NY 165: A Large Normal (Game Over!)

[Serene]

In BSG, he's giving reads, he's voting, he's commenting, he's terse but not useless. Very unlike this game.

[Serene]

Just to be clear:

VOTE: Nero

[Rift Adrift]

In BSG, he's giving reads, he's voting, he's commenting, he's terse but not useless. Very unlike this game.

Do you know what the real difference between that game and this one?

Nobody in that game let themselves be trolled by him for more than a post or two. All of the stuff you're pointing to in the BSG game was happening in this game before the troll-feeding started.

[Serene]

Ignore the trolling - the evidence remains.

[Serene]

All of the stuff you're pointing to in the BSG game was happening in this game before the troll-feeding started

No. There are only a few posts that aren't trolling and they aren't at all like BSG.

He bus'es Calcifer, then bus'es Stevie, trolls without updating reads, without adding information, without actually pushing the Stevie lynch.

Come on now. Sometimes we want to believe really hard that some a-hole players are town. It's as if it makes us feel better about ourselves, makes us feel that we're above being trolled, and that we can co-exist with a-holes. It is a good feeling.

Except that this one is scum, and the only thing more satisfying than lynching scum, is lynching a-hole scum.

[Serene]

He bus'es Calcifer

actually, he's refusing to bus Calcifer and kept his vote parked on stevie until dropping a troll-vote onto ank

[Rift Adrift]

I'll review his earlier posts tonight and see if my memory is incorrect.

There are actually three of us who played with Nero in that game. Syryana was in that game too. And he also thinks Nero's game here is similar to BSG.

There is a Nero scum game out there btw. Orcinus and I both meta'd him in the BSG game and had a close look at his prior scum game.

[Serene]

Maybe you compared them on page 3... how could you not see the vast differences?????

[KingCrabd]

I see logic has re-entered the thread. Awesome. I'm home from work as well.

[Serene]

post #2 is a vote.
post #5 he's givine reads on 4 players.
post #8 different reads that are "preliminary" ie subject to CHANGE.
post #14 he changes his vote.
post #16 he pushes for a lynch.
post #18 he tells someone to knock off the insults.
post #19 narrows down reads to 4 scums
post #21 hints at PR content day 2.
post #24 criticizes a wagon
post #26 UNVOTES
post #27 compromise vote to be team player
post #30 responds rationally to orc's scum read on him.
post #31 expresses a very stron towng read

*********************

All that in Nero's FIRST 31 posts. I didn't even bother looking at more. HE HAS DONE NONE OF THIS HERE. NONE.

So please. All of your professing to lean on meta. LURN 2 META

[KingCrabd]

Reading BSG but it does look like Nero was much more open in giving reads and thoughts there than here.

[Serene]

It's like night and day.

[Rift Adrift]

Reading BSG but it does look like Nero was much more open in giving reads and thoughts there than here.

I will reveiw later tonight when other stuff calms down.

Where do we stand wrt townbloc? Did you read my post about shadi's "slip"?

[Serene]

Yeah I don't believe in "slips" and that's a particularly unconvincing one.

I also don't care about "townblocs." No one wants to lynch in this game, how you expect to get a "townbloc" going when everyone is too chicken to vote and shake people up, I dunno.

[KingCrabd]

I read your post about shadi but I'm not sure what to make of it. You're kind of unique in the good way, I've never seen another player do that like you have. Maybe Shadi is secretly your lovechild, I dunno.

I'm liking the townbloc just fine, or did you mean something more specific?

[Serene]

We're too disorganized to get a wagon going! We can't add the additional hurdle of townbloc-making.

[Shadi1337]

I read your post about shadi but I'm not sure what to make of it. You're kind of unique in the good way, I've never seen another player do that like you have. Maybe Shadi is secretly your lovechild, I dunno.

I'm liking the townbloc just fine, or did you mean something more specific?

???? what does this mean

[Rift Adrift]

I read your post about shadi but I'm not sure what to make of it. You're kind of unique in the good way, I've never seen another player do that like you have. Maybe Shadi is secretly your lovechild, I dunno.

I'm liking the townbloc just fine, or did you mean something more specific?

There are nulls. Who do you think we could sort? I've got Brian Hollywood, BROseidon, Stevie, TSO and Stubbs in my nullpile.

TSO was town at one point but that read is pretty stale.

[Serene]

Ah Jesus, can we get something done and lynch Nero already?

What more can I give you? Are you waiting for fingerprints and DNA evidence and high-definition video surveillance with a face and a plate number?

Nero is scum, just vote him. Why does it have to be so complicated.

[Serene]

I read your post about shadi but I'm not sure what to make of it. You're kind of unique in the good way, I've never seen another player do that like you have. Maybe Shadi is secretly your lovechild, I dunno.

I'm liking the townbloc just fine, or did you mean something more specific?

???? what does this mean

Who cares what this means, just vote Nero.

[Rift Adrift]

Ah Jesus, can we get something done and lynch Nero already?

What more can I give you? Are you waiting for fingerprints and DNA evidence and high-definition video surveillance with a face and a plate number?

Nero is scum, just vote him. Why does it have to be so complicated.

Here:

VOTE: Nero

Now, want to help us sort other players?

[Serene]

I gave my town reads and my scum reads. I don't sort out null reads.

[Zdenek]

Vote: Nero

[Serene]

Update

TOWN

Serene
dramonic
TheIrishPope
Ankamius
ProHawk
BROseidon
Baby Spice
DOMO
Mac
orcinus_theoriginal
Rift Adrift (Syryana and fferyllt)
T S O
Zdenek
Shadi1337
KingCrabd

NULL

StubbsKVM

SCUMLIST

Metal Sonic
Nero
Calcifer
Cephrir/Doc Holliday
StevieT92
TMTOLBTWNTOF
Brian Hollywood
The Goat

Some of the lurkers on my scumlist are probably town, that'll be sorted out when they are replaced.

[KingCrabd]

Nero works for me for now.

Vote: Nero

That said rift/serene/townbloc, let's go one at a time, ISO-meta as we go down the list?