Calvin and Hobbes Mafia(GAME OVER! Grownups Mafia Wins!)

[Desperado]

Varsoon, obviously me and Desperado are opposite alignments

It isn't obvious.

[Rubicon]

TheIrishPope: Null.
Psyche: Town.
penguin_alien: Null.
Rubicon: Town.
Skullduggery: Town.
boxxy: Scum.
Desperado: Town.
Metal Sonic: Scum.
T S O: Town.
TiphaineDeath: Null-town.
EddieFenix: Null.
Nobody Special: Town.
Dante: Scum.

Thanks, Varsoon.

1) Did Varsoon's response make you think he was town? I notice he's not on your list.

2) Why is Nobody Special town?

3) Dante / boxxy / Metal Sonic cases, in your own words?

[TheIrishPope]

How could both of us possibly be Town together

[Rubicon]

Desperado, thoughts on the game state? I don't think you've said anything alignment-related in over a week.

[Varsoon]

@TSO: No prob. Honestly, I hate using nulls, but it helps people who are more used to the gameplay on this site.

@TIP: I proposed the scum is between you, Desperado, and Boxxy, given the claims made by each of you. If boxxy turns up town, then I'll narrow to either you or Desperado. You still feel more town to me than him. Also, to reflect this:

Vote: Boxxy

Honestly, Boxxy and PenguinAlien are the only two players I feel really good about calling scum.

@Rubicon: My role PM has flavor, and I already said enough about it in thread without quoting the thing. Anything more will get me modkilled, likely.

[Varsoon]

I really think Boxxy should be today's lynch.

[Rubicon]

I'm mostly curious about how Monkey related "snowman" to "neighborizer". My flavor connects Moe bullying Calvin into playing baseball with me being the paranoid baseball bat owner. Anything like that for your role?

[Skullduggery]

Begrudgingly, I would choose anyone over a no lynch.

Yeah, cool. You didn't answer my question, though. Which three players would you most support lynching today and why?

Why is Boxxy Town, Eddie? His wagon analysis is just...yuck.

Going on a gut feeling right now with him.

You'll have to do better than that. You can't prove or disprove "gut." Why is Boxxy Town?

As far as your 2nd question

TIP (I don't trust him)
TD (Not sure about his claim gambit)
To be decided (too many candidates)

And you aren't voting for anyone because...?

TheIrishPope: Null.
Psyche: Town.
penguin_alien: Null.
Rubicon: Town.
Skullduggery: Town.
boxxy: Scum.
Desperado: Town.
Metal Sonic: Scum.
T S O: Town.
TiphaineDeath: Null-town.
EddieFenix: Null.
Nobody Special: Town.
Dante: Scum.

Thanks, Varsoon.

And you aren't voting for anyone because...?

Also, why is Nobody Special Town? Don't give us a cop-out answer either. Link to specific posts, please.

There's no way in hell it was all town on the zoidberg wagon.

The more I think about it, the more I don't like Boxxy's wagon analysis -- this observation in particular. You guys saw how much heat Zoidberg had on him on day two. Just about the entire player list was out for blood and I don't recall seeing a single player come to his aid. There's a reason why I haven't looked too closely at the Zoidberg wagon to find Scum: this is one instance where a player was likely going to be lynched regardless of whether there was Scum on his wagon or not.

Just about all of Boxxy's 1332 looks like an effort to throw us off track and make us believe that there is definitely Scum on Zoidberg's wagon. When/if Boxxy flips Scum, I would feel pretty confident saying that none of the names on that wagon are his buddies.

[Varsoon]

Fairly certain of Boxxy scum, Skull. I really think it's the lynch we should do today.

@Rubicon: Explained it earlier in 782 . Snowman is grotesque, eventually melts or is destroyed by Calvin's Parents, and is usually tied to Calvin's creative outlet, buddying with Hobbes/other characters, and the heartwarming winter stories in C&H.

[Varsoon]

Er, the right post is 787. Dunno why that messed up. Just ISO me for it.

[TheIrishPope]

I responded. Anyone.

[Varsoon]

TIP: As I said, either you, Desperado, or Boxxy is scum. Boxxy is the weakest link.

[TheIrishPope]

Varsoon, I am disappointed. You should sheep me more.

[Skullduggery]

I responded. Anyone.

You responded, but you didn't answer -- presumably because you can't count to three.

Whatever, it doesn't matter. Your answer doesn't make you any less worthless. Vote Boxxy with me. He qualifies as "anyone," does he not?

[TheIrishPope]

I said only close to deadline, so chill

[Varsoon]

What's the deadline? Four days from now or something?

TIP, I'm sheeping Skull, since Skull is the only voice of reason in this whole damn game.

[TheIrishPope]

Does it mean she's right? Does sanity mean she will win this game?

[Skullduggery]

I can't make any promises, Pope, but I'm trying my best.

[Metal Sonic]

varsoon

i am already active in the game

i read the whole damn thing do you know how tiring that is


dante is really really bad


boxxy is scummy

and nobody special is not very special


choose 1

[T S O]

Skull perhaps frog can sub in and we'll tunnel you

But on an iPod ATM. I'll answer q's tonight.

[Varsoon]

@MS: What I mean is to put forward your cases, back them with evidence, be transparent as far as your alignment goes, and be active in the thread.
Also, I've already chose one. Boxxy's my bet for scum.

[EddieFenix]

Why is Boxxy Town, Eddie? His wagon analysis is just...yuck.

Going on a gut feeling right now with him.

You'll have to do better than that. You can't prove or disprove "gut." Why is Boxxy Town?

As far as your 2nd question

TIP (I don't trust him)
TD (Not sure about his claim gambit)
To be decided (too many candidates)

And you aren't voting for anyone because...?

1.) The last analysis post left me with a town intent/impression. If Boxxy could post more, I could examine their posts over more. It's still a gut read and I know that you can't prove or disprove "gut"... But, I can't help BUT trust it at the moment.
2.) See day 2. I'm going to drag my feet as far as a vote goes so we can get everything onto the table and have every bit of discussion out.

[Metal Sonic]

@MS:

What I mean is to put forward your cases, back them with evidence,

be transparent as far as your alignment goes, and be active in the thread.
Also, I've already chose one. Boxxy's my bet for scum.

that shit is hard, btw

not gonna do that till Day 5, 1 hour essays per player are not my thing

however you can give me a specific target ( for example, boxxy) and i can do a powerful analysis



if he is scum i will push hard if he is town i will defend hard

thats my policy - if i put 1 hour of proper shit into something i expect it to be followed


yes that is what i will do and what i will not do

[Varsoon]

If you ask me, this game is dragging its feet.
Everyone needs to be transparent about who they think is town, scum, and inbetween.
That way, we can get some damn trajectory going on this game.

P-EDIT:
@MS: Yeah, man, it's pretty difficult.
You and I and Skull all agree that Boxxy is likely scum. I'd like to read your case as to why.
I know how you feel about putting time into a case/it not being followed. However, we're at a bit of a pinch since only one scum is down and we've lost 6 town. At this rate, we won't win. We all need to do our best to catch and lynch scum.

[Metal Sonic]

fine

i'll skim gimme (1 min haha) 5 mins