The Walking Dead Mafia! ( Game Over )

[Venmar]

Votecount 2.9

[L-10] Pitoli:

[L-10] RedCoyote:

[L-8]

Amrun:

No Brains Here, borkjerfkin

[L-8]

Titus:

OhGodMyLife, Aj the Epic

[L-10] Desperado:

[L-8]

borkjerfkin:

Mattp, Amrun

[L-10] PeregrineV:

[L-9]

Mastin2:

ActionDan

[L-8]

OhGodMyLife:

Desperado, Sangres

[L-10] Aj the Epic:

[L-10] No Brains Here:

[L-10] Toogeloo:

[L-7]

Ellibereth:

Sugar Cain, Toogeloo, Thor665

[L-9]

ActionDan:

Mastin2

[L-10] Mattp:

[L-10] Sangres:

[L-10] Thor665:

[L-10] GuyInFreezer:

[L-10] Sugar Cain:

Not Voting (6):

• Pitoli, RedCoyote, PeregrineV, GuyInFreezer, Titus, Ellibereth

Deadline:

• Friday, August 16th, 2013

Mod Notes:

• With 19 alive, it takes 10 to lynch.
  
• Mattp is V/LA until August 9th I believe.
  
• GuyInFreezer is V/LA until 8/5 ( should be getting off V/LA now )
  
• Amrun and Mastin2 are V/LA on Weekends.

Will ask the next person in replacement queue for Pitoli's slot

I'm going to sleep now, don't blow anything up again guys.

[No Brains Here]

( deaths that are described as death to a "walker" for example )

OMGL's kill wasn't walker-related so his role doesn't work like ours at all.

Why is that?

[Desperado]

Unvote
Vote: Ellibreth

[sangres]

UNVOTE

[Venmar]

( deaths that are described as death to a "walker" for example )

OMGL's kill wasn't walker-related so his role doesn't work like ours at all.

Why is that?

I cannot answer this question?

[Toogeloo]

I am all sorts of confused as to what just transpired over the last 10 pages.

What I don't understand is how Michonne is a vig that "herds" Walkers. For one, if she is a Vig, why wouldn't she just use her Katana? For two, she kept walkers with her, but she destroyed their capability of attacking other players.

NBH, I would very much like a full role claim. Are you labeled as a Vigilante specifically, or do you have a different role name? If you aren't a Vig, and pretty much just influence the mechanic, what makes you feel that an actual Vig can't exist?

[Amrun]

Unvote

Okay, I buy.

VOTE: bork

How come you buy THAT so easily and you gave me such a hard time?

VOTE: Amrun

Because Matt is town, and I was actually "buying" YOUR explanation. I'm voting for bork because Matt's read makes sense.

You did shit that didn't make sense. That's not MY fault.

[No Brains Here]

If you aren't a Vig, and pretty much just influence the mechanic, what makes you feel that an actual Vig can't exist?

We killed chesskid last night, it felt pretty vig'ish in the morning, in a very good way.

[Toogeloo]

Also... my two cents on the Merle Dixon and Morales claims.

Merle Dixon would not be the first person I think of when I think Vig, but it's not implausible since he has little issues with killing, and he's quite proficient at it. He does fight for the right side when he dies, but he spends most of the series absolutely despised by everyone, so it's hard to just accept he's aligned with town no strings attached.

Morales is a pretty bland character and a pretty easy Vanilla to accept. Considering we had Oscar flip already and he was just as unmemorable if not more so, it's fairly easy to accept the claim. That being said, unmemorable characters make great vanillas and are easy to fake claim.


P-Edit: That doesn't answer the question and you know it DGB. If you manipulate the mechanic, that doesn't make you a vig, so again... Is your role labeled as Vigilante, or no?

[Ellibereth]

kay, so in conclusion
3 conf town that can shoot and direct zombies

[Ellibereth]

I dunno flavor.
Is there good role correlation with the people that flipped?

[Amrun]

kay, so in conclusion
3 conf town that can shoot and direct zombies

3?

[Toogeloo]

Oscar and Shumpert are very much Vanillas in the show. Morales (Titus' claim) would also very much be a Vanilla.

Andrea as a Vanilla is more funny than true, but very plausible by host discretion. In the GNs, Andrea is a bad-ass, but in the show, she was quite dull and generally despised by fairly vocal fan base. Being a Vanilla makes it somewhat funny to me.

Rick as a power role is important. Why he's a Redirector, I wouldn't know for sure, an argument could probably be made for it for sure, but it's more important that he's a power role. The Series is mostly focused around him, so he should have power.

[Toogeloo]

<= Has seen all 3 seasons multiple times btw, and just started collecting the graphic novels.

[Ellibereth]

dgb matt ohmy

[Amrun]

that's not what matt claimed.

[Ellibereth]

oh he lied
I forgot
he's still elliconfirmed though tt -.-

[Toogeloo]

DGB - claimed a way to manipulate the mechanic and took credit for it killing chesskid.
Matt - faked that he was vig because he thought DGB was actually the vig. He later reneged the claim and stated it was false.
OGML - the only "actual" claimed Vig. Claims to have shot Jiffy.

[Ellibereth]

and MYSTERIOUS ABILITY
mattwise
the plz don't hide thingy
but yeah

[ActionDan]

Votecount 2.9

[L-8]

Titus:

Aj the Epic

[L-7]

Ellibereth:

Sugar Cain, Thor665

[L-9]

ActionDan:

Mastin2

Not Voting (6):

• Pitoli, RedCoyote, PeregrineV, GuyInFreezer

I don't particularly like these votes placements

[ActionDan]

And by that I mean specifically the people voting. (I don't particularly like that amrun is being voted by 2 people)

[Toogeloo]

Anyways, if I'm right, both NBH and OGML are at least for sure not-mafia.

From everyone who doesn't have or know about the ability to herd zombies, we all just assumed chesskid was a victim of the RNG mechanic. So OGML discounts that death and knows his own kill on Majiffy and how it happened. So he sees what he believes is a perspective slip from Titus' slot, and goes for it.

NBH has their own bias because they believe the herd mechanic is basically town's vig power. They know they had a direct hand in chesskid's death, and therefore feel the other two deaths are anti-town related. They see OGML's attack as a reverse perspective slip and go for OGML's throat not realizing that OGML has an actual perspective on the situation.

The only player who doesn't escape from this cleanly is Titus, and whether or not their claim that the Trust Fund kill was the Mafia kill was a perspective slip or not.


I am confident enough to assume that NBH, OGML, Amrun, and MattP are all for sure town thanks to this whole clusterfuck ordeal (I might have a little bias towards Amrun because of the Glenn claim).

[No Brains Here]

Hi Toog Hi

I have been wanting to crawl all over you about the flavour of this game cos I bet you love it every bit as much as I do. I mean I have had to literally sit on my hands the whole time.

I gave our full claim when I said that we were

town herder

and that we herded the zombies onto our target. that is our role that is our claim. I was surprised that we didn't get to kill with that awsum sword too but I am going to guess that we herd the zombies by making noise in order to help the group do other things. michonne is not the only one who did this, it was all of the group at certain times and I have been wondering if the "hey your target may not always get killed!" has something to do with a hidden mechanic, where a certain number of the core group has to be alive or not hidden or something in order for it to work. what do you think. also michonne makes sense as a vig cos lets admit she is the biggest badass on the show. I was jumping up and down when we rolled this role.

tell me what you think of this: merle is the traitor and if you look at the

timing

of ogml's role claim really made no sense at the time but it does make sense and is great play from a

traitor perspective

. titus was town telling all over the place, she was bleeding town and the lynch was probably going to dissipate and scum knew that. <------ we should look at who was the up for the next lynch lead. what do you think is the number 1 thing on scum'd mind; "who's the vig who's the vig ARRRRRRGHHHH!!!". so a good traitor would want to take care of that threat immediately, wouldn't you agree? so ogml actions makes sense from a traitor POV and merle fits the flavour as a traitor (even though he did redeem himself at some point).

going to get with dgb and discuss our reads.

on a side note: about dgb. I love her I love her I love her I want to marry her and have all of her babies. she has been awsum and is cracking me up on our wb and spreadsheet. super duper bonus she also uses and updates the spreadsheet so you best believe you will get a good list that will hopefully help town.

anybody who pushes for a lynch, derp votes or anything like that before we have a chance to post our list you should just shoot them in the head and burn them cos they are working against a town wc.

[Amrun]

The thing about omgl is not true. If I were scum in a game, and had a traitor that did that at anything but L-1, I'd think they were fucking terrible and be pissed.

[No Brains Here]

The thing about omgl is not true. If I were scum in a game, and had a traitor that did that at anything but L-1, I'd think they were fucking terrible and be pissed.

why do you sound like petulant scum right now?