Harry Potter and the Philosopher's Stone Mafia Game Over

[fuzzybutternut]

Town points?

[BROseidon]

Obvious fakeclaim was obvious.

[Lord Mhork]

What was so obvious about it?

[Lord Mhork]

Also I adore the fact that you're only now saying that you didn't believe the claim and, moreover, that you've found Ghostlin scummy all game but there were also posts of his that you "liked a lot." What's up with that?

[RachMarie]

Mhork if dude is scum, he would know that Arc was town, and there was plenty of scoffing and backlash on her fake claim to make it a hammer that would not come back to bite him in the ass.

So that is not enough to clear him.

[fuzzybutternut]

BRO is flopping.
VOTE: BRO

[ChannelDelibird]

What was so obvious about it?

Also I adore the fact that you're only now saying that you didn't believe the claim and, moreover, that you've found Ghostlin scummy all game but there were also posts of his that you "liked a lot." What's up with that?

Hmm. I went back and looked back at BRO's iso around the AA claim because my response was going to be: Come on, it was obviously fake enough that six people pre-Ghostlin wanted to lynch her. But BRO doesn't actually show any signs of disbelieving the claim itself, only that he's "thirding the idea of using AA as a double lynch".

VOTE: AA

That's L-1. I third the idea of using AA as a double lynch.

In the post before, Lord Mhork does a similar thing, but he only a few posts earlier, just before the claim, explains why he thinks AA is scum so he's on record as being unlikely to believe the claim. So his position makes sense from a town POV.

The only thing that BRO had said about AA before that, however, was a "not sure if scum or stupid". It's altogether more indicative of someone who knows AA's alignment and is happy to go ahead and get somebody else to hammer the claimed supersaint. He doesn't even mention Ghostlin specifically at this point, although he was voting him earlier.

UNVOTE: Ghostlin, VOTE: BROseidon

Hopefully Ghostlin can show up soon. I'd really like to see which way he went when BRO and penguin_alien are the top two alternatives to his own wagon.

[penguin_alien]

Broseidon, are your only scum reads PoE?

I've found Ghost scummy all game. Also feeling off about p_a now, but that may be because I have town meta on her from a different site where the meta is pretty different (my meta there is very different as well).

(You actually have Day One town meta on me as I play as town on that site, as I'm going on three games of not playing as town beyond Day One: two NKs N1, one culting.) And

He specifies later with the quote above about TWTOLBTWNTOF buying the masons claim too readily for his taste. Why not say what's making you vote at the time?

For shits and giggles, honestly. I thought it was fairly obvious and that other people would see it.

Obvious fakeclaim was obvious.

You keep saying things are obvious, which seems like a great tactic for keeping people from questioning you on them or having to spell anything out. And then you try to brush off your reaction to the ArcAngel9 lynch any way you think will fly. At the time, you say you want the double lynch, which implies that you don't think ArcAngel9 will flip scum. Then it was an obvious fakeclaim, which would mean that you didn't expect to get a double lynch out of it.

I would have hammered as either alignment. js

Why?

why did you change avatar

This question-dodging is pretty scummy, followed by a vote on CDB, when he hasn't mentioned CDB as any sort of scum read. He actually had CDB as a town read the only times he's mentioned him, so far as I can tell. Care to explain?

[Saint]

i could hammer

[Saint]

Saint, what do you think of BROseidon? Why is CDB scummier?

cdb kept giving excuses
i wanted to promote pressure for him to see if he would continue being helpful to the town - he did

i don't think he is scum at this point, and my vote is going off of him very shortly

[Saint]

fuzzybutternut - read town
penguin_alien - leaning scum
Mac RachMarie * - i guess mason
BROseidon - ???
SafetyDance * ChannelDelibird * - leaning town
Lord Mhork - i guess mason
DoctorPepper * Amrun - reading town
Saint * - know town
Ghostlin - null

so i really dont mind hammering here... waiting on claim...

[Lord Mhork]

Mhork if dude is scum, he would know that Arc was town, and there was plenty of scoffing and backlash on her fake claim to make it a hammer that would not come back to bite him in the ass.

So that is not enough to clear him.

But it's enough to not want to lynch his as much as, say, BROseidon.

[BROseidon]

Fuck I need to claim and don't have time to put together a coherent case.

I'm Hermione Granger, Vanilla Townie.

[ChannelDelibird]

I'd rather we figure out whether or not Ghostlin has flaked before anyone hammers. I want to see what he says about BRO and penguin_alien.

[fuzzybutternut]

inb4 hammer.

[Saint]

unvote right now unless there is a hermione cc, and with harry being a townie, this all fits
if someone hammers they are lynched tomorrow, end of story/discussion/game

period

unvote now
NOW.

[Saint]

in fact the next person to post who has a vote on broseidon and doesnt unvote is going to get lynched

[Saint]

______________________
the line is in the sand
now i might not be the best player
but i know how this is going to go

my way
OR THE HIGHWAY
ok?!

[Saint]

Mhork if dude is scum, he would know that Arc was town, and there was plenty of scoffing and backlash on her fake claim to make it a hammer that would not come back to bite him in the ass.

So that is not enough to clear him.

But it's enough to not want to lynch his as much as, say, BROseidon.

i want you guys to NOT TALK TO EACH OTHER AT ALL
honestly, talk to the rest of the game
your alignments are CLEAR to you guys, regardless of what they are
so, you all are exhibiting noobish behavior

[ChannelDelibird]

Saint, you have heard of safeclaims, right?

[Nexus]

"Books! And cleverness! There are more important things — friendship and bravery.” - Hermione Granger

Votecount 3.2:

BROseidon (4)-

penguin_alien, Lord Mhork, fuzzybutternut, ChannelDelibird

penguin_alien (1)-

Amrun

Ghostlin (1)-

BROseidon

ChannelDelibird (1)-

Saint

Not Voting (2)-

RachMarie, Ghostlin

With 9 alive it takes 5 to lynch. Deadline is at 6am BST on Thursday July 4th

Ghostlin has failed to pick up his prod. I'm going to look for a replacement now.

[Amrun]

VT is zero reason to unvote so.

I'm still kind of conflicted on him though. :/

[ChannelDelibird]

Sigh. Replacement.

Anyway, Saint, to expand: Nexus is a competent mod, so I'd assume that the scum have at least one important character as a safeclaim. Hermione could be a VT in this game, sure, but if anything having a dead Harry Potter actually makes her

more

likely to be a safeclaim that without a dead Harry, if you get me. Basically the claim is super null.

[Lord Mhork]

Yeah there is no reason to unvote. Hell if I were a mod the character's role in the novel would be only loosely related to his mafia role. Maybe Hermione is pissed that she gets picked on. Maybe a Death Eater used polyjuice potion. Like dude said, VT is no reason for unvote.

[fuzzybutternut]

Keep in mind, this is the first book. Clearly Hermione is pissed because Ron was picking on her.