Newbie 1391 - Game Over - FINALLY!!!

[Antagon]

I will be semi-V/LA for the next week.
Sorry if that causes any inconveniences.
I don't have time to make any analysis, but I am going to claim One-Shot Bulletproof.

[Feel It]

Do they get assigned in newbie games?

[Miss Stranger]

@Feel It:

Column-A or Row-3 on this deck (see front page). What kind of a question was that?

I sort of expected Antagon to claim some sort of power role and walk away with no information as always. I hope everyone else realises that even if he's actually the bulletproof, he isn't going to make a very good leader later in the game when he's actually needed. Sigh.

I don't think that post will make me retract my vote, in all honesty.

[Feel It]

I just wasn't sure, forgot about the table thanks. I'm not moving my vote and I think overall the best choice would be to hammer him. Bulletproof is an easy scum claim and it smells like a last ditch effort to save himself. If we let him go now and he's lying (which is likely), we've let a scum go, but even if he's telling the truth all it will do is let the scum know not to target him because he's bulletproof and not a helpful townplayer, which will make it easier for them to pick the rest of us off.

[champinoman]

Even with the claim the fact that you haven't included any sort of indication who you think scum is is just another nail in the coffin. You are either scum or a useless townie.

I just wasn't sure, forgot about the table thanks. I'm not moving my vote and I think overall the best choice would be to hammer him. Bulletproof is an easy scum claim and it smells like a last ditch effort to save himself. If we let him go now and he's lying (which is likely), we've let a scum go, but even if he's telling the truth all it will do is let the scum know not to target him because he's bulletproof and not a helpful townplayer, which will make it easier for them to pick the rest of us off.

I agree with this. And in addition I think we need to look at the value of his PR in the event he is telling the truth. I think it is very unlikely that he would get NK'd anyway considering it would be a foolish scum to kill someone who is providing zero to the conversation. So I still fully support the lynch.

[Feel It]

7 hours till the deadline, I'll probably be asleep at that time

[Generic]

No value whatsoever.

Claiming it means it won't help town in night phase, mafia aim elsewhere. Mafia wouldn't aim at town antagon cos his play has been anti town and no threat to them. And now he is absent...

Not good enough,

vote: antagon

I will put this one on me. No way am I accepting that crap as a good defence.

[Miss Stranger]

[Miss Stranger]

Also if Antagon is mafia, by looking at the votes I'd say it's pretty likely that Fegelein is the partner.

[StubbsKVM]

Feel It: 0
Gen Wolf: -1
Nacho: 2

[StubbsKVM]

that was a hammer yes?

[Miss Stranger]

There's more subtle hints, too.

Antagon:
1) Ignoring Fegelein's early town read on him
2) Trying to distance from one another WITHOUT actually voting each other
3) Demanding excessive explanation from Fegelein or about Fegelein
4) Post #248 is quite damning and probably a scumslip
5) Both of them don't hesitate to hop on Nacho's wagon, who is likely very dangerous for them if he's town

Fegelein:
1) Subtle backing for Antagon early in the game #17 #23
2) Ignoring Antagon in his list of reads #71
3) Asking for excessive explanation #175
4) I really don't like #219

[Miss Stranger]

[Vel-Rahn Koon]

Prodding Nachomamma8.

Vote Count 1.10

Fegelein - 1 (Gen_Wolf)
champinoman - 1 (Nachomamma8)
Nachomamma8 - 2 (Fegelein, Antagon)

Antagon - 5 (Miss Stranger, Feel It, StubbsKVM, champinoman, Generic)

Not Voting - 0 ()

5 to Lynch.

Deadline is in (expired on 2013-06-30 08:00:00)

.

[Vel-Rahn Koon]

"Alright guys, uh, I'll be like, sorta kinda here, not really, just a heads up....."
Antagon tries to slip away but Generic throws a noose around his neck.
"Not so fast, Scummy McScummerson. Hang out for a while..."


Good call!

Antagon,

Mafia Goon

, lynched Day 1

Night has begun. Those of you with night actions must submit your choices

within (expired on 2013-07-03 07:00:00)

.

[Vel-Rahn Koon]

Hooray for dumb luck!

No one was killed Night 1

Vote Count 2.0

Not Voting - 8 (champinoman, chkflip, Feel It, Gen_Wolf, Generic, Miss Stranger, Nachomamma8, StubbsKVM)

Day 2 has begun. With 8 alive, it takes 5 to lynch.

Deadline is in (expired on 2013-07-17 07:00:00)

[/b].

chkflip replaces Fegelein.

[Miss Stranger]

I sort of expected that, strange as it is. Welcome back.

VOTE: chkflip

Number one candidate for Antagon's partner. Refer to what I said before D1 death scene.

[StubbsKVM]

There's a number of possibilities there.

chkflip = Fegelein?

[Generic]

It's feel it or fegelein/chkflip.

But don't disregard any of the ones to be replaced or recently replaced, technically I should be dead by now. I was considered town universally and hammered the mafia player.

So unless we have a doc (silence if you are out there, I do NOT want to know, just keep up the good work) the kill wasn't registered in time.

[StubbsKVM]

it's also possible a jailkeeper targeted the scum player
or the scum player could have targeted a bulletproof.

All speculation.

[Generic]

Either way,

vote feel it

You can now explain your panicky reaction when I took nacho out of L-1 and took away your ability to hammer him, and put it on a now confirmed scum player.

And if you use at any time the arguement you were voting for antagon I will push this lynch with everything I have. Bussing does not clear anybody.

[Gen_Wolf]

sorry,was slack end of day 1. Got plenty of time now. I was completely wrong about Anta so good job on that.

Any chance scum didnt NK on purpose as make sure it could not be linked to the scum team or is that unlikely?

[Miss Stranger]

Generic, I think the Fegel/chk case is much more substantiated than Feel It. While I have reservations about Feel It, Fegelein is glaringly scummy after Antagon was confirmed scum.

[chkflip]

I see why my predecessor bailed. I'll look for associative tells connected with Antagon and get back with you all.

[StubbsKVM]

sorry,was slack end of day 1. Got plenty of time now. I was completely wrong about Anta so good job on that.

Any chance scum didnt NK on purpose as make sure it could not be linked to the scum team or is that unlikely?

Anything is possible. I don't think we should give it too much thought.