Harry Potter and the Philosopher's Stone Mafia Game Over

[Saint]

I would keep you alive, if I was scum, Amrun

Penguin, can you quit it with the obnoxious questions? You've been doing it all game

[Saint]

hammer yesterday is null and not alignment indicative as i would hammer as any alignment
TMT was on my ass all game, and I'm a self preservationist
I Wouldn't be admitting this as scum, tbh

The defense of Broseidon was correct, no? How can you ATTACK me for me calling the setup correctly? Why the fuck would scum call for an unvote?
Lynching a townie wasn't necessarily bad play, though, and I suspect there could be more to this puzzle than meets the eye
The name claim with Harry being VT made me think Hermione was either VT or a fakeclaim for scum which would automatically win the game for them from me(because i'm not lynching ahermione vt claim when harry flipped vt it just makes sense to me from a moderator standpoint k thx bye)

[Lord Mhork]

I'm wanting to lynch Saint again... RachMarie stop me >.<

Who is scum then, Saint?

[RachMarie]

Stay strong brother we got this in the bag if we stick together...

[RachMarie]

im seamus or sheamus
let me check his full name
im a vt
the red haired kid

wait a minute...

the red haired kids were the Weasley family WTF? Seamus was from Ireland but he was not a Weasley....

[Lord Mhork]

I'm, like, 90% sure that Saint is scum. If I was right--again--and the town all pushed me away, I'm going to swear off listening to anything about meta ever and tunnel even harder in games. I promise. >:T

K then RachMarie. PA, CDB, Amrun, Ghostlin. Where is the scum?

[RachMarie]

Lets look at the claims

CDB one shot commuter Albus Dumbledore.... pretty sure this one should stay in the town pile.....

PA VT Neville Longbottom

Ghostlin VT Ron Weasley

Amrun VT Hagrid

Saint VT Seamus Finnegan

Um Amrun are you serious? You wonder why they would NK a JK (even if he only had 2 shots) over someone else? We dont know for sure if they have some form of role cop after all, and we need to keep that in mind....

[Lord Mhork]

Alright so I'm pretty sure at least two of the VTs are fake. I'm leaning to go for amrun first. What do you think?

[ChannelDelibird]

Mhork, tell me how this game makes sense if Ghostlin and penguin_alien aren't scum, because I don't see it at the moment.

I'm done with marathon weekend now so I'll go back to my reread shortly.

[ChannelDelibird]

CDB, why commute last night? As opposed to on an earlier night? Or seeing if we can lynch scum today and so have the breathing room of MyLo down the road if you used it later?

Earlier on, I thought I was safe to not use it because I thought the masons would start dying a lot earlier. Assuming three scum, I knew we would have to massclaim today so, if I kept the commute until after that and the numbers started to thin, I felt like it would just look like I was gambiting scum if I successfully soaked a kill in the late/endgame. If I'd been another player looking in, that's what I would have suspected.

Anyway, even if I had soaked the kill on a previous night, that would still give us the breathing room of MyLo down the road.

[Ghostlin]

Ghostlin, what's your take on the BROseidon and TMT lynches?

TMT was a drag and not someone that Town really wanted in LYLO. At the time, I felt the idea of him being scum wasn't unlikely; then again, I thought Fuzzy was scum with the mind melting logic that Archangel was obv town with the horrible, awful, scumtastic claim of super saint.

BROsideo, yeah, I get Town thought he was bad, but I didn't see it, frankly; his points seemed cognizant and he had replies to the points people made against him. I was away for most of that lynch, but I wouldn't have gone with BRO as the play that day. I'd probably have much rather have lynched CDB, who's tunnelled on me but hasn't done much about it, Saint, who again, I'm having trouble actual scumhunting since Day 1, and either Amrun, who's been Town to me most of the game, but I ask the question now, is she Town now? Why is she still here?

[penguin_alien]

hammer yesterday is null and not alignment indicative as i would hammer as any alignment
TMT was on my ass all game, and I'm a self preservationist
I Wouldn't be admitting this as scum, tbh

The defense of Broseidon was correct, no? How can you ATTACK me for me calling the setup correctly? Why the fuck would scum call for an unvote?
Lynching a townie wasn't necessarily bad play, though, and I suspect there could be more to this puzzle than meets the eye
The name claim with Harry being VT made me think Hermione was either VT or a fakeclaim for scum which would automatically win the game for them from me(because i'm not lynching ahermione vt claim when harry flipped vt it just makes sense to me from a moderator standpoint k thx bye)

As far as 'calling the set-up correctly,' scum would have known that BRO would flip town. Yet a VT claim was highly unlikely to be enough to derail the wagon. You get to be off what was a mislynch while the lynch would still go through. I see plenty of scum motivation there.

And you think someone 'being on your ass' in a game where one is supposed to scum hunt is a good reason to hammer their lynch without a claim? So, did you have an actual scum read on TMT or not?

CDB, why commute last night? As opposed to on an earlier night? Or seeing if we can lynch scum today and so have the breathing room of MyLo down the road if you used it later?

Earlier on, I thought I was safe to not use it because I thought the masons would start dying a lot earlier. Assuming three scum, I knew we would have to massclaim today so, if I kept the commute until after that and the numbers started to thin, I felt like it would just look like I was gambiting scum if I successfully soaked a kill in the late/endgame. If I'd been another player looking in, that's what I would have suspected.

Anyway, even if I had soaked the kill on a previous night, that would still give us the breathing room of MyLo down the road.

Makes sense, especially the part about avoiding looking like scum no-killing to bolster their image. Zero interest in lynching here at present.

Ghostlin, what's your take on the BROseidon and TMT lynches?

TMT was a drag and not someone that Town really wanted in LYLO. At the time, I felt the idea of him being scum wasn't unlikely; then again, I thought Fuzzy was scum with the mind melting logic that Archangel was obv town with the horrible, awful, scumtastic claim of super saint.

BROsideo, yeah, I get Town thought he was bad, but I didn't see it, frankly; his points seemed cognizant and he had replies to the points people made against him. I was away for most of that lynch, but I wouldn't have gone with BRO as the play that day. I'd probably have much rather have lynched CDB, who's tunnelled on me but hasn't done much about it, Saint, who again, I'm having trouble actual scumhunting since Day 1, and either Amrun, who's been Town to me most of the game, but I ask the question now, is she Town now? Why is she still here?

Do you think if Amrun is town, she's more lynchable than fuzzy was from a scum perspective? Same question to Amrun: RachMarie's point about a possible role cop in play aside, would fuzzy have been in your lynch pool today? Because you had him as pretty firm town in #740 and #742 from what I can tell.

[Amrun]

I would keep you alive, if I was scum, Amrun

Penguin, can you quit it with the obnoxious questions? You've been doing it all game

Oh, I would have kept me alive too. Does that mean I can't have HOPE?!

I'm not lynching saint today.

Rachel's post about a cop really bothers me. increases my mason paranoia exponentially.

Penguin_alien, out of saint/cdb/fuzzy, fuzzy's town read would have been the first to fail. Like saint, he's an easy player to attack which can be tempting for scum to keep around, so his death was quite odd for me over someone like masons/cdb.

[Lord Mhork]

VOTE: amrun

Can you explain your mason paranoia?

[Amrun]

You idiot what the fuck is wrong with you.

Jesus.

Why the fuck would masons who claimed day 1 but are alive in lylo need an EXPLANATION?
Rach's post reeked of inside information, and now you vote like an idiot. Ugh

[Lord Mhork]

Your explosion looks sketch. I don't like it.

UNVOTE: amrun

[Lord Mhork]

What do you think, Rach?

[RachMarie]

I dont know for SURE what the scum have Amrun....

I just know that scum in general would definitely want a JK dead...

Mhork well I am not sure on that I need to really look at ALL of the VT claims and ISO them.

[Lord Mhork]

Yup. I get that.

[ChannelDelibird]

Mhork, you've briefly voted Amrun and you're 90% sure on Saint. I'll get back to those guys after my morning shift (during which posting now) but that means at least one of Ghostlin and penguin is town. Just ... how? Explain one to me. I don't understand how this game makes sense if they're not scum.

[Saint]

It's PA and Amrun
look at the nameclaims
...Ron is probably VT, just like Harry and Hermione, logically, from my perspective

[Saint]

im seamus or sheamus
let me check his full name
im a vt
the red haired kid

wait a minute...

the red haired kids were the Weasley family WTF? Seamus was from Ireland but he was not a Weasley....

he looks redhaired to me
not strawberry red but darker

[Amrun]

Then why have I been riding Pa's ass for days?

[Amrun]

Also why assume 2 scum?

[Saint]

im just sticking to the facts, hon