Calvin and Hobbes Mafia(GAME OVER! Grownups Mafia Wins!)

[Zoidberg]

more zoidberg votes

No reasons given still. I guarantee this guy is scum.

It goes without saying we lynch the fuck out of rofl after we deal with Irish.

[TheIrishPope]

Deal with = Lynch, I suppose

[Zoidberg]

Deal with = Lynch, I suppose

Still waiting for you to even attempt some kind of actual analysis.

[Skullduggery]

@MonkeyMan:

With 21 players remaining, it should only take 11 votes to hammer, right? Not 12?

It's a thought I put in the open because I am transparent. Hiding info is harmful to Town, don't you agree?

In most cases, yes, hiding info is harmful to the Town. That's not what I said you were doing, though.

And I explained why only scum would do it. Is that not the same thing as explaining why it's scummy?

Only

Scum cast naked votes? Really? So that means we can expect you to have a Scum read on every player who naked votes for the rest of the game, right?

Right now, I'm thinking Rubicon is scum for being in the butter zone, so my vote will go there

Butter zone? What the heck is that?

we have 4 pages full of shitty votes

Including your own? So your push on Rubicon is "shitty" as well?

too much mafia too little calvin & hobbes

Too much Mafia in a Mafia game? How?

In fact I think he told us what the scum flavor is.

there is no scum in this game, only calvin

Scum flavor is the bad/evil/mischievous side of Calvin.

If Metal Sonic was Scum, why would he tell us this?

Zoidberg, it's incumbent upon you to show me you are Town.

A Town player shouldn't care about how Towny he looks. He's here to find Scum, not spend the whole game defending himself.

I agree with what Tiphaine said here.

UNVOTE:
VOTE: TheIrishPope

Your Town read of me isn't going to magically disappear now, is it?

more zoidberg votes

Why?

[Zoidberg]

roflcopter:

Did you miss this? Here it is again.

Why should we lynching zoidberg today?(If the answer is because he’s scum, follow up question; why is he scum?)

Don't want you to miss it.

Here it is again.

Why should we lynching zoidberg today?(If the answer is because he’s scum, follow up question; why is he scum?)

Eagerly waiting your reply, but also expecting you to just dodge the question again.

[TheIrishPope]

The butter zone is where scum hide on a wagon. You're in the butter zone of my wagon right now.
And again, meh

[Skullduggery]

The butter zone is where scum hide on a wagon. You're in the butter zone of my wagon right now.

So I'm Scum now?

[TheIrishPope]

Never said that. Misreps ahoy

[Varsoon]

Skull is working on town rationale. Too bad scum can play that card, too.
Not getting the Irish Pope/Zoidberg tension. It feels contrived, given they're both flinging baseless arguments back and forth as if they had merit.
Otherwise, I definitely don't like how inflammatory Irish Pope is, especially in response to Skullduggery.
We're getting nowhere as it is.

My history with big games has generally been a pretty big day 1, then short days for the rest. Honestly, I'd prefer lynching out weaker players so they don't make it to those last clutch days.
Also, those players could easily be scum hiding behind the guise of being a weak player, or playing to their meta, etc.
Not that there's much else to go on at page 8 right now. Eh, maybe I'll comb the thread and notice something worthwhile.

[Mr E Roll]

In fact I think he told us what the scum flavor is.

there is no scum in this game, only calvin

Scum flavor is the bad/evil/mischievous side of Calvin.

If Metal Sonic was Scum, why would he tell us this?

My theory is that his disappointment with the very bad and lame, flavor resulted in sub-optimal play.

If you think my premise is wrong what do you think he intended to convey by saying there is no scum only Calvin?

[Skullduggery]

Never said that. Misreps ahoy

First I'm in the "butter zone" and now I'm misrepping you. It's like you're trying to imply that I'm Scum without outright saying it because you're afraid that someone else will try to rustle your jimmies for flip-flopping on a Town read or something.

Has anyone else noticed the disconnect between Pope's insistence that it's important for him to stay in the game since he's Town and his apparent lack of concern at the votes that have been placed on him?

If you think my premise is wrong what do you think he intended to convey by saying there is no scum only Calvin?

Good question. I think Metal Sonic would be more qualified to answer it, though.

[TheIrishPope]

Scumtells aren't 100% accurate. Anyway, you put yourself in the butter zone, so it's not my problem.

[Mr E Roll]

I'm thinking Zoidberg is scum for that stupid ass scumteam guess
But wagon ahoy, I recognise Metal Sonic as scummy, but he may be one of those useless players. I will lead the Zoidberg wagon.
VOTE: Zoidberg

So you voted for Zoidberg for doing something stupid which you’ve said could come from either town or scum over Metal Sonic who you have recognized as scummy.

Is it because joining the Metal Sonic wagon would have placed you in the butter zone?

[TheIrishPope]

Ok, so, you're understanding wrong:
Metal Sonic is doing scummy things
However, he may not be scum
Zoidberg is doing silly things
And his guess was stupid
So I'm telling everyone to sheep me because he's scum

[Mr E Roll]

So you think being silly is a stronger scum tell than be being scummy?

[TheIrishPope]

Knowing Metal Sonic, yes

[MonkeyMan576]

It is indeed 11 to lynch, not 12.

[Metal Sonic]

Knowing Metal Sonic, yes

I havent even played a game with you before

?????????????

unless you are an alt or hydra

[Metal Sonic]

whoever is voting me for "speculating on flavor"

is

scummy by the way


i mean, just look at their justification for their vote

[TheIrishPope]

I know how players like you operate
Or are you claiming scum?
Oh yeah we got him
VOTE: Metal Sonic

[Metal Sonic]

but i've never played with you before????????????????

what do you mean "knowing metal sonic"

[TheIrishPope]

I know how players like you operate

Like geez, can't read?

[Metal Sonic]

I know how

players like you

operate

Like geez, can't read?

Okay I'm pretty sure you don't know how

I

operate


Do what you wish

[Mr E Roll]

Knowing Metal Sonic, yes

I havent even played a game with you before

?????????????

unless you are an alt or hydra

What did Metal Sonic do between post 190 and 194 that warranted a vote change? Other than expose your lie.

Unvote

VOTE: TheIrishPope

[TheIrishPope]

It's not a lie; I have never played with him before. I'm pressuring him, so shh go away