The Red Wedding - The Goose is Loose

[Generic]

Metal Sonic does the objectively Most Bad Thing of D1,

Do you consider all fake day kills the objectively most BAD THING OF DAY 1?

Because if you do you're probably dumb.

It caused discussion and generated activity. So yeah.

The only thing it accomplished was getting him lynched. Can you point to some good discussion and activity that it generated?

PEdit: Generic, are you saying that I can't have multiple reads? I don't understand what you're criticizing exactly. I haven't even come close to abandoning it, what gave you that idea

And what is "convenient" about it? I started poking her with suspicious intent (that's what scumhunting is) and because she immediately voted me I no longer get to vote her without it being labeled OMGUS? What do you consider her vote?

You flit though from so tunnelled over it I must make comment on it cos you demanded it so, to considering macmollie the utter threat.

Which is the stronger case you have desperado?

[macmollie]

So when I stop voting Nexus the lead goes away?

Yes, the case on Nexus revolves around his ISO being filled with scumreads that come from players doing bad things, but then Metal Sonic does the objectively Most Bad Thing of D1, but Nexus says he's bad but town? It's a scum motivated contradiction.

I don't even know what you're implying in your last line. I can't even commit to the vote? How do you figure that?

And please explain how that's me OMGUSing mollie when I started the conversation by FOSing her, and she is pretty blatantly making up her meta read on me? She's approaching me as if she knows what town desperado looks like but there's really no way for her to know that for sure. You know how else I know she hasn't actually researched my meta? She thinks I'm terrible at playing scum.

well if you flip scum I will have a baseline won't I

and I like to think that I am not retarded at this game and can sometimes spot scum w/o any meta at all.

want proof? sometimes it is early, sometimes it is late and sometimes never at all

you look scummy desp

That isn't what you said. You said "this is not town desp." Meaning you know what town desp looks like and this isn't it.

You

clearly

implied you were using meta to establish your read and are now backtracking.

why were you so worried that I was ignoring you?

[Desperado]

Metal Sonic does the objectively Most Bad Thing of D1,

Do you consider all fake day kills the objectively most BAD THING OF DAY 1?

Because if you do you're probably dumb.

It caused discussion and generated activity. So yeah.

The only thing it accomplished was getting him lynched. Can you point to some good discussion and activity that it generated?

PEdit: Generic, are you saying that I can't have multiple reads? I don't understand what you're criticizing exactly. I haven't even come close to abandoning it, what gave you that idea

And what is "convenient" about it? I started poking her with suspicious intent (that's what scumhunting is) and because she immediately voted me I no longer get to vote her without it being labeled OMGUS? What do you consider her vote?

You flit though from so tunnelled over it I must make comment on it cos you demanded it so, to considering macmollie the utter threat.

Which is the stronger case you have desperado?

I'm sorry, are we at the deadline or something? It honestly sounds like you're "accusing" me of scumhunting.

Neither case is even close to complete.

@ Mollie: because I was reading you as town and I feel confident about my ability to catch mac if you guys rolled scum anyway.

[macmollie]

Time for Kill 'Em or Keep 'Em!

Kill 'Em -
Dekes
Desperado
Cabd
xReckonerx
macmollie
ChannelDelibird
Ankamius
Venmar
Amrun

Keep 'Em -
Tierce
Generic
tsunami
Nexus


Oh boy, looks like death is on the menu. I need to sort through the huge for-death pile and try to keep some more.

why is cdb in your kill em pile

[inHimshallibe]

Hasn't impressed me and very finicky voting preferences.

[Amrun]

Cdb is town okay

So am I but I feel like everyone should see objectively that cdb is town

[macmollie]

I do not like Desperado's case. (stick that in your pipe, macmollie )

then mebbe you will be able to eke out some town cred by voting him cos I don't think we are seeing town desp here

it will buy you some time I guess

It's possible, though at the moment if I were to vote one of your scumreads it would be Dekes.

dekes will get himself lynched unless he blazes into the game with all barrels firing. I am not worried about dekes as much as I am worried about scummy looking role-fishing you and terrible should be today's lynch desp.

but how sweet of you to suddenly take an interest in my scumreads.

tell me moar about how protown you are by laying out the foundation for further analysis later in the game I mean I guess you aren't worried about a nk huh.

I'm your Huckleberry.

I try to at least take some note of everyone's scumreads. Certainly does help later in the game. To that end, I should make some death tiers.

nah. you are more like tom sawyer if you are town.

you went from a scum pool of 3 to a scum pool of ten million.

explain that

[Ankamius]

Inhim's "Keep 'em" list is good. I agree with 3 of them and can accept the 4th. He can go into the town pile.

[inHimshallibe]

I do not like Desperado's case. (stick that in your pipe, macmollie ;))

then mebbe you will be able to eke out some town cred by voting him cos I don't think we are seeing town desp here

it will buy you some time I guess

It's possible, though at the moment if I were to vote one of your scumreads it would be Dekes.

dekes will get himself lynched unless he blazes into the game with all barrels firing. I am not worried about dekes as much as I am worried about scummy looking role-fishing you and terrible should be today's lynch desp.

but how sweet of you to suddenly take an interest in my scumreads.

tell me moar about how protown you are by laying out the foundation for further analysis later in the game I mean I guess you aren't worried about a nk huh.

I'm your Huckleberry.

I try to at least take some note of everyone's scumreads. Certainly does help later in the game. To that end, I should make some death tiers.

nah. you are more like tom sawyer if you are town.

you went from a scum pool of 3 to a scum pool of ten million.

explain that

For-Death and Not-For-Death do not exclusively mean Scum and Town, as you should be able to properly interpret. I'm just taking those that I don't particularly feel are Town and lumping them into the For-Death pile.

And then, nowhere did I say cabd, reck, macmollie were my only 3 scumreads, or did I actually call them my scumreads.

I specifically stated, in my incomplete analysis of Day 1 voting trends, that if cabd were scum i'd be killing reck/macmollie. Then I gave my opinion on which of those I'd be willing to run up. In the vacuum, Reck is truly a scumread, cabd is like taking care of unfinished business, and you would be if I were going to start barking up a suspected PR's tree.

[macmollie]

Hasn't impressed me and very finicky voting preferences.

so why no push?

[inHimshallibe]

Hasn't impressed me and very finicky voting preferences.

so why no push?

Reck's the prize today imo.

[macmollie]

For-Death and Not-For-Death do not exclusively mean Scum and Town, as you should be able to properly interpret. I'm just taking those that I don't particularly feel are Town and lumping them into the For-Death pile.

And then, nowhere did I say cabd, reck, macmollie were my only 3 scumreads, or did I actually call them my scumreads.

I specifically stated, in my incomplete analysis of Day 1 voting trends, that if cabd were scum i'd be killing reck/macmollie. Then I gave my opinion on which of those I'd be willing to run up. In the vacuum, Reck is truly a scumread, cabd is like taking care of unfinished business, and you would be if I were going to start barking up a suspected PR's tree.

why is scumreading cabd taking care of business?

[inHimshallibe]

For-Death and Not-For-Death do not exclusively mean Scum and Town, as you should be able to properly interpret. I'm just taking those that I don't particularly feel are Town and lumping them into the For-Death pile.

And then, nowhere did I say cabd, reck, macmollie were my only 3 scumreads, or did I actually call them my scumreads.

I specifically stated, in my incomplete analysis of Day 1 voting trends, that if cabd were scum i'd be killing reck/macmollie. Then I gave my opinion on which of those I'd be willing to run up. In the vacuum, Reck is truly a scumread, cabd is like taking care of unfinished business, and you would be if I were going to start barking up a suspected PR's tree.

why is scumreading cabd taking care of business?

Cabd (KA) had an immense wagon on him, it ran alongside other options, reached a climax, and was dismantled. Oodles of information.

[macmollie]

Hasn't impressed me and very finicky voting preferences.

so why no push?

Reck's the prize today imo.

no

[ChannelDelibird]

You're weird, inHim.

[tsunami]

Tammy--no, I get the Amrun part, that one clicked and I don't think her play is quite the same either (I had a similar "huh, let's leave this read for later" Yesterday with Cabd and have since explained it), I was trying to figure out if you actually have/had a Townread on inHim or if that was just for show when I brought up the slot.

Oh okay, that makes sense. My leaning town read on that slot is based on me thinking bro sounded genuine in those early posts, especially the weak day one reads thing. I remember thinking some of his other posts were kinda meh, and haven't really read any of inhim's posts to see if I need to reasses; I kinda checked out near the end of day yesterday.

[BeautyAndTheBeast]

For-Death and Not-For-Death do not exclusively mean Scum and Town, as you should be able to properly interpret. I'm just taking those that I don't particularly feel are Town and lumping them into the For-Death pile.

And then, nowhere did I say cabd, reck, macmollie were my only 3 scumreads, or did I actually call them my scumreads.

I specifically stated, in my incomplete analysis of Day 1 voting trends, that if cabd were scum i'd be killing reck/macmollie. Then I gave my opinion on which of those I'd be willing to run up. In the vacuum, Reck is truly a scumread, cabd is like taking care of unfinished business, and you would be if I were going to start barking up a suspected PR's tree.

why is scumreading cabd taking care of business?

Cabd (KA) had an immense wagon on him, it ran alongside other options, reached a climax, and was dismantled. Oodles of information.

so why are you voting reck

[macmollie]

For-Death and Not-For-Death do not exclusively mean Scum and Town, as you should be able to properly interpret. I'm just taking those that I don't particularly feel are Town and lumping them into the For-Death pile.

And then, nowhere did I say cabd, reck, macmollie were my only 3 scumreads, or did I actually call them my scumreads.

I specifically stated, in my incomplete analysis of Day 1 voting trends, that if cabd were scum i'd be killing reck/macmollie. Then I gave my opinion on which of those I'd be willing to run up. In the vacuum, Reck is truly a scumread, cabd is like taking care of unfinished business, and you would be if I were going to start barking up a suspected PR's tree.

why is scumreading cabd taking care of business?

Cabd (KA) had an immense wagon on him, it ran alongside other options, reached a climax, and was dismantled. Oodles of information.

so why are you voting reck

that was me

[Venmar]

Hydra slipped with a hydra. Hm.

[inHimshallibe]

You're weird, inHim.

It's a feature.

[tsunami]

Amrun - what is your read on ankamius?

[inHimshallibe]

For-Death and Not-For-Death do not exclusively mean Scum and Town, as you should be able to properly interpret. I'm just taking those that I don't particularly feel are Town and lumping them into the For-Death pile.

And then, nowhere did I say cabd, reck, macmollie were my only 3 scumreads, or did I actually call them my scumreads.

I specifically stated, in my incomplete analysis of Day 1 voting trends, that if cabd were scum i'd be killing reck/macmollie. Then I gave my opinion on which of those I'd be willing to run up. In the vacuum, Reck is truly a scumread, cabd is like taking care of unfinished business, and you would be if I were going to start barking up a suspected PR's tree.

why is scumreading cabd taking care of business?

Cabd (KA) had an immense wagon on him, it ran alongside other options, reached a climax, and was dismantled. Oodles of information.

so why are you voting reck

I'm flashy and vain.

[tsunami]

okay, laying out some thoughts and questions here.

@ tierce

I don't like your dismissal of nacho saying you were scum stalling by calling it trolling. nacho is a massive troll but he does not troll the game by calling people scum if he doesn't think they are cos it muddies the waters.

This is false. Remind me at a future point to explain why. There's also something in game that I will point to when I have more time and can explain this that throws some doubt on this.

[tsunami]

So how does missing hat change your read, inhim?

And besides, I still read macmollie as roled. I've already said it once, may as well just be out front about it.

I don't get why you'd point this out.

[tsunami]

1171 note for myself where I'm at for when I get home.