The Walking Dead Mafia! ( Game Over )

[No Brains Here]

I can think of a name for your role that isn't vig, since its the one you gave. Herder.

My role name is Vigilante.

Once again, counter claiming was dumb, you dummies.

instead of herder can I use zombie queen?

what made you think majiffy was so scummy you had to nk him on n1?

[No Brains Here]

@ sangres

well he completely failed in maintaining that consistency when he shot majiffy over you

[Toogeloo]

also can you clarify as to whether or not you still think the rifleshot was a scum kill and that the suffocation is a sk kill? has this changed? if so, what are you thinking now?

When the day started, I thought the suffocation kill was SK and the Rifle shot was Mafia.
Here is the post:

From a flavor perspective, I can totally see Shane as a Serial Killer, and the Gov'nuh and his cronies as the Mafia. The Governor's crew aren't stealthy, they fight with guns, and they outright shoot their enemies. Shane was more of the crazy and kill them in quiet type. He killed Otis and said the zombies ate him, he took Randall into the forest and broke his neck, and he tried to get Rick alone and kill him in quiet as well. I'd say smothering with a pillow represents a player that is on the inside with the players and killing via stealth. Now all this being said, Venny already stated that flavor isn't indicative of anything, but I highly doubt he would say that chesskid got munched on by Walkers but really was a Vig shot. From a setup perspective, outside of Rick, the only characters I could logically see as Vigs are Daryl and Michonne, and considering their weapons (and again, I know it's only flavor) I don't think either would suffocate a player with a pillow or shoot them through the head with a bullet.

Shane as SK and Gov Mafia makes the most sense to me at the moment.

This was before any claims.


Since then, OGML and yourself have claimed and shed light on the overall mechanic of the game and some setup spec. With OGML's vig claim to have shot Majiffy, then my previous flavor assessment of the kills is now thrown out the window. Trust Fund was the Mafia kill, not the SK kill. Also, the chesskid kill was not as random as I'm sure most of us (including myself) had considered. The mechanic does state 0-2 players can die to zombies each night, and that it's random, though not as random as we might think. Your role opens up the avenue of thought that there are players who influence where the zombies will strike in particular, but it's highly illogical to assume you are the only player who does this since the mechanic openly states that no one player or faction monopolizes the ability to influence the zombies. Therefore, it's just as likely that the mafia faction has roles that influence the walkers, and there are likely another town or two who could as well. This means that in likelihood, instead of randoming between 22 different targets last night, it was narrowed down to maybe a handful. The fact that chesskid bit it (or got bit), more than likely went to your head, making you feel as if you were the sole proprietor of walker influence, when it's more logical to suspect that your random number was chosen for the walkers to attack.

With the claims, and the analysis of perception on the kills, it almost assures that both you and OGML are town, and Titus' slip is indeed a real potential slip.


P-Edit: I have a suspicion that you aren't very up to date on the last several pages at this point, mollie. Frustration is bound to happen if you aren't actually paying attention to what's been transpiring. OGML threatened to kill Sangres tonight, not last night. He killed Majiffy because he didn't like how fast the thread was moving, suspected a vocal player was scum, and took a shot at who he considered the scummiest. He's threatening to shoot sangres tonight due to sangres' actions today.

[sangres]

@ sangres

well he completely failed in maintaining that consistency when he shot majiffy over you

Raise your right hand and swear that as vig you've never targeted someone you intentionally didn't mention during the game day.

[PeregrineV]

Anyone know what pages the claimapolooza started?

[Thor665]

Urge to policy lynch Mollie rising...

In other news, i still think we're off base with the Titus wagon and ignorin gthe ever-so-tasty Elli wagon.
I think some people are doing this because they like Elli and are indifferent about Titus.
Uncool guys.

[No Brains Here]

finally some dialogue! I have been waiting for this all day.

This was before any claims.


Since then, OGML and yourself have claimed and shed light on the overall mechanic of the game and some setup spec. With OGML's vig claim to have shot Majiffy, then my previous flavor assessment of the kills is now thrown out the window. Trust Fund was the Mafia kill, not the SK kill.

so if suffocation is the method of a scum kill, character wise, who would be scum? do you have any ideas?

Also, the chesskid kill was not as random as I'm sure most of us (including myself) had considered. The mechanic does state 0-2 players can die to zombies each night, and that it's random, though not as random as we might think. Your role opens up the avenue of thought that there are players who influence where the zombies will strike in particular, but it's highly illogical to assume you are the only player who does this since the mechanic openly states that no one player or faction monopolizes the ability to influence the zombies.

I have stated a couple of times that there might be more than 1 herder so I am glad I never made that assumption.

Therefore, it's just as likely that the mafia faction has roles that influence the walkers, and there are likely another town or two who could as well.

I agree with this. I had this in mind it is 1 of the reasons I have been wanting to talk to you.

This means that in likelihood, instead of randoming between 22 different targets last night, it was narrowed down to maybe a handful. The fact that chesskid bit it (or got bit), more than likely went to your head, making you feel as if you were the sole proprietor of walker influence, when it's more logical to suspect that your random number was chosen for the walkers to attack.

I never said we were the sole proprietor of the zombies. I have said there might be more than 1 town herder. are you with me now?

With the claims, and the analysis of perception on the kills, it almost assures that both you and OGML are town, and Titus' slip is indeed a real potential slip.

except he did not mention majiffy at all on d1 but he fosed sangres:

FoS: Sangres

too.

so I am trying to figure out why he shot someone whom he had no suspicion on over someone else whom he clearly did.

P-Edit: I have a suspicion that you aren't very up to date on the last several pages at this point, mollie. Frustration is bound to happen if you aren't actually paying attention to what's been transpiring. OGML threatened to kill Sangres tonight, not last night. He killed Majiffy because he didn't like how fast the thread was moving, suspected a vocal player was scum, and took a shot at who he considered the scummiest. He's threatening to shoot sangres tonight due to sangres' actions today.

cos he did not voice suspicion of majiffy he voiced suspicion of sangres. on d1. yes I saw he threatened to shoot sangres early in the day round but he was already suspicious of sangres so I am wondering why he did not followup with that.

[Amrun]

All OMGL posted on day 1 was a stupendous key vote. That's it. Do some fucking research before you post. This is getting ridiculous.

Vigs don't need to address suspicion to targets anyway, because the point of being a vig is not to be obvious about it.

[Desperado]

Dan and Elli are both scum. 1a and 1b least genuine reactions to all of the claims + their interaction on the Stup wagon. We've already got 3 townies on Elli so what are the rest of you waiting for?

[OhGodMyLife]

Dan and Elli are both scum. 1a and 1b least genuine reactions to all of the claims + their interaction on the Stup wagon. We've already got 3 townies on Elli so what are the rest of you waiting for?

Does that jive with this post?:

dan and elli i dare you to lolhammer with no claim

i dare u

think of all the rage

I agreed with whoever posted early D2 that this makes at least one if not both Dan and Elli town.

[RedCoyote]

I'm reading as promised, my friends. I'm shocked and amazed that pitoli's slot wasn't lynched on sight for everything she said on page 31. For our metalovers, I just got out of a game with her as scum and she played exactly the same way. This is just a teaser, but something pretty gnarly is going to have to happen over the next 55 pages for me not to jump all over this slot.

[Amrun]

Dan and Elli are both scum. 1a and 1b least genuine reactions to all of the claims + their interaction on the Stup wagon. We've already got 3 townies on Elli so what are the rest of you waiting for?

Does that jive with this post?:

dan and elli i dare you to lolhammer with no claim

i dare u

think of all the rage

I agreed with whoever posted early D2 that this makes at least one if not both Dan and Elli town.

That was me.

RedC, what game was that?

[Desperado]

I'm reading as promised, my friends. I'm shocked and amazed that pitoli's slot wasn't lynched on sight for everything she said on page 31. For our metalovers, I just got out of a game with her as scum and she played exactly the same way. This is just a teaser, but something pretty gnarly is going to have to happen over the next 55 pages for me not to jump all over this slot.

Do you think Pitoli-scum would privately ask the mod to be replaced?

[Desperado]

Dan and Elli are both scum. 1a and 1b least genuine reactions to all of the claims + their interaction on the Stup wagon. We've already got 3 townies on Elli so what are the rest of you waiting for?

Does that jive with this post?:

dan and elli i dare you to lolhammer with no claim

i dare u

think of all the rage

I agreed with whoever posted early D2 that this makes at least one if not both Dan and Elli town.

I think the best you could argue is that it clears one as town. It certainly doesn't make them both town. If I had to pick one as town I'd say Dan.

[RedCoyote]

Amrun, click the link (Mini 1464).

Desperado, I haven't got that far yet, but she replaced out of the game I just referenced as scum who was getting battered too badly.

Also, someone please tell me immediately who waynegg is. He is not listed on the OP.

Mod

, please tell the hydras to post from their accounts or, at the bare minimum, list all the players in the hydra in the OP, please. It's completely unacceptable that a player is allowed to consistently post in here and I have no idea what slot they are.

[Sugar Cain]

Mollie/DGB, claim your ROLE name NOW!

[Sugar Cain]

Mollie/DGB, claim your ROLE name NOW!

[Desperado]

Amrun, click the link (Mini 1464).

Desperado, I haven't got that far yet, but she replaced out of the game I just referenced as scum who was getting battered too badly.

Also, someone please tell me immediately who waynegg is. He is not listed on the OP.

Mod

, please tell the hydras to post from their accounts or, at the bare minimum, list all the players in the hydra in the OP, please. It's completely unacceptable that a player is allowed to consistently post in here and I have no idea what slot they are.

Wayne and Titus used to be Jon Doe. Then wayne got ejected so Titus is by himself now.

Sugar, they already did. Michonne, Town Herder

[Sugar Cain]

UNVOTE:

I don't want to touch Titus

I don't want to touch Sangres

I don't want to touch OGML

I do, however want Thor's blood

I'll re-read the game and about two hours when I get home

~Sugar

[Thor665]

All OMGL posted on day 1 was a stupendous key vote. That's it. Do some fucking research before you post. This is getting ridiculous.

Vigs don't need to address suspicion to targets anyway, because the point of being a vig is not to be obvious about it.

In a sad realization, it just occurred to me that even with the number of games I've played - I've only been a Vig once.
The hell?

I don't want to touch Titus

I don't want to touch Sangres

I don't want to touch OGML

I do, however want Thor's blood

I'll re-read the game and about two hours when I get home

~Sugar

I don't want to lynch three players, two of whom I did want to lynch earlier and, in fact, called Thor scummy for not wanting to lynch them and how he weridly avoided doing so.
Also decided not to lynch Sangres, another player Thor already indicated no desire to lynch - probably about the same time I said all his reads were terribad.
Oh, yeah, still want to lynch Thor though - I'm sure for reasons *not* involving his weird defense of people I now also don't want to lynch.

In other news, Sugar is still scum.
Just saying.

[Thor665]

I also want to be on record in saying I think he's lying when he says he's going to be home and 're-read' the 80+ page game.
I mean seriously.

[Sugar Cain]

Are you high? No one is rereading the game. Mara left and went elsewhere. Stop pretending like we aren't a hydra.

[No Brains Here]

Mollie/DGB, claim your ROLE name NOW!

Town Herder

We've said it before.

[PeregrineV]

Anyone know what pages the claimapolooza started?

A Page number?

[RedCoyote]

Pere, are we reading together, buddy?