope]

Why me?

Between these three, who would you shoot, Bert? Me?

wut, how am I ignoring you?

huh? I wasted your time with mollie? How so?

Why am I out of your list again and feg back in?

I have seen this and used this as scum; you are self-aware. Very self-aware. You worry too much on your image. "Why me why me" "I did X I did Y" and your posts are really fluffy. I just can't see you as logical Town.

Bonus

Good catch

Subtle post to get me to like you and have a town read on you.

[Wisdom]

464 actually asks why I am

out

of a scumlist, so it doesn't really belong there, does it?

On a more serious note, that's how I play. My ego is big. Doesn't have anything to do with my alignment.

[Wisdom]

Actually only 89 fits what you're trying to say.
199 tries to understand Bert's thought process just after he gave his scumreads.
346 and 353 I'm trying to communicate with Nacho and understand what he's saying.
464 explained in above post.

As for the good catch, I really thought it was a good catch. I had no need to buddy you anyways since you were not suspecting me.

[Kerberos]

w.
o.
w.
there is really no need for name calling.

anyways. i just gave you a list that could give us up to an 80% chance of hitting scum. i think thats a pretty good contribution.

Care to explain this? This post raises red flags for me. How do you justify your list a good contribution? Your list is:

how many hydras do we have here? and when did this hydra fad start?

why is anyone worried about losing oil? they have a 40% chance of hitting scum if they fire blind. this set-up is intensely pro-town. a misfire only confirms another townie. how many successful day 1 lynches have any of you ever seen anyway?

heres where i would fire:

JacobSavage
ArcAngel9
Kerberos
borkjerfkin
Fegelein

did i miss anything?

You didn't explain your names. You just put all five in order. How about an order of priority at the moment of who you would shoot?

Nacho, if you are looking for a person who knows you, does DJ know you?

i am vaguely familiar with two names on the player list from shockingly recent games. are there any alts in the mix who i may know?

He opens with the above post, as if he isn't aware of who he signed up to play with.

hi marangal. you are the head i trust. please discourage mollie from posting whenever possible.

And he implies that he has prior experience with mollie and wants to discourage her from posting.

I'm also against his idea of giving up a confirmed townie to shoot a confirmed hydra, just for the sake of shooting a trio. I take issue with that.

Bert is defs town for this

Wait...

is that Nacho, and is he reading Science as scum?

FFS

No, that was me.

that's good, because that Science scum-read is shit IMO

and I think that, when Mala comes in and finds time to post here, Syry will finally get his bearings straight and realize that the three of us aren't scum.

I'm glad Mollie can tell the difference between you guys though cuz I can't tell for shizz other then when you guys give reads... I think

DJ feels off to me, not only does he try to get me to keep Mollie from posting, but he specifically appeals to me stating that he trusts me. Like he's trying to divide the three heads or something

not only that, but his reaction to Borky looks weird and a few posts after stating that he trusts me, he states that he would shoot us not because we are scum but because we are a hydra... I still don't understand the mindset behind trading one hydra for another

His reaction to TIP in 247 is odd as fuck and to me, He takes offense to being called an Idiot even though he's called everyone else an idiot twice. Not only does he take offense though, he's trying to make it like it doesn't bother him at all when clearly, it does.

Wisdom, Yes I do think Science caring about the gun-bearer's survival is coming from a town mind-set. His threats... Meh, it's iffy for me though other things he has done is townish

on page 15 and OMG, science is sooo town

and if I see another person use AtE as a scum-tell I will bash their head into a wall. No joke.

not sure if I can get on board with Feg's reaction test... the test itself looks townish, though how he used it to implicate Science rings alarms for me

TIP and Science can stop fighting now though, all it does is add noise

Wisdom, I'm wrong in the sense that you called out TIP and Science for all their flaws though I've been skimming and that's the initial impression I've been getting from you.

You aren't taking a stance though which is odd because I have seen town wisdom take stances early on in the game. I am scum reading you for calling people out for Anti-town over scummy actions and for leeching off of other peoples reasons when making your arguments. The only thing that was your own was your little argument with Fege and starting up the conversation with me. Nothing you are doing reminds me of town Wisdom in the slightest

[Wisdom]

Except there's no such thing as town Wisdom; I'm tired of hearing things like that.

[Wisdom]

DJ feels off to me, not only does he try to get me to keep Mollie from posting,

I lol'd at this, btw. Looks like you don't know a joke when you see it.

[TheIrishPope]

ATE IS A SCUMTELL LOLOLOL
Anyway, Wisdom, you were calling NS out for saying "it's how I play". And now you do the same. Not cool.

[Wisdom]

I don't really recall doing that, can you quote it?

[notscience]

He didn't call me out for it, it was more a "not all town looks up how people play."

[Wisdom]

That I do recall.

[Bert]

Posting here. I'm here, waiting for my eye pain to get a little better so I can review more of this game again to get an even better feel. I did manage to read through the past two pages of activity this morning, so I am caught up. The other day before this, I looked back at the two past Popcorn Mafia games. I had no idea that people could give lists of scum reads and town reads in order based on feeling, without lots of explanation. I've always been afraid to give lists for fear of not having adequate explanation. I always thought my scum reads cannot change, so once I say it, I can't change who I think is scummy. My bad.

And from reading through the past two pages, I'm getting a strong town read on Kerberos and a scum read on Wisdom. It sucks because it's hard to put into words why I think Wisdom is scum, as I alluded to a few pages back. Null/leaning town on TIP. He posts a freakin ton but I don't really think it's scum-posting. It's just so tunneled the way he is going after notscience, and yet that makes me think he's town because it's so blatant? Don Johnson - I'm stubborn still think he is scum for that 80% comment and trying to say his contribution is worth more than it really is. I think notscience is town now. Way too overreactive like a semi-experienced yet newbtown and that's town to me at this point. If notscience were in her/his first game in a newbie, I'd think she's definitely town. But for now I place her in my town reads pile. Arcangel is such an inactive here, and I think it's on purpose. I'm not even allowed to say why, but I did glance at her past activity. I think she's scum for that BS excuse on the 28th. Why she isn't caught up now is beyond me. She's going to refute that, but I won't believe her. Bork I have no idea honestly, but I am worried about him/her after one of the Kerberos hydras said that she has misread Bork before and it almost cost them. That worries me, and since I’m sorta inexperienced I feel like I’m not qualified to really read that person and give a good opinion because I fear being wrong. Sad but true :/ Fegelein’s reaction test gave me a gut town feeling. That was really gutty and took a lot of spunk to do IMHO.
I don’t like the tone of Jacob’s last post. People are saying he’s an easy target. The thing is he knows he’s an easy target and still won’t post worth a flip. I’m on the fence about that right now.

So Scum - Wisdom, ArcAngel, DonJohnson.
Not sure/confused about my read: Jacob, Bork
Leaning Town – TIP, not science, Fegelein
Strong Town – Kerberos