The Walking Dead Mafia! ( Game Over )

[MattP]

Hi

Can we please lynch Thor?

[No Brains Here]

I won't vote RedCoyote, NBH, ActionDan, MattP, and Sugar Cain in that list meaning our pool is looking more like:

PV, mastin2, AJ, Ellibereth, GiF. Don't want to vote Ellibereth that much today but he has to do something soon. I'll talk it over with ffery later and get back to you with a nice healthy wagon.

why are you staying away from us nacho?

and are you really going to let thor get by a semi-push on a policy lynch on us?

[No Brains Here]

Hi

Can we please lynch Thor?

it would be only for policy reasons

[No Brains Here]

Do y'all want me to stick around or would you rather have another person in this slot that would be less curmudgeony and more carefree?

Stay; you're town.

[No Brains Here]

Hey kids

The conversation about policy lynches STOPS HERE.

-DGB

[sangres]

I won't vote RedCoyote, NBH, ActionDan, MattP, and Sugar Cain in that list meaning our pool is looking more like:

PV, mastin2, AJ, Ellibereth, GiF. Don't want to vote Ellibereth that much today but he has to do something soon. I'll talk it over with ffery later and get back to you with a nice healthy wagon.

why are you staying away from us nacho?

I was wondering the same thing about you, but figured it might be an in-hydra disagreement about our alignment, or maybe a decision to let us get settled into the game and start doing our thing.

and are you really going to let thor get by a semi-push on a policy lynch on us?

We're going over thor's reads together right now. They'll be pretty key to figuring out his motivations.

But, no, we're not going to stand by for a policy lynch on you no matter who pushes it.

[sangres]

gah. quote tag fail

[MattP]

I'm not PLing here

[No Brains Here]

I won't vote RedCoyote, NBH, ActionDan, MattP, and Sugar Cain in that list meaning our pool is looking more like:

PV, mastin2, AJ, Ellibereth, GiF. Don't want to vote Ellibereth that much today but he has to do something soon. I'll talk it over with ffery later and get back to you with a nice healthy wagon.

why are you staying away from us nacho?

I was wondering the same thing about you, but figured it might be an in-hydra disagreement about our alignment, or maybe a decision to let us get settled into the game and start doing our thing.

and are you really going to let thor get by a semi-push on a policy lynch on us?

We're going over thor's reads together right now. They'll be pretty key to figuring out his motivations.

But, no, we're not going to stand by for a policy lynch on you no matter who pushes it.

so what is your read on us?

[No Brains Here]

I'm not PLing here

I know matt I was just being facetious. can you tell me exactly why you are wanting thor lynched cos what you have said so far are just his playstyle and I don't think that is alignment indicative.

[sangres]

I won't vote RedCoyote, NBH, ActionDan, MattP, and Sugar Cain in that list meaning our pool is looking more like:

PV, mastin2, AJ, Ellibereth, GiF. Don't want to vote Ellibereth that much today but he has to do something soon. I'll talk it over with ffery later and get back to you with a nice healthy wagon.

why are you staying away from us nacho?

I was wondering the same thing about you, but figured it might be an in-hydra disagreement about our alignment, or maybe a decision to let us get settled into the game and start doing our thing.

and are you really going to let thor get by a semi-push on a policy lynch on us?

We're going over thor's reads together right now. They'll be pretty key to figuring out his motivations.

But, no, we're not going to stand by for a policy lynch on you no matter who pushes it.

so what is your read on us?

Town. Did you miss our saying so on day 1?

[Thor665]

And yet, I have a confirmable power role

Oh, what's the claim this time?

I think your conversation with me is you running me in circles, I don't actually see any legitimate reason you're asking me the questions you're asking other than to make me jump through hoops, your questions are trying to make me admit I'm illogical and wrong on every count of this game so far and to make me admit my scumread on you is hypocritical but who te Smurf cares if it is?

I care if you're being illogical - I would like to think you'd care too.
Do you think you're being illogical?

Oh oh oh also if you try to turn this conversation around and attack me with technical questions I'll be ignoring them

It is dangerous when people bring reality into the game.

So figure out a way to rephrase any questions you have into statements tia

Rephrase questions into statements?
Man...that makes perfect sense, why did I never do that before?
Maybe I'll just replace question marks with periods and fool you by using bad grammar.

[Venmar]

Votecount 2.6

[L-7]

Pitoli:

Desperado, Amrun, ActionDan

[L-10] RedCoyote:

[L-10] Amrun:

[L-8]

Titus:

OhGodMyLife, Aj the Epic

[L-10] Desperado:

[L-10] borkjerfkin:

[L-10] PeregrineV:

[L-10] Mastin2:

[L-7]

OhGodMyLife:

No Brains Here, Titus, borkjerfkin

[L-10] Aj the Epic:

[L-10] No Brains Here:

[L-10] Toogeloo:

[L-9]

Ellibereth:

Toogeloo

[L-10] ActionDan:

[L-10] Mattp:

[L-10] Sangres:

[L-9]

Thor665:

Mattp

[L-10] GuyInFreezer:

[L-9]

Sugar Cain:

Thor665

Not Voting (8):

• Pitoli, RedCoyote, PeregrineV, Mastin2, Ellibereth, Sangres, GuyInFreezer, Sugar Cain

Deadline:

• Friday, August 16th, 2013

Mod Notes:

• With 19 alive, it takes 10 to lynch.
  
• Mattp is V/LA until August 9th I believe.
  
• GuyInFreezer is V/LA until 8/5
  
• Amrun and Mastin2 are V/LA on Weekends.
  
• Prodding Ellibereth

Pitoli has asked to be replaced.

[Thor665]

Pitoli has asked to be replaced.

Somebody calling this a scumtell in three...two...one...

[Desperado]

No that's about the towniest way to replace out I can think of. Scum don't privately ask to be replaced.

[Desperado]

Unvote
Vote: Ellibreth

[sangres]

Looks like our pitoli vote wasn't recorded. To make it official

UNVOTE

[MattP]

Oh, what's the claim this time?

Yep, happy with my vote ty

[MattP]

I care if you're being illogical - I would like to think you'd care too.
Do you think you're being illogical?

Even happier with my vote because of more useless questions hurray!

[Toogeloo]

Okay so first of all I'm guessing that Elli AND AD are scum. They would have more fun as scum together and I'm pretty sure they would've talked about the quickhammer gambit in thread instead of letting chesskid goad them into it after Elli already promised the quickhammer and AD declared intent to hammer.

<Snipped stuff not relating to Elli/Dan>

Why are people ignoring Ellibereth and his anti-town day 1 and lack of wild appearance today ?

I feel like, with 20 players in the game, conversations have been saturated on like 4 of them. I nearly had an aneurysm reading 20 pages of John Doe or OGML are scum more votes pl0x posts.

cos he's town

What's going on here, sangres? In the same post, you say Elli and AD are scum together, but then later you say Elli is town.

Then you post this:

I won't vote RedCoyote, NBH, ActionDan, MattP, and Sugar Cain in that list meaning our pool is looking more like:

PV, mastin2, AJ, Ellibereth, GiF. Don't want to vote Ellibereth that much today but he has to do something soon. I'll talk it over with ffery later and get back to you with a nice healthy wagon.

Claiming ActionDan town, and considering Elli scum now but not wanting to vote him.

Unvote;
Vote: sangres

[Thor665]

@Matt - Do you think you're being illogical?
You have fear that I'm suggesting you are - why not just point out how you're not?
You still haven't explained my logical fallacy, maybe that's a place to start? I even explained to you explicitly how to answer the question when you got confused about how to go about it.

[sangres]

Okay so first of all I'm guessing that Elli AND AD are scum. They would have more fun as scum together and I'm pretty sure they would've talked about the quickhammer gambit in thread instead of letting chesskid goad them into it after Elli already promised the quickhammer and AD declared intent to hammer.

<Snipped stuff not relating to Elli/Dan>

Why are people ignoring Ellibereth and his anti-town day 1 and lack of wild appearance today ?

I feel like, with 20 players in the game, conversations have been saturated on like 4 of them. I nearly had an aneurysm reading 20 pages of John Doe or OGML are scum more votes pl0x posts.

cos he's town

What's going on here, sangres? In the same post, you say Elli and AD are scum together, but then later you say Elli is town.

Then you post this:

I won't vote RedCoyote, NBH, ActionDan, MattP, and Sugar Cain in that list meaning our pool is looking more like:

PV, mastin2, AJ, Ellibereth, GiF. Don't want to vote Ellibereth that much today but he has to do something soon. I'll talk it over with ffery later and get back to you with a nice healthy wagon.

Claiming ActionDan town, and considering Elli scum now but not wanting to vote him.

Unvote;
Vote: sangres

That was a catch-up post by Nacho, wherein he posts his reactions/thoughts quote-block by quote-block. His read changed over the course of the catch-up based on the unfolding thread content.

I'm not quite there in terms of the reasons for his current read of Ellibereth, but he's mentioned that he feels pretty confident about correctly reading him.

[Toogeloo]

I don't see how someone who's town's reads can change so drastically back and forth over a couple posts. I mean he literally goes Elli is scum to Elli is town in the same post, then back to Elli is possible scum again. I'm assuming Nacho doesn't have short term amnesia, so this looks really bad imo.

[MattP]

@Matt - Do you think you're being illogical?
You have fear that I'm suggesting you are - why not just point out how you're not?
You still haven't explained my logical fallacy, maybe that's a place to start? I even explained to you explicitly how to answer the question when you got confused about how to go about it.

Here's my issue.

I don't like your line of questioning because I don't believe you really think it's a useful line of questioning. I think you're trying to lead me by the leash and make me subservient to you by making me feel like I have something to prove to you. It's like you're trying to shut me up and trying to prevent me from having any sort of leadership role by calling me scum and keeping me absorbed in trying to please you with roundabout questioning. Whatever, you're being incredibly technical towards me, that's one thing, but then you JUST SO HAPPEN to have every single powerful player in the game as a scum read and have tried getting every single player that has power to look bad. I am not appealing to your line of questioning because I see no benefit in continuing with it. I am not fearful of anything, I'm frustrated.

Don't worry, I don't expect you to be any less vindictive because of it, just direct your energy towards being redundant with other people about me rather than being redundant towards me. I'd rather that because at the end of the day you're powerless towards me because I know I have a confirmable role and therefore I can stop a conversation I feel is unproductive without worrying about how it changes my position in the game.

See? You're trying to make me explain myself but I'm telling you I don't have to because I have nothing to prove. So now you're in a pickle where you don't know how to continue distracting me from everything else in the game. Oh the joy of confirmable roles!

[MattP]

Aaaaand with that this line of conversation is over