The Walking Dead Mafia! ( Game Over )

[TheIrishPope]

omg venmar like the OP says we're still in N1 and the player list needs to be updated kthx

[TheIrishPope]

Pretty sure mastin and Elli are scum
Sugar and RC and OGML and Thor have PRs
In a game of this size, how many scum would there normally be?
Also someone please gimme the claims and counterclaims and shiz

[RedCoyote]

Why would you tell people who you thought had PRs?

[Titus]

A tl;dr and a reason why Titus is the major wagon would be appreciated.

tl:dr - People decided that night kill spec wherein you don't immediately presume Vig when a non-scummy player was killed = scum play.
We had a bunch of killing roles claim, cross claim, and cross vote all while not actually being the same role.
People ignore some good wagons.
Instead they will run up Titus, because...y'know, he scum slipped...or...something...y'see, he was trying to figure out night kills and offered his thoughts about them, and now he has to die because he sounded a *little* too sure of himself.
The person who created the case did the same thing (and, considering their claimed role, it was even derpier, frankly)
Everyone has ignored that this isn't actually a scumtell.
And now we're here.

You should vote Elli or Sugar, both are actually looking like scum.
Unlike Titus, who looks like frustrated town.

Thor, someone pushing my wagon is likely scum. At this point, I'd think Sugar, AJ, or OMGL. Thoughts?

[Sugar Cain]

Dear Matty:

Players with Walker mechanics are legit.

Love, Mara

Pedit: TIP WHY MUST YOU OUT US? WHY? D;

Oh, and Titus, my post are signed if I'm not referring to Nero in said post

[TheIrishPope]

For lulz? Umm, my reasoning is we need to distinguish the PRs from the VTs to hopefully save them by coordinating night actions and the like; for example, Jiffy was a redirector, and the usefulness of his role depends on the alignment of target and his or her role, if that makes sense

Titus, good to see you, do you have any preference over who we lynch today?

[Titus]

Pretty sure mastin and Elli are scum
Sugar and RC and OGML and Thor have PRs
In a game of this size, how many scum would there normally be?
Also someone please gimme the claims and counterclaims and shiz

OMGL is Vig. Brains is Herd Keeper. I'm VT. Matt's vig I believe.

Why did you out those you think are PRs?

[Titus]

For lulz? Umm, my reasoning is we need to distinguish the PRs from the VTs to hopefully save them by coordinating night actions and the like; for example, Jiffy was a redirector, and the usefulness of his role depends on the alignment of target and his or her role, if that makes sense

Titus, good to see you, do you have any preference over who we lynch today?

I've been trying to get there but I've been FoSed the living daylights out impeding investigation. I figured scum would be pushing me really hard, so I have three thoughts ATM, but I'm unsure which. Throw Amrun in for good measure too.

[Titus]

A tl;dr and a reason why Titus is the major wagon would be appreciated.

tl:dr - People decided that night kill spec wherein you don't immediately presume Vig when a non-scummy player was killed = scum play.
We had a bunch of killing roles claim, cross claim, and cross vote all while not actually being the same role.
People ignore some good wagons.
Instead they will run up Titus, because...y'know, he scum slipped...or...something...y'see, he was trying to figure out night kills and offered his thoughts about them, and now he has to die because he sounded a *little* too sure of himself.
The person who created the case did the same thing (and, considering their claimed role, it was even derpier, frankly)
Everyone has ignored that this isn't actually a scumtell.
And now we're here.

You should vote Elli or Sugar, both are actually looking like scum.
Unlike Titus, who looks like frustrated town.

Thor, someone pushing my wagon is likely scum. At this point, I'd think Sugar, AJ, or OMGL. Thoughts?

Add Amrun to this.

[TheIrishPope]

Two vigs? Preposterous
I just want to give any thoughts I have right now in case I get eaten by someone

Oh jeez, Amrun's in this game
Titus, you're, like, the most obvtown, so I'm sheeping you, k?

Sugar, Thor, what are your roles?
inb4 jailkeeper

[RedCoyote]

I'm sorry, guys, but I got to take a step away from this game. I can't read more than 40 pages in one sitting. Everything is starting to blend together and I am reading over the same posts over and over again because my eyes are glazing over each time.

VOTE: Metal Sonic

I have a lot of other scumreads/townreads but I am collecting everything into one big post. I just cannot read anymore tonight. Like I said, I am unable to process anymore.

[Titus]

Derp. Sugar and Thor should not be claiming ATM. It's bad enough your fishing for hypothetical PR roles now you're wanting them to claim. Not to mention the blatant buddying. :S

[TheIrishPope]

You see buddying as something bad? But but but

[No Brains Here]

so when you started reading the game here:

So many fucking hydras.
Reading up 87 beautiful pages.
A tl;dr and a reason why Titus is the major wagon would be appreciated.

in a short amount of time you managed to get caught up to know what our role is and nothing else?

You were the one who claimed horde controller or some shit right?

and why are you focused on our role rather than interested in scumhunting?

I was so excited when I saw you replacing in tip and now you are just breaking my heart.

[Sugar Cain]

This is townTIP mollie

Leave him alone

[Sugar Cain]

~Sugar

[TheIrishPope]

Well if the horde can kill EACH AND EVERY ONE OF US then yes I'm interested; I was in a random page searching why wayne got removed or something and I saw your claim
The scumhunting begins...
NOW

[No Brains Here]

For lulz? Umm, my reasoning is we need to distinguish the PRs from the VTs to hopefully save them by coordinating night actions and the like; for example, Jiffy was a redirector, and the usefulness of his role depends on the alignment of target and his or her role, if that makes sense

Titus, good to see you, do you have any preference over who we lynch today?

Now I have scum lynch blue balls.

[No Brains Here]

Well if the horde can kill EACH AND EVERY ONE OF US then yes I'm interested; I was in a random page searching why wayne got removed or something and I saw your claim
The scumhunting begins...
NOW

that isn't where we claimed. it was several pages later.

[Sugar Cain]

VOTE: Thor

Follow me TIP, I will lead you to victory

Elli, Pit, and AD are also likely to be scum.

Nero thinks RC is scum, but I don't really agree there

~Sugar

[TheIrishPope]

I know mollie, I was reading up
Mara I'll stick to my scumreads tyvm

[No Brains Here]

how exactly fast do you read tip? cos you knew we were town herder in minutes when it when the claims started on p70.

and you seem very unclear as to when we had claimed when you had just "supposedly" read it.

[TheIrishPope]

I just know I saw a claim and I stopped to pay attention lol ok

[No Brains Here]

I'm warming up to Thortown.

-DGB

[Amrun]

Thor, for the record, I am not voting Titus/Jon Doe because of a supposed scum slip. I don't think it was a slip. I think their behavior outside of that has been scummy, particularly day 1.

But I've decided to let it ride for a while.

VOTE: ellibereth