WWE Believe in the Shield

[pidgey]

AP

MY

HOMIEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEE

Damn this game just got better but you are town right

[pidgey]

because im town like a mo fo

[Mac]

mastin what is your Monkey read? what did you make of my reason for wagoning him? (for which, you found me scummy...?)

My read on Monkey is town. It's admittedly not as strong of a townread as I would prefer (again, not having read the game, difficult to say for certain), but I definitely think he's town, and did not like the wagon on him at all.

I don't really remember your reasoning for thinking Monkey was scum, but I remember it either being unimpressive or leaving an impression--of you being scum wanting a mislynch. (Would have to check back to see which.)

2026 and 2028 were the crux of it.

what made you feel it was scum wanting a mislynch rather than town thinking they had caught scum?

[AngryPidgeon]

Damn this game just got better but you are town right

Im always town.

Except when I get back late at night and I see this post and I'm like 'oh fuck, oh fuck, I was so close'

I was seriously going to make a post but didn't at that point because I was so emotionally compromised.

[Nero Cain]

Also, *insert comparison between AP calling his slot town and Darthe calling his slot town*.

but I don't feel like he did. Why would town need to give a list that *shows* how my slot was compared to him?

[pidgey]

Hey so you find penguin to be scummy so that's cool, but exactly why, AP?

[AngryPidgeon]

Well I barely skimmed Darthe and I barely skimmed her.

She uses a lot of weak precursors for her opinions 'seems', 'feels like', etc and IIoA in general. My reads are all pretty weak considering I haven't read at all, but Id rather lynch her than Darthe. And < 1 day to go.

[mastin2]

mastin what is your Monkey read? what did you make of my reason for wagoning him? (for which, you found me scummy...?)

My read on Monkey is town. It's admittedly not as strong of a townread as I would prefer (again, not having read the game, difficult to say for certain), but I definitely think he's town, and did not like the wagon on him at all.

I don't really remember your reasoning for thinking Monkey was scum, but I remember it either being unimpressive or leaving an impression--of you being scum wanting a mislynch. (Would have to check back to see which.)

2026 and 2028 were the crux of it.

Those two actually show remarkable consistency.

And, hey. I didn't know the daykill was scum. Granted, replacement, not enough time to read the flavor which apparently makes it clear the daykill is scum to the point of being obvious, but I can very easily see town making the posts you describe as being faked.

Give me more, because that aint enough to sell him as scum to me in a million years.

[pidgey]

thumbs up for joining in our first scum lynch of the game then

[pidgey]

swear you are not scum btw

[AngryPidgeon]

mastin, do you have any compelling reason to think Nero is town?

p-edit: I swear Im actually town this time. And I know Im a sneaky scumbutt that no one wants to trust nowadays ><

[pidgey]

Darthe is still probably scum, btw.

The thing about putting his own slot on a list and the character claim are both really bad.

But i trust penguin lynch more.

[Nero Cain]

Nero is town 'cause I'm not being lurky you stupid bird

[pidgey]

my fav people suddenly got together. I only need swords in here.

[AngryPidgeon]

mutleyddmc is a suspicious person (after having read one of his posts lol)

[Mac]

mastin what is your Monkey read? what did you make of my reason for wagoning him? (for which, you found me scummy...?)

My read on Monkey is town. It's admittedly not as strong of a townread as I would prefer (again, not having read the game, difficult to say for certain), but I definitely think he's town, and did not like the wagon on him at all.

I don't really remember your reasoning for thinking Monkey was scum, but I remember it either being unimpressive or leaving an impression--of you being scum wanting a mislynch. (Would have to check back to see which.)

2026 and 2028 were the crux of it.

Those two actually show remarkable consistency.

And, hey. I didn't know the daykill was scum. Granted, replacement, not enough time to read the flavor which apparently makes it clear the daykill is scum to the point of being obvious, but I can very easily see town making the posts you describe as being faked.

Give me more, because that aint enough to sell him as scum to me in a million years.

no I'm not asking you to believe the case

right now

, I'm happy with penguin at the moment, but I'm asking you to appreciate that I had legit reasons for suspecting Monkey rather than me just find the top two wagons to be scummy for no reasons. Although I do wonder how you feel town would make posts like those.because I don't see it.

[AngryPidgeon]

Oh lol PA replaced Squidward? I had him in my 'leazy looking posts' category, so this lynch is doubly awesome.

[AngryPidgeon]

sleazy*

[Rubicon]

Even if you think my logic is wrong, I have that immensely-strong gut townread on him, and that's not something you should ignore.

This is the only part of your list that would make me second guess Darthe being scum.

-The composition of the wagon is crap, and the reasons for wanting him lynched are worse than the reasons I've presented for keeping him alive.

You're definitely right that the wagon looks like 30% scum to me, but this is multiball. If anything, that should tell you that one of the teams believes Darthe is scum.

[pidgey]

AP thoughts on

http://forum.mafiascum.net/viewtopic.ph ... 3#p5009993
and
http://forum.mafiascum.net/viewtopic.ph ... 0#p5012240

[AngryPidgeon]

I dont see anything scummy in Darthe's list. (Not to be a broken record, but I really haven't read)

If anything I'd say likely town for being dumb and putting other people as townier than his slot.

I feel like I need context for the Mac vote that I am missing.

[Mac]

I have asked twice but he's done a runner

[Rubicon]

The thing about Darthe's post is it looks a LOT like he was given a safe flavor claim but not a safe PR claim. Thoughts, mastin? Talk me out of it and I'll vote penguin.

(I'm vaguely concerned I might be TRIPLE POWERBOMBED for this post, but meh.)

[Rubicon]

and the disappearing act

town motive for that, mastin?

[AngryPidgeon]

^ I'd triple power bomb you for that post.