Harry Potter and the Philosopher's Stone Mafia Game Over

[DeasVail]

Don't do it Mhork! D:

[DeasVail]

Also I'm actually starting to think Jake might be town (please don't use this against me saying I'm trying to avoid OMGUS claims because that's something I'd never do), but I will get back to you later.

[Jake from State Farm]

post 16 - no scum would be dumb to say
I like what he was trying to say in 39, though it didn't really come out how I think he wanted to. Any attempt to move a game form RVS to serious is always welcome as I hate RVS
post 60 read town to me also

he has a spattering of posts that come off abrasive at times and that reads to me as town.

@ deas - why the bad reactions to just 1 person? if you are town it doesn't help your situation. If you are scum, by all means carry on.

[Jake from State Farm]

here I will give you a chance to prove to me you are town.

please explain to me the thought process behind post 43, because fmpov, I can't possibly see anything pro-town about that one post.

[DeasVail]

I don't understand your question about the bad reactions.

On 43, that was because Saint had originally voted for AA for a pseudo-serious reason, but then voted SD for OMGUS, which is the equivalent of a RV as far as I'm concerned, so I was wondering why he change his pseudo-serious vote from AA to to the perhaps non-serious vote on SD (If it was serious then that's another problem entirely). The possibility that it was a reaction to him being accused of reaching did cross my mind.

[Lord Mhork]

But there's his post where he quotes DV and says arcangel is town...

[DeasVail]

That doesn't seem very scum-motivated?

[Lord Mhork]

But it's a lie he refuses to acknowledge

[fuzzybutternut]

Lying=\=scum

[Lord Mhork]

It's scummy when there's no reason to lie and he ignores the fact that he did.

[Nexus]

“The truth. It is a beautiful and terrible thing, and should therefore be treated with great caution.” - Albus Dumbledore

Votecount 1.4:

Saint (3)-

Lord Mhork, penguin_alien, SafetyDance

TMTOLBTWNTOF (3)-

DoctorPepper, Ghostlin, Saint

DeasVail (2)-

ArcAngel9, Jake from State Farm

penguin_alien (1)-

BROseidon

Lord Mhork (1)-

DeasVail

Ghostlin (1)-

fuzzybutternut

BROseidon (1)-

Mac

Not Voting (1)-

TMTOLBTWNTOF

With 13 alive, it takes 7 to lynch. Day 1 will end at 7am BST on Wednesday 12th June 2013.

DoctorPepper is v/la until 5th June

Rule 0 is a guide - I will tell you if I think you're close to breaking it.

[Saint]

i realized i did that and if you notice i have them both listed as town

[Saint]

So, safetyDance, considering your shitty vote is pretty RVS worthy, you've attacked mhork for self meta-ing onto me (which was complete and utter trashtier play) why is your vote still on me? other than the fact you've been doing shit-all this game

[Saint]

mhork is really beating a dead horse here
i wonder if he will actually get around to hunting scum, or if he's content sitting on his thumb

[Saint]

mhork my read on aa came from page 12
when i realized what i did i put deasvail at the top of my town list, if youll notice... let me find the post...
i quote the same post twice... i guess the fact i thought AA made a post I later realized Deasvail made removes AA from my list of who I think is town
it was an honest mistake i dont think scum would make, especially if one of them flips scum
i dont normally humor useless tunnelers, but you're starting to annoy me to the point that i dont even care who my character is

[Saint]

you know what, i'm going with a policy vote policy of being a hypocritical village idiot. plus deasvail my strongest townread is voting him. plus im not going to be 3rd/4th voter and commit a jeep tell if he does flip town, which, if he isn't a townie idiot he's scum. it's pretty much 50% townie 50% scum from mhork at this point in my eyes, and i really dont care to lose him if he's either, if he's going to continously tunnel on me and hinder us later on, OR EVEN WORSE GET A WAGON ON ME

unvote;
vote: lord_mhork

[Saint]

unvote;
vote: deasvail

[Saint]

VOTE: vote: deasvail

[Saint]

explanation of #43 falling way short
i thought the reasoning would be this: rxn test
reasoning given is reaching. from top of town to bottom of scum, all off of jake's questioning
this is why mafia is a beautiful game
mhork still sucks

[fuzzybutternut]

...Saint wtf are you doing?

[Lord Mhork]

i realized i did that and if you notice i have them both listed as town

You're just making things up though. You still haven't justified your ArcAngel read apart from 'he's town.'

mhork is really beating a dead horse here
i wonder if he will actually get around to hunting scum, or if he's content sitting on his thumb

I'm hunting scum right now, jackass.

you know what, i'm going with a policy vote policy of being a hypocritical village idiot. plus deasvail my strongest townread is voting him. plus im not going to be 3rd/4th voter and commit a jeep tell if he does flip town, which, if he isn't a townie idiot he's scum. it's pretty much 50% townie 50% scum from mhork at this point in my eyes, and i really dont care to lose him if he's either, if he's going to continously tunnel on me and hinder us later on, OR EVEN WORSE GET A WAGON ON ME

unvote;
vote: lord_mhork

Fuck off you fucking fuckface. You haven't provided one shred of evidence against me. What is my hypocrisy? What am I doing that's bad? What is scummy about me? Is it because I'm attacking you? Is because I'm perceiving things you're doing as scummy? Those aren't scumtells. And I'm going to keep tunneling you until you prove me wrong and start acting townie. Fuck off or get it together.

VOTE: vote: deasvail

Can we please lynch this? Someone give me one good case for why he's town apart from "I feel towniness" or "Scum wouldn't be this blatant."

...Saint wtf are you doing?

He's being a fuckhead. You should help me lynch him.

[DeasVail]

I think I'm going to cry.

[Lord Mhork]

Also I'm totally going to keep tunneling Saint until someone proves me wrong or he actually starts doing things. Then someone can try and sell me on the DeasVail case.

[DeasVail]

Weak Town:

Fuzzy
BROseidon
SafetyDance

Not a townread:

Penguin
Mac

Scumreads:

Lord Mhork- He might be too aggressive to be scum (although Puppy's eyes reveals he can at least be abrasive), but I stand by my original point, and also the fact that his complaints about AtE from Saint don't seem quite right considering that I think he's AtE'd himself as town before. He later said that it was because it was instead of a defence, but the original accusations didn't say anything about that and were instead just implying that AtE was a bad scummy thing.

Other:

ArcAngel9- When she's town, she's usually pretty obvtown, so I'll wait for that to happen, and if it doesn't we can lynch her in a couple of days.
Jake- I'm still not sure. ~Feelings~ keep getting in the way. I just completely disagree with the reasoning he uses and... the whole OMGUS and modkill things are just so weird! Could you link me to a game where you behave similar to this. Also, what caused the change in opinion from this post?

I'll do the rest tomorrow.

[Jake from State Farm]

I don't understand your question about the bad reactions.

On 43, that was because Saint had originally voted for AA for a pseudo-serious reason, but then voted SD for OMGUS, which is the equivalent of a RV as far as I'm concerned, so I was wondering why he change his pseudo-serious vote from AA to to the perhaps non-serious vote on SD (If it was serious then that's another problem entirely). The possibility that it was a reaction to him being accused of reaching did cross my mind.

but he didn't really have a pseudo serious reason, he said so in post 39. Saint also said the next person who voted him, was going to get voted and he did exactly that.

the fact that you asked why he voted SD over AA when that info was available to you in the thread is quite suspicious, at the least it shows poor reading skills which is inherently anti-town.