Harry Potter and the Philosopher's Stone Mafia Game Over

[Amrun]

K you're dumb

No. Especially because I've already posted at least one example.

[RachMarie]

Amrun do you have links for town and scum games for Saint?


I cant wait til I get my new computer too its on my Amazon wishlist ♥ And of course get a hearing aid too/

[Ghostlin]

ArcAngel9, why aren't you posting here? This seems like a game you'd be all over if you're tow

I have been sick and away site wide..
are you scum?

What's the purpose of this? I understand you've been sick, but it's been PAGES since you last said something. I'd imagine if you're here to post, you'd have SOMETHING TO SAY.

Also, Jake: why did you ask Amrun about her Town read on me, but you won't push fuzzy on why I'm scum? Particularly since Amrun did the homework and fuzzy could be pulling it out of his butt, for all you know; particularly since last read post you read me as 'null'.

[Ghostlin]

Nothing I find suspicious, no. My reactions with you show me you're town. Saint is also town.
I'd like to hear more from CDB.

Amrun is likely town.
TMT is scum
Ghostlin is scum.

I'm not scum >.<
Blasted replacements.... Catching up

Said every scum replacement, ever.

*SCOWLS* This stinks under progression of reads. I mean, really fucking

stinks.

[penguin_alien]

ArcAngel9, why aren't you posting here? This seems like a game you'd be all over if you're tow

I have been sick and away site wide..
are you scum?

I'm not scum. You? Why not post V/LA if you're V/LA?

Ghostlin town

Can we talk about this read, because I disagree.

You're asking to talk about a read but not kicking things off. You've been mentioning he's a scum read, but the most you've said about why is:

I don't like Ghost's vote for letters and subsequent only commenting on the modkill thing. Do like his earning votes point, though

and not addressing anything he's done since. It reads like you're trying to get others to make a case for you or give you something to attack.

Saint seems to be scum hunting more, and the last time I played with someone who was so abrasive they did turn out to be town.

UNVOTE: Saint
VOTE: BROseidon

Do you have some reason to think that RachMarie is scummy? The chattiness seems more null to me.

[ChannelDelibird]

CDB, I asked you a question and you didn't answer it. IS THE SHEET STILL ON YOUR HEAD?!

http://forum.mafiascum.net/viewtopic.ph ... 4#p5010614

Ghostlin town

Why?

[ChannelDelibird]

Mhork, I've already mentioned part of why I think Saint is town in the post you quoted - his first post started off on a town foot. Ever since that, I've been unsettled by the votes that have gone his way - as well as yours, penguin_alien's #13 was not a good vote. Ghostlin's #59 wasn't great, either, and makes him look slow on the uptake when you compare it to the post I pointed out before where he unilaterally declares Saint town. I definitely didn't buy that you could have been ready to lynch Saint in #69, as well. He may know it a bit too much but Saint seems fairly clear town to me and there are so many other better avenues to explore that it feels absurd.

BRO - 'k.

This isn't a case for towniness though. I say he needs pressure, especially after the way he reacted earlier. He flipped a shit about three votes. Why was my vote bad? Penguin might have been sketch, but still...

It is a case for towniness. He looked town early on, scummy people are attacking him. I've already explained why your vote is bad but I may go back and find it for you a bit later when it's not 7am.

And who says that I was ready to lynch Saint?

PEdit:
So... Uh... I'd be cool lynching this thing...

[ChannelDelibird]

#429 looks pretty town.

[Saint]

I slept over 30 hours yesterday. Post-meet exhaustion. I am always scarce on weekends but I'll attempt to keep catching up tonight.

how can you sleep over 30 hours in a day

LAL

LYNCH AMRUN

haha jk... but really... you slept a day and a quarter? I mean, I sleep half a day, but for real... 30 hours? that's crazy. you might want to look into that.

[Saint]

I would be okay with a Rach or Ghost lynch at this point, honestly.

Would not lynch DV/p_a/CDB/FBN/Saint.

this list is what i've worked out as town, for the most part

am really liking your reads... if i had a hat on, i would tip it

hi five

[Saint]

Saint, can you please try to keep your thoughts in one post? maybe just spoil it or something. It creates useless page clutter.

quit being a baby

but yeah, i will

[Saint]

Thanks Amrun

Hi

Jake - who are you referring to as fakeclaiming on D1, and getting policy lynched?

Waiting on DeasVail to answer CDB before I continue scumhunting... don't want to stir the pot or spotlight at this point... sorry to spam, y'all... mike n mike in the morning -> bed -> lynch rachmarie -> steal underpants -> ??? -> profit

[ChannelDelibird]

Pretty sure DeasVail did answer me.

[Jake from State Farm]

I was referring to furclow

[Amrun]

rach, I dont have meta on him as Saint. As furcolow, I do, but the only one I remember is the one U pick we were in as one of my first games. We were scum together, but I replaced in at the end of Day 1 in ehich he was lymched with great prejudice. he was obvscum, tbf. we won the game anyway, though. We have played together plenty of times, but my wiki is not up tk date because i uldated it pre-crash amd them thr togers ate it so i said fuck this shit. The game I mentioned is still there, though.

CDB, I asked you a question and you didn't answer it. IS THE SHEET STILL ON YOUR HEAD?!

http://forum.mafiascum.net/viewtopic.ph ... 4#p5010614

Ghostlin town

Why?

CDB, I didn't know that was an answer because it lacked a comma. I thought you were saying you needed to see
More of me before commenting on my alignment.

Either way, that's a pitiful answer to that question. You said Ghost looking for a universal reason to call Saint town was scummy. I asked you why. You can't possibly need more time to evaluate that; you've already said it is scummy.

I slept over 30 hours yesterday. Post-meet exhaustion. I am always scarce on weekends but I'll attempt to keep catching up tonight.

how can you sleep over 30 hours in a day

LAL

LYNCH AMRUN

haha jk... but really... you slept a day and a quarter? I mean, I sleep half a day, but for real... 30 hours? that's crazy. you might want to look into that.

I actually meant 20 hours. But really if you count amount of time slept after midnight too, it's still 30. I just got back from a meet and was tired as fuck.

[Amrun]

I second Jake detailing his read on Ghostlin because its weird to have him as null and then go "why do you read him as town?"

[BROseidon]

Do you have some reason to think that RachMarie is scummy? The chattiness seems more null to me.

Go read Popcorn Mafia that Rach is in, versus one of her town games.

She tends to be more hesitant giving reads when she's scum.

[ChannelDelibird]

CDB, I didn't know that was an answer because it lacked a comma. I thought you were saying you needed to see
More of me before commenting on my alignment.

Either way, that's a pitiful answer to that question. You said Ghost looking for a universal reason to call Saint town was scummy. I asked you why. You can't possibly need more time to evaluate that; you've already said it is scummy.

I actually don't know what you're trying to say here. I did put you in the 'needs to post more before I can judge alignment' category but what does that have to do with my answer to you (I'm not asking as an accusation, I'm just confused)? What have I said about needing more time to evaluate my point about Ghostlin? I've explained my thought process as best I can. If Ghostlin is scum, he doesn't need to put in the effort to read Saint thoroughly in order to know that he is town. I think his cheap catch-all reason for Saint being scum is the sort of thing that people who've only glanced at Saint rather than actually tried to read him properly would say.

[Amrun]

That's the answer I was looking for and I get what you're saying now.

[Amrun]

For the record, I disagree that Ghostlin was doing that and that it's especially scummy. I don't really see scum looking to clear controversial town for generic reasons that often. If a scum needed to clear a town, I see that being a reasonably scummy way to do it, but I don't see the scum motivation for doing that in the first place.

[Jake from State Farm]

I second Jake detailing his read on Ghostlin because its weird to have him as null and then go "why do you read him as town?"

I'm slow. This is directed at me? If yes, I never saw anyone ask me to clarify anything.

[Amrun]

Ghostlin did.

[Jake from State Farm]

I'll find it when I get to my computer but I didn't have ghostin as null.

[Jake from State Farm]

particularly since last read post you read me as 'null'.

Please provide a link to where you think this happened please, because I guarantee you I never called you "null"

post 200 - I say you are on my FOS list
post 382 - I say I am suspicious of ghostlin

so yeah

the question is invalid, cause I never had a null or town read.

but let's play devil's advocte here, even if I did have a null read on him, there is nothing wrong with asking someone who has a town read on them to explain it. Null means unsure, in order to become more sure you need to see what others who are town reading that person has to say.

Also @ Amrun, I appreciate it if you don't call me dumb in the future.

Thank you

[Amrun]

Yes, that's true -- but IF you had said null (and I was assuming you had, didn't check), then you should be equally inquiring about both sides of the read. But you didn't say null so it's a moot point. Apologies.

As for calling you dumb, I didn't mean it personally, but I find that kind of rich considering how rude you were to DV especially. But sorry if it offended you; I didn't mean it to.