Calvin and Hobbes Mafia(GAME OVER! Grownups Mafia Wins!)

[Dante]

I have some sketchily out-of-game reasons to think TIP was scum that I actually talked to Varsoons about. Is it possible that TIP could be scum and and has a role that hides his flip to prevent association tells?

Or scum could get a limited use cannibal style kill like Donner Party set-up.

T S O, is Dante's posting here scummy in contrast to his town play? Or is that unknown.

Dante, you've known since the last day ended that you were wrong about boxxy. So where do you go from here?

I'm re-reading now...I tried to force some action on MS...I also focused too much on the inactives...boxxy put some narrative out there...better than what I've saw from the others I had scum reads on...I'd could argue the benefits of a Varsoon lynch...but don't want to muddy the waters at this point...boxxy appeared to mirror my thoughts to get me to agree...I'd been pushing a Varsoon lynch since his claim...

[Psyche]

oh ok then

unvote

dante is just bait

[Rubicon]

Dante, why do you think Desp was killed?

[Dante]

If it's a delayed NK, then that's a good thing.

vote Dante

his varsoons vote in light of the boxxy flip is as suspect as ever

Looking for the quick lynch...wow.

[Dante]

Nobody Special jumping on that wagon right after the hammer was pretty shady too.

His ISO looks awful as well.

[Dante]

At the risk of having weirdness happen, I'll point out that we had 13 alive post-boxxy flip, and now it's 11. The missing person is almost certainly effectively dead (if he were silenced , usually that's announced in-thread) and TheIrishPope wasn't included on the day start PM.

Dante seems like a fine lynch. Wanting to policy lynch a claimed miller at that point yesterday is all sorts of blech.

I still don't see what's wrong with that...yeah...I was wrong on boxxy...but at some point we need to eliminate the wifom with Varsoon...just saying.

[Psyche]

If it's a delayed NK, then that's a good thing.

vote Dante

his varsoons vote in light of the boxxy flip is as suspect as ever

Looking for the quick lynch...wow.

uh no

[Rubicon]

I propose we lynch TIP just to make life difficult for Monkey.

[Psyche]

At the risk of having weirdness happen, I'll point out that we had 13 alive post-boxxy flip, and now it's 11. The missing person is almost certainly effectively dead (if he were silenced , usually that's announced in-thread) and TheIrishPope wasn't included on the day start PM.

Dante seems like a fine lynch. Wanting to policy lynch a claimed miller at that point yesterday is all sorts of blech.

I still don't see what's wrong with that...yeah...I was wrong on boxxy...but at some point we need to eliminate the wifom with Varsoon...just saying.

varsoon is town there is no wifom
could he be a scum neighborizer? sure.
is he? no.

One way or another this will be made explicitly clear at some convenient point in the game — probably after one of us dies
until then just focus on someone more scummy

like ns

vote ns

]

[Dante]

Despe had an anti-town role and on the chopping block. Come onnn.

I'm confused by this...can you clarify?

[Rubicon]

Dante, why do you think Desp was killed?

[Psyche]

It's weird that he was chosen for the NK since his ability was harmful to the town and he was under scrutiny that might have led to a lynch.

[Dante]

Dante, why do you think Desp was killed?

I'm still trying to figure out what role he had...originally assumed he was a Bus Driver...then I read Skull's post suggesting a Sidekick...the way I read the roles doesn't explain what happened last night.

[Dante]

Dante, why do you think Desp was killed?

ninja'd.

[Dante]

It's weird that he was chosen for the NK since his ability was harmful to the town and he was under scrutiny that might have led to a lynch.

huh?

how was his ability harmful to town?

what role do you think Despo was?

[Rubicon]

Dante, why do you think Desp was killed?

I'm still trying to figure out what role he had...originally assumed he was a Bus Driver...then I read Skull's post suggesting a Sidekick...the way I read the roles doesn't explain what happened last night.

okay wow

[Rubicon]

That's either a town slip or really clever scum.

[Rubicon]

Or I might be misreading.

[Dante]

Dante, why do you think Desp was killed?

I'm still trying to figure out what role he had...originally assumed he was a Bus Driver...then I read Skull's post suggesting a Sidekick...the way I read the roles doesn't explain what happened last night.

okay wow

ok...wow...what?

what role do you think he had?

do you have any ideas?

[Dante]

That's either a town slip or really clever scum.

you've lost me...

[Psyche]

looking at his iso it seems that the desp nk is only justified as a poor case of doc-dodging

[Psyche]

TheIrishPope
Psyche
Varsoon
penguin_alien
Rubicon
Skullduggery
Metal Sonic
T S O
TiphaineDeath
EddieFenix
Nobody Special
Dante

So it was suggested that we're looking at two 3-person scum teams, right?

That would mean 4 of 11 are scum and if we mislynch here and two nks occur again, the town loses its majority.

Today is important, then.

[Psyche]

(whether tip is alive or not)

[Rubicon]

Dante, why do you think Desp was killed?

I'm still trying to figure out what role he had...originally assumed he was a Bus Driver...then I read Skull's post suggesting a Sidekick...the way I read the roles doesn't explain what happened last night.

Can you explain your thought process here in more detail? What's confusing you exactly? <-- these aren't very good questions but I'm trying to figure something out so work with me.

[Rubicon]

@ Psyche - I wonder what happens if the town loses its majority but the scum teams are uneven (1 slimy girl vs 3 on the other team). Does the game continue?