NY 165: A Large Normal (Game Over!)

[Calcifer]

I'm shocked that you would be voting for someone one of you heads has as a scum read. I never could have deduced that from the fact that you are voting them.

Well, you

asked

for why we were

voting

, so I gave why we were.

To answer the better question of "why is BulbaFenix scum?", the answer is honestly, "not much from me; it's more of a Nacho read". It's basically gut. Mind you, haven't read the whole game, but a lot of their posts just don't come off as town, and give me some scum vibes. If I had more than that, I'd share, but that's about it from me. As I said, it's mainly trusting in Nacho.

[Nero]

serene is a parody of its own stupidity.

[Serene]

Don't make me rage against you.

do it

[Serene]

You are not a scumhunting god.

Yeah I'm no scumhunting god but I did catch you didn't I.

I'll talk if you bus Nero. Hard. Realllll hard.

But I must warn you, I have no patience for your scum shenanigans.

[Nero]

what a stupid fucking idiot ^

[Serene]

Calcifer, why are you voting BulbaFenix?

Because they're still technically a scumread, combined with the fact that--while I may currently be the dominant head--I still hold some trust in Nacho, and last I knew, Nacho had BulbaFenix as scum.

Oh god this is so scummy

[Nero]

you're probably the densest cunt on this site.

[Nero]

Calcifer, why are you voting BulbaFenix?

Because they're still technically a scumread, combined with the fact that--while I may currently be the dominant head--I still hold some trust in Nacho, and last I knew, Nacho had BulbaFenix as scum.

Oh god this is so scummy

Oh god this is so scummy

[Serene]

It's basically gut.

Oh. Gut is good for you, but not for me?

[Serene]

vote: calcifer

Downhill ever since.

[Nero]

It's basically gut.

Oh. Gut is good for you, but not for me?

its cause you're shit

[Ankamius]

VOTE: Calcifer

I'm getting those weird vibes almost half the time he posts now. I would post an actual case, but I'm not interested in having to read another ten damn pages of virtually nothing while I make it.

[Serene]

Nero, since you know that I am town - you have literally ZERO reason to use 90% of your posts to discredit me.

You also have no scumreads. You have been voting your buddy Stevie since June 12.

The only explanation for the above is your scum role PM.

You're very lucky we're playing a game where no one seems to want to lynch anyone. If this game had normal players, you know, that vote players to lynch, and get the game moving, I'm pretty sure you'd be lynched.

[Nero]

Nero, since you know that I am town - you have literally ZERO reason to use 90% of your posts to discredit me.

You also have no scumreads. You have been voting your buddy Stevie since June 12.

The only explanation for the above is your scum role PM.

You're very lucky we're playing a game where no one seems to want to lynch anyone. If this game had normal players, you know, that vote players to lynch, and get the game moving, I'm pretty sure you'd be lynched.

i have a right to discredit you because you're a fucking psuedo-intellectual idiot who shit-posts continuously.

also policy lynching is probably the stupidest idea in the entire game of mafia and is only advocated by elistist snobs who can't scumhunt. if you really think im bussing then why dont you fucking vote stevie.

[Nero]

VOTE: Calcifer

I'm getting those weird vibes almost half the time he posts now. I would post an actual case, but I'm not interested in having to read another ten damn pages of virtually nothing while I make it.

how do you read stevie?

[Rift Adrift]

For those who are into meta, here's a recently completed Newbie game where Shadi was scum: http://forum.mafiascum.net/viewtopic.php?f=11&t=28769

I'll review this and report back my findings.

One thing I'll say before even looking at the game - I'm finding Shadi's fluff ratio in this game to be way higher than in the previous game we played.

[Shadi1337]

Yes I replaced into that spot I don't know which round and I didn't catch my predecessor's claim and therefore failed horribly and was pretty much lynched 20 minutes after I made my first post or so lol (Well maybe 20 minutes is an over exaggeration but that's how it felt )

[Ankamius]

VOTE: Calcifer

I'm getting those weird vibes almost half the time he posts now. I would post an actual case, but I'm not interested in having to read another ten damn pages of virtually nothing while I make it.

how do you read stevie?

Vague memory is some sort of null. I'm pretty sure I found town and scum motivation in his posts. His lurking is null.

[Rift Adrift]

Yes I replaced into that spot I don't know which round and I didn't catch my predecessor's claim and therefore failed horribly and was pretty much lynched 20 minutes after I made my first post or so lol (Well maybe 20 minutes is an over exaggeration but that's how it felt )

Yeah, I scanned the game. Looked painful!

I'm not sure how useful it will be in comparing to this game.

But I am still concerned by your posts after the last week or so. You're not digging in. You're not scumhunting. You're making jokey, fluffy posts.

[StubbsKVM]

For those who are into meta, here's a recently completed Newbie game where Shadi was scum: http://forum.mafiascum.net/viewtopic.php?f=11&t=28769

I'll review this and report back my findings.

One thing I'll say before even looking at the game - I'm finding Shadi's fluff ratio in this game to be way higher than in the previous game we played.

Shadi only lasted a couple of hours after replacing in. It was a very bad spot to replace into, as TSO, Nani and me were only doubting if Nacho or Shadi's slot was scum and we had 2 lynches left. So unless he was able to pull off an enormous case on one of us, while backing up that bulletproof claim, he had basically no chance. Not sure how that's comparable to this game.

Well, maybe you can get something out of it. Nacho, TSO and myself were also in that game, and all 3 of us were town.

[Serene]

policy lynching

Haha, no, nice try.

NOT policy lynch.

Scum lynch.

I'd rather lynch you than Stevie because Stevie appeals to my condescending intellectual pretensions more than you do.

[Brian Hollywood]

Deadline should be approaching rather quickly.

[orcinus_theoriginal]

lmao

[Nero]

[Shadi1337]

Yes I replaced into that spot I don't know which round and I didn't catch my predecessor's claim and therefore failed horribly and was pretty much lynched 20 minutes after I made my first post or so lol (Well maybe 20 minutes is an over exaggeration but that's how it felt )

Yeah, I scanned the game. Looked painful!

I'm not sure how useful it will be in comparing to this game.

But I am still concerned by your posts after the last week or so. You're not digging in. You're not scumhunting. You're making jokey, fluffy posts.

Well it's mainly because people aren't doing anything than bickering and thinking of a new lynch target. If you wanna go for me, fine but at least find somebody to lynch. If you haven't noticed 90% of the posts is Serene's bitching.