I think the above summarizes the first four pages well. Moving on.In post 94, Amrun wrote:The suggestion itself is 100% pro-town. This set-up isn't a mystery so if the plan is adopted, it will be a good plan regardless of the alignment of the originator.
Sure, suggesting it doesn't make me town, since scum also want to appear town. It also doesn't make me scum, either. In fact, traditionally, such suggestions are made far more often by town -- BUT it's still null because the scum motivation for doing it is so cut and dry. So the fact that I suggested a plan should not be treated as a tell in either direction (in my opinion, at least). Analyzing the manner in which I did it is another matter entirely.
I disagree with the reasons for this read. Questioning why people have you as a townread is common practice enough in order to allow scum to adopt it as well.And as I said, some people are rude regardless, but it's a perfectly valid reason to not be interested in pursuing you at the moment. That conviction is only strengthened by you arguing with the basis of my townread on you.
By the way: where was Wisdom rude?
I also question this early townread of him. Sounds to me like you just want him out of your hairs so you give a soothing townread to try and make him back off. What's wrong with just sticking to the arguments that are to be found in the first quote-snippet of post 94? Why do you feel the need to add a townread of Wisdom this early?
