Xenoblade Mafia (Game Over)

[TiphaineDeath]

things are muddled enough I should probably join you in that, it's just so much goddamned work for this big a thread.

[Nachomamma8]

Things are muddled for you, TD? Certainly didn't seem like it here:

...... I'll go through this one last time.

MS is blue scum
You are red scum.
Andi is town.
I was working on the assumption that GIF/Spinach were red scum. Given that you are neither of them can be and they are both town.
SAD is not your buddy and is thus town.
POE Bro is your buddy

[Metal Sonic]

strong^

nacho

spinach and Gif listen to andy, I am defintiely not blue scum

nacho only pretends to listen because he is a scum aligned slot

[borkjerfkin]

Votecount 5.4

[2] TiphaineDeath (BROseidon, spinachattack)
[1] Metal Sonic (TiphaineDeath)
[1] Nachomamma8 (Ser Arthur Dayne)
[1] Ser Arthur Dayne (Nachomamma8)

[3] Not Voting (Andrius, GuyInFreezer, Metal Sonic)

With 8 alive, it is 5 to lynch.

Let me know if you see any problems.

Deadline is in (expired on 2013-06-27 14:00:00)

[borkjerfkin]

I usually don't get so screwed up on WIFOM, but I had to step out of the box and take a look from a different angle here. Removing those considered conf town from the alive list, I looked at it from the perspective of what is to be gained, information wise, from any lynch if the player is town or scum.


10. Ser Arthur Dayne- nothing
12. Metal Sonic- nothing, he's done nothing but tunnel TD all game
17. Nachomamma8- loads either way
18. TiphaineDeath- nothing, he's done nothing but tunnel MS all game

Retreading back over all that from last night, Nacho did crumb red scum. His reply to me about that was hand face, which I think was more to himself than anyone else. Also, after I pointed the slip out, his whole tone changed from attacker to consolatory. So, right or wrong

UNVOTE TD

VOTE NACHO

This vote was NOT counted.

[Metal Sonic]

wasnt i voting

VOTE: TiphaneDeath

[spinachattack]

UNVOTE: TiphaneDeath

VOTE: Nacho

[spinachattack]

Now that I've properly voted to get me back to where I should be, what's your take on this Nacho?

Because

im sheeping nacho

your reads are lazy and inconsistent.

Explain your sajin vote.

Speaking of sajin, where is he?

Wait. He's not here anymore
I don't remember him dying/lynched?
Brb

Oh he died n3.

Not liking this a bit, personally. Where's the town motivation in being so absent from the thread you don't even know the deaths from 3 phases ago? Scum doesn't have to read to win.

Btw, Scumputer is something new for me. Liespotting is something I've used for a while now, so it's actually part of my meta.

[Ser Arthur Dayne]

Hmm TD's recent posts seem genuine. Right now, thinking MS is last blue. Nacho is red. GiF isn't his partner. Andy in general reads town. Leaving BRO/SA out of PoE.

Wow, this is a horrible read flip. I guess you're not going to do those ISOs, huh?

I did? Well tbf I only had time to ISO BRO, SA, and TD. BRO reads a lot more scum than SA (just because he reads so.. passive... and robotic, and generic). TD's posts on a whole don't really read too bad. His obsession with MS can be scummy in the sense it makes him look like he's doing work while at the same time having little connections with anyone else, but some of his posts really read genuine. And SA is just kinda on and off, but they read like they believe in the stuff they say.

I continue to disagree that red is better :/. Relying on luck to see you through is never a winning strategy.

Well another advantage of lynching red today is going in tomorrow with 1 scum of each alignment, meaning that each of them individually have less power than if there were two on the same scum team.

[Metal Sonic]

^ sounds good

lets kill red today


and i suspect red is
(also minorly sheeping spinach)
UNVOTE: TiphaineDeath

VOTE: Nachomamma

[waynegg]

Don't hammer. As a matter of fact to be sure

UNVOTE NACHO

I really want his take before he's lynched. If he's lynched.

[Metal Sonic]

there was only 2 votes on him

unless you mean that the remaining 2 mafia will flash lynch

[waynegg]

There were three with yours, and yeah, if Nacho isn't scum they would do that in a heartbeat.

[spinachattack]

Ugh!!!!

UNVOTE NACHO

[spinachattack]

There were three with yours, and yeah, if Nacho isn't scum they would do that in a heartbeat.

Quote for ISO! Possss!!!

[TiphaineDeath]

They weren't, then everyone started talking at me and now I'm not even sure which way is up anymore X_x.

Like, I'm starting to doubt my MS scumread, that can't be healthy.

I'm still trying to figure out the whole Nacho and MS both advocating for me to be voting them.

Really it's that.

Scum don't do that.

So confused.

[Andrius]

Yeah I keep feeling like I need to post but all I can do is restate what I've said and still not have reread anything.

Anything for me otherwise? D:

[waynegg]

Yeah I keep feeling like I need to post but all I can do is restate what I've said and still not have reread anything.

Anything for me otherwise? D:

Do you think Nacho is scum?

If not, do you have any stronger leads?

Do you think, even if Nacho isn't scum, that more information could be gained by lynching anyone else?

How long had you had your 'breadcrumbs' quoted and ready to post to prove your role, because you posted that pretty quickly when called out for it?

[spinachattack]

Ok, that time I had actually logged into my hydra and when I posted got a 1040 error and came back to the above...

Yeah I keep feeling like I need to post but all I can do is restate what I've said and still not have reread anything.

Anything for me otherwise? D:

Do you think Nacho is scum?

If not, do you have any stronger leads?

Do you think, even if Nacho isn't scum, that more information could be gained by lynching anyone else?

How long had you had your 'breadcrumbs' quoted and ready to post to prove your role, because you posted that pretty quickly when called out for it?

[TiphaineDeath]

What happens to this game if I step back and decide MS and Nacho are both town?

Or that nacho is blue and MS is red?

[Andrius]

1) Yes, though I have no solid team to put him in. Honestly expected varsoon to flip scum, and Nacho was a likely buddy.

2) Stronger? Nothing is strong here to begin with.

3) I'm not exactly great at drawing town to scum connections, so I'm sure it COULD I just have no idea how that works.

4) I never quoted them/saved them; I just knew keywords (Monado, Buster, unloved, promise) so I could self-ISO and Ctrl-F.

Two things will happen before I vote, though.
1) I'll casewrite.
2) I'll do some reading.
Because voting someone without doing so at this stage is dumb.

[TiphaineDeath]

If Nacho+MS town then 3/4 of spinach/Gif/Bro/SAD are scum. I don't think this is true so we're gonna ignore that option for now.

If MS red Nacho blue then one of Spinach/Gif/Bro/Sad is an MS buddy, not a nacho buddy. brb looking for relational tells.

[spinachattack]

Then I'll old my vote so you have time to do that.

[spinachattack]

Oh yeah. And what do you think of the recent GiF brilliance?

[spinachattack]

Lets see...Why hasn't GiF payed close attention to the game since N3? What significant event could have possibly happened to influence that? Hmm. Well, two of the Blue team were killed leaving presumably only one. A loner has no need to pay attention to the game because everyone who isn't them is against them. Yeah.