Calvin and Hobbes Mafia(GAME OVER! Grownups Mafia Wins!)

[Psyche]

If it's a delayed NK, then that's a good thing.

vote Dante

his varsoons vote in light of the boxxy flip is as suspect as ever

[Psyche]

Rubicon, lol.

[Rubicon]

Nobody Special jumping on that wagon right after the hammer was pretty shady too.

[Psyche]

I've seen that before from town but I don't want to say so since I want him dead too.

[T S O]

vote Dante

It's his scum play meta, and I'm a lamb.

[penguin_alien]

At the risk of having weirdness happen, I'll point out that we had 13 alive post-boxxy flip, and now it's 11. The missing person is almost certainly effectively dead (if he were silenced , usually that's announced in-thread) and TheIrishPope wasn't included on the day start PM.

Dante seems like a fine lynch. Wanting to policy lynch a claimed miller at that point yesterday is all sorts of blech.

[Rubicon]

Also "disappeared in the night" doesn't really fit a delayed kill.

@ T S O: How do you know it's his scum play meta?

[Rubicon]

So basically TIP is dead but we don't get his alignment.

[Dante]

Still think the policy lynch on Varsoon is the correct call...but I was wrong on boxxy...obviously you guys need to decide

I'll try to read a little later on...and offer more commentary.

[Psyche]

I have some sketchily out-of-game reasons to think TIP was scum that I actually talked to Varsoons about. Is it possible that TIP could be scum and and has a role that hides his flip to prevent association tells?

[T S O]

Rubicon: I died n1 in a Large Game which Dante was scum in, and he posted just like this.

[Rubicon]

Is Dante an alt or...?

[T S O]

It was Dante, iirc.

[Rubicon]

He doesn't have any other games in his post history.

I'm thinking http://wiki.mafiascum.net/index.php?title=Janitor.

[T S O]

It was WWE Believe in the Shield, btw.

[Rubicon]

I have some sketchily out-of-game reasons to think TIP was scum that I actually talked to Varsoons about.

Wanna share?

[T S O]

Yeah, it turns out the guy in WWE was Darthe. >?_?>

Nice catch, Rubi.

[Psyche]

In site chat, He said somewhat wistfully "I've never been a town PR before" without any prompting. I don't think he would have said that in that context if he were a town PR right now. :/

But I feeel icky for bringing that into this thread, though it has affected my thinking about his alugnment.

[penguin_alien]

I have some sketchily out-of-game reasons to think TIP was scum that I actually talked to Varsoons about. Is it possible that TIP could be scum and and has a role that hides his flip to prevent association tells?

Or scum could get a limited use cannibal style kill like Donner Party set-up.

T S O, is Dante's posting here scummy in contrast to his town play? Or is that unknown.

Dante, you've known since the last day ended that you were wrong about boxxy. So where do you go from here?

[Rubicon]

In site chat, He said somewhat wistfully "I've never been a town PR before" without any prompting. I don't think he would have said that in that context if he were a town PR right now. :/

But I feeel icky for bringing that into this thread, though it has affected my thinking about his alugnment.

Hmm.
His wiki says he was JOAT in Micro 172 and Innocent Child in Micro 187.

[Varsoon]

Okay, so what the fuck was up with the NK results? I've never seen that in a game yet, can someone explain it to me?

Also, I agree with a Dante lynch, but I think rushing the day would be far too easy at this point--that's something scum would want, given they are winning at this point.

I think that Penguin Alien's willingness to rush out the Dante lynch and pressure hard in light of how much P_A was lurking before is really odd. It doesn't fit, but lurkers always give me bad vibes.

For now,

Vote: Penguin_alien

What's up with that?

[Dante]

Rubicon: I died n1 in a Large Game which Dante was scum in, and he posted just like this.

You've never played a game with me.

[Psyche]

In site chat, He said somewhat wistfully "I've never been a town PR before" without any prompting. I don't think he would have said that in that context if he were a town PR right now. :/

But I feeel icky for bringing that into this thread, though it has affected my thinking about his alugnment.

Hmm.
His wiki says he was JOAT in Micro 172 and Innocent Child in Micro 187.

probably best to stick with the "he got NKed gangnam style" hypothesis for now, then

dante is as good as dead to me

[Skullduggery]

Hrm. If I understand the Wiki correctly, a Sidekick is basically a Self-Redirector, right? That doesn't really explain why Pope didn't see Desperado targeting Boxxy on night two. There must be some other shenanigans afoot.

Or scum could get a limited use cannibal style kill like Donner Party set-up.

This seems more likely than Janitor. From what I understand, a Janitor kill will still indicate which player died but hide their role and alignment. This kill(?) hid

everything

.

Psyche probably killed Desperado. Just calling that now.

What makes you say that?

i admit it
i was wrong about metal sonic

How did you come to this conclusion?

T S O, is Dante's posting here scummy in contrast to his town play? Or is that unknown.

T S O confused Dante for another player. This is the only game that Dante is in, so it's pointless to meta him.

Guys, Varsoons is town and if he isn't you will know by tomorrow. Promise.

Care to elaborate on this?

[Psyche]

i read his posts and saw innocuous

not atm thx