Harry Potter and the Philosopher's Stone Mafia Game Over

[Amrun]

On second thought, it doesn't really matter because if penguin_alien isn't scum, this game doesn't make sense. Basically no scum teams make sense without her in it.

At least one of my cdb/saint town reads are wrong (given the masons are true) and I'd certainly choose cdb as the loser between the two.

[ChannelDelibird]

It makes sense because three of the four of you must be scum (and, I agree, at this point it's hard to imagine anything making sense if penguin isn't one of them) so it'd be more notable if there

weren't

things to link people together.

[Amrun]

Sure things link people together, but not necessarily as buddies and that was a strange and scummy way to phrase it. It read to me like a note to yourself to manufacture buddy tells, as if you'd already come to the conclusion and were looking only for "evidence."

I still want to lynch penguin_alien today but it makes me itch.

[RachMarie]

Im here guys n gals...

Crap this does not look good for us does it?

Will do some ISO work .....

Fine with popcorn claiming since it is LYLO

[penguin_alien]

Before further discussion, can we kick off the popcorn claiming? I'd like one of the claimed Weasley twins to pick who goes first, whichever one posts next. Delaying the claiming only gives scum more info on who to set up for a mislynch IMHO.

[RachMarie]

ehhh

That works


How about we start with you PA ?

[Lord Mhork]

Also while you popcorn you can tell us who your scumbuddies are. We'll lynch you last if you do.

[penguin_alien]

Neville Longbottom, VT. (No scumbuddies, Mhork Although I suppose Trevor is a regular buddy? But they totally said we could bring a toad...)

Popcorn to Ghostlin.

[Ghostlin]

Ron Weasley, VT; One of the reasons I agreed to hammer Archangel was we weren't gonna miss out on much.

I've got a Town read on Amrun; CDB goes next.

[Saint]

yo dawg am i alive

[ChannelDelibird]

I'm Albus Dumbledore. Once per game I can commute to the Ministry of Magic and become untargetable, which I did last night.

Amrun, you're up.

[Amrun]

I'm Hagrid, vanilla as they come.

Saint, your turn.

[Ghostlin]

yo dawg am i alive

Are you

volunteering

to be noticed by me? Because outside of Day 1, I'm having trouble coming up with reasons to remember you.

[Lord Mhork]

-.-
If saint is scum, I'm going to rage hard here...

[ChannelDelibird]

Should add that Marathon weekend is distracting me so that read and stuff is probably getting finished after it's done.

[RachMarie]

Saint needs to claim

[penguin_alien]

...Saint. Claim. Pronto. /belated prod dodge

[Lord Mhork]

*jeopardy theme*

[Ghostlin]

Am I the only one in this game who's ever read DGB's signature?

[Saint]

im seamus or sheamus
let me check his full name
im a vt
the red haired kid

[Saint]

Seamus Finnegan

[Saint]

Which is a REALLY WEAK CLAIM that I wouldn't make as scum
/wifom

[penguin_alien]

I'm assuming RachMarie and Lork Mhork don't have anything further to claim. If you do, go for it, but I don't want to waste any more of the day's time in the meanwhile.

Saint, why didn't you elaborate on your hammer of TMT yesterday? And why the white knighting of BROseidon just off a character claim? Without any move to suggesting another casd?

Ghostlin, what's your take on the BROseidon and TMT lynches?

CDB, why commute last night? As opposed to on an earlier night? Or seeing if we can lynch scum today and so have the breathing room of MyLo down the road if you used it later?

Amrun, not loving all the 'oh, I wanted to die' WIFOM. Saint and you commenting on the whole not being the NK makes me uneasy. If you're town, why would you want to be out?

With BRO flipping town, I'm not sure where scum is most likely to be, except that even if we're wrong about RachMarie and Lord Mhork likely being on the up-and-up there would still be one more scum. And if so, we're screwed anyways, because I don't see lynching either of them at LyLo as a good move. So might as well assume they're town.

As such I'd like to hear more complete thoughts from them. Their double-ISO from yesterday is mostly on BRO, and while I get that they'd want to communicate a lot in-thread if they are effectively masons without a QT, I don't have as much of a sense on how others are communicating with them as a result.

[Lord Mhork]

I wish I were an investigator 'cause I would have investigated the shit out of Saint. However I should really reread and stuff

[Amrun]

Why wouldn't I want to be out, as town?

I am, legitimately, in the lynch pool today. I'd put myself there if I were someone else. That is patently bad for town.

It gives me horrible wifom about why am I alive.

Who is alive today is a key piece to the puzzle.

Rach and mhork are obvious. Here either scum or scum is hoping we'll doubt their scum claims.

Ghostlin and penguin_alien are obvious as well, since they're either scum or likely to be lynched today.

Last night's kill was odd. Why him -- why not me? More importantly, why not cdb?

If Ghostlin is scum, leaving cdb alive is quite dangerous. Cdb is unlikely to be lynched and a strong player. He's much more influential than who actually died. It begs the question, then, why not him. This is a significant part of my paranoia on cdb today.

Why not saint? This is a little more cut and dry. Even though he's more universally town read, he does a bunch if stupid shit that's easy to attack for both town and scum.

Some of my reads are clearly wrong. That's why I'M alive. The question is, now, which ones