In post 1548, Amrun wrote:Also, he suspected NS since very early on and called NS straight scum, whereas SD didn't really do that.
I need to look for that then. I'm still baffled that anyone could have a superhard scumread on NS given that he has meta of being a lurksack independent of alignment.
SD was barely posting for whatever that means. Im excited to hear qwints cough up some town/scum lists though.
In post 1411, pirate mollie wrote:re: safety dance. I think he is lynchbait material but he has done fuckall this entire game. having said that I think amrun needs to go first. hwen she was laying into me the other night it felt scummy.
In post 1411, pirate mollie wrote:re: safety dance. I think he is lynchbait material but he has done fuckall this entire game. having said that I think amrun needs to go first. hwen she was laying into me the other night it felt scummy.
@AP: Here are things I've previously said about enomis that I still believe.
In post 1397, Amrun wrote:To put it simply, that post was not engineered with a survival mindset. I'm pretty sure it's just his reads, and they happen to be fencesitty. That's how he's been all game, and it's weirded me out, but re-reading, his reads have progressed in a way that makes sense, given that he is as cautious as that.
I opened our qt the way I did for a reason. I wanted to see if enomis was interested in gaining a town read from me.
At first it appeared that he was, but it's now abundantly clear that he's more interested in determining if I am scum than being town read by me. That's what town does.
P-edit: yes USUALLY. This is not the first,'or the last, time that ns has done nothing at all as scum. That's why his meta is so successful. He's very good at being unreadable.
In post 1413, Amrun wrote:@wisdom: I think I see what the confusion is, then. I never said "always" or "never." When I said anything at all, I said "usually." In absence of usually, I assumed that would be understood because its common sense. I don't see the point of using wishy washy language when we all know there are no absolutes.
You said that enomis reads genuine because scum would not post the reads he did. That is a generalization regarding what scum would generally do/don't. You did not explain why enomis-scum would not do that in this certain situation.
Except I did. I said it even before you and I started having a conversation about it.
Enomis came in and didn't even try to push the alternatives as scum, even as a compromise. It's not suspicious to push one of these people as scum; it's very safe, since all of the popular targets are on the block right now. He's not fabricating reads because scum fabricating reads isn't likely to fabricate those reads at that precise time.
In addition, when looking over his iso in the process of compiling my reads, I found his early push on Elyse both good and genuine. Sure, none of these are like ... town slips. I just think he's town. Period.
My LEAST sure town read is probably Elyse, if you are interested.
But it's not just that. It's minor things that collectively make me think I'm not seeing town-mollie. Like how she's now claiming to doubt her Majiffy townread, despite it being so strong early on (and for silly reasons too). Like she not getting my "town signals" and still waffling on her read on me (in other games I was actually scummy as town yet she still townread me, now I'm feeling I'm being very obvtown yet she doesn't). Like how I'm getting an impression that she doesn't give many fucks about this game - and I remember her stating that she's usually lazy and doesn't care as scum.
I could actually agree with the scumteam Amrun is seeing. With Venmar or Elyse as wildcards, probably.
I've had her as weak scum since Day 1, and only near the end of the day did I decide she felt marginally better (like, maybe null). I kind of wish I'd had the time/energy/not gotten distracted and pushed her harder day 1, but alas. Now, she is my second strongest scum read after Grim.
I think the main reason I haven't really pushed pirate mollie more is that I lack "reasons" that might convince other people. So I'm pleasantly surprised to see support here.
EBWODP: Ok. She told me she wasn't going to waver on it. In fact she lightly poked at me because she thought I was trying to get her to waver on that read for some reason. I wouldn't say she is doing that at all, the opposite really.
I wasnt aware anyone really suspected mollie until just now.
I don't think scum-mollie goes out of her way to inform me that Im not actually confirmed town as scum. I think scum are more likely to just sheep the general sentiment that Im obvious town and not try and buttheads with me over something so dumb.
Ergh, sorry for triple posting, but maybe later when I have more time, I will try to compile something on her, because I can do it if I really try but I've been so busy (v/la for so long, plus still generally busy) that I just haven't had time to do anything but react to what's in front of me.
p-edit: Yeah, I have since Day 1. I got distracted by Majiffy or I would have pushed her harder. I has a sadz.
p-edit 2: Come on, now, that has OBVIOUS scum motivation! And it's not like she was feeling pressure or the need to not butt heads with people.
In post 1567, AngryPidgeon wrote:I don't think scum-mollie goes out of her way to inform me that Im not actually confirmed town as scum. I think scum are more likely to just sheep the general sentiment that Im obvious town and not try and buttheads with me over something so dumb.
That's not a bad point, however consider the fact that this is nightless. In games with nights, scum can just go with the flow and call the obvtown obvtown, then nightkill them. Here they'll be at a loss if they townread someone too hard.
And if you add the fact she's already buddying Majiffy into the blend.. it becomes apparent that she cannot afford getting another strong townread like that.
I think that's why she refuses to strongly townread me like she would normally do, as well as why she's starting to "freak out" about Majiffy.