Open 503 - POLYGAMY IS EVIL. GAME OVER

[Wisdom]

Then you didn't understand what I said, in which case you have to reread.

[Core_H86]

simple math 12 players 7 needed to lynch you telling me 7 townies are going to be the only ones involved in a D1 mislynch?
PE: will reread..

[Wisdom]

No, scum are going to vote too. The thing is we WONT get a lynch before we determine things. Scum are not just going to quickhammer.

[Core_H86]

ok I did misread your post but still prefer all claiming for more available info. scum has it why shouldn't town I prefer to compare pairs with this setup. at this point I could know damn near for a fact who 4 townies are if we had claimed

[Wisdom]

The point is that scum DON'T have that info. Giving more info to scum than they already have is suicide.

[Mutleyddmc]

Claim late, not early. Its just like any normal game in a sense thatscum know who scum is but dont know cops docs etc. However in this case its pairs

[Wisdom]

Exactly. It's like arguing that a town in a normal game has to massclaim all their PRs on D1, so that town have more info. The problem is that you're giving SCUM more info.

[Mutleyddmc]

I feel sorry for TAM

[Core_H86]

Not the same, there are no nights to kill PR's before they are used. in this setup the "pr's" are our claims we use through out the day to give us more to read on. I just don't understand your point even the wiki says claim D1

[Wisdom]

The wiki says claim D2 or LATE D1. Are you sure you read it?

[Mutleyddmc]

Exactly we need some info first before we pair up. Wiki also says about random lynching so lets just do that fuck it

[Core_H86]

yeah before I read other polgamy games maybe i got that ^ wrong, however the other games claimed right off the bat and I found it easier to find scum pairs when comparing eachother's interactions. My point is over with you I'm not going to win and have you calim, that was never going to happen at this point I'm just trying to justify what i believe is best for town.

[Mutleyddmc]

Probablem was most people were saying not to claim and yo ucame right out and not only said lets claim you actually claimed

[Core_H86]

prefer the claim sadly didn't get to talk to TAM previously but that's how the other games went and it helped town.

[Wisdom]

however the other games claimed right off the bat and I found it easier to find scum pairs when comparing eachother's interactions

According to the wiki, the last 4 polygamist games were won by scum.
So I guess it didn't really help town, did it?
Unless you're not referring to those games.

[Mutleyddmc]

I got a plan, the sucm should claim to give the town more info but not town. K thx for your co-operation scum

[Core_H86]

so claim then mut

[Wisdom]

Core what you don't understand is that you give the scum too much information in exchange for giving the town a "benefit" which as I described is double-edged and can backfire. It's not worth it.

[Core_H86]

then how do we move on?

[Mutleyddmc]

Play a normal day 1 for now

[Wisdom]

Normally. Wagons, reactions.

[Wisdom]

Or you just vote VV because he's most likely scum.

[Mutleyddmc]

so claim then mut

I'm actually your partner lolz

[Core_H86]

strange reading through the last 4 mafia wins no mass claim cept open 183 not 243 364 or 422 however the game i was refering to that i read to get familiar with the setup (open 76) massed claimed and ended in town victory. I know my point is null with you just want you to know where I'm coming from

[Mutleyddmc]

Thing is as I said, I understand why people could want to claim, but so far the consensus was not to, but you just went and did it on your own accord.