La Isla de la Muerte (Game over!)

[Desperado]

What do Skull and I have to do to get this Zoid wagon going?

[Skullduggery]

They both seem scummy. I am not saying that both of them are scum, or are even on the same scum team, if there are multiple. I am simply saying that my read on them are both scummy. I am sorry I don't have anything more solid on them yet.

Argh, this response is so Town, it burns us!

UNVOTE:

So you're saying that you're differentiating between "Scum" and "scummy," basically. If I held a gun to your head and told you to pick just one of them, who would it be? (I'm assuming you wouldn't say that they're both Town.)

Also, considering the size of the game, I'm fairly confident that we're only dealing with one Scum team -- or possibly one Scum team plus a Serial Killer. I find it unlikely that an 18-person game would be multiball, bastard rules be damned.

Damn, 19 pages and nothing interesting has happened.

If you don't think anything interesting has happened, then perhaps you should

make

something interesting happen.

VOTE: Zoidberg

Something's up with you, Zoidy my man. You can't expect me to believe that your disinterest in the game is caused by a boring role, like you said in 290. You were a Vanilla Townie in Calvin & Hobbes Mafia, but that didn't stop you from being one of the most active players in that game. Why is this game different?

it would be funny if i actually won 'cause of skullduggery
too funny

no i will not stop fluffposting
that's how i play D1 regardless of my alignment

I never said that your fluff-posting was indicative of your alignment. Why did you feel the need to throw in that detail?

What do Skull and I have to do to get this Zoid wagon going?

I dunno. How about bribery? We haven't tried bribery yet.

Attention, fellow players of La Isla de la Muerte! Have we got a deal for you! Move your vote over to Zoidberg today and

we'll

Desperado will give you ten bucks! Wow! That's twice as much as five bucks! Just think of all the things you could buy with that! Here's your chance to line your pocket with the taciturn face of Alexander Hamilton! The ladies love his powdered wig, and you will too! This offer won't last long, so act today and vote Zoidberg!

[mnemonicdevice]

So you're saying that you're differentiating between "Scum" and "scummy," basically. If I held a gun to your head and told you to pick just one of them, who would it be? (I'm assuming you wouldn't say that they're both Town.)

I would pick Waynegg

[mnemonicdevice]

Eh. Maybe it will make him do something.

VOTE: Zoidberg

[Baby Spice]

Mod meta shows that if there are players with post restrictions, one of them will be scum. Of course this could be the game SC breaks his meta.

Here's the thing.

Before this post every one of Hydrochloric's posts were in caps. As if he had a post restriction.

Their next post after this is:

GUYS, CATCHING UP, FRET NOT

They their next post quotes post #302 (Note mine above is #303) and the all caps has disapeered.


To me, this is a scum reaction.
Their first post came after two post restricted players had posted, and after Mitzi's only post of that picture which could have been mistaken for a third post restricted player.

Plenty of time to realise that there were post restricted players in the game and to decide to fake one.
It disapeers as soon as one of them read my comment.


So we have a player deciding to fake a post restriction, then dropping it like a hot potato when it's pointed out that in an SC's mod meta is to have a post restricted scum.

I didn't think the all caps was a PR because I thought it just TIP.

You can see I did notice it in post 70.

I'm guessing that's the Irish head.
Jason's PR looks amusing.
~SD

WRONG BBY <3

Your post #70 was your fifth post after you were told it wasn't TiP posting the all caps. and you were posting immediatly after the GiF head said so.

Looks to me like you knew that Hydrochloric didn't actually have a Post Restriction, and only commented on it after you realised that they were trying to fake one. (Some 12 hours later)

I think you're both scum, and on the same team, and that your team doesn't have a post restricted player in it.

Vote SalmonellaDoctor

I'd rather Hydrochloric but SD has two votes already.

[Saki]

i could be jester
i could be scum fakeclaiming jester
i could be town fakeclaiming scum fakeclaiming jester
all the glorious possibilities!


VOTE: Zoidberg
<3

[SalmonellaDoctor]

I understand your case on Hydro. However, your case on me is extremely weak. It looks like you're trying so hard to be able to jump on a forming wagon. Additionally, if you'd rather lynch Hydro, why not fucking vote him? Who cares about how many votes you have on me? And how the fuck is not noticing a post restriction for five votes scummy? You're vote on me looks very opportunistic, considering your case on me is crap, and you have a stronger scum read on someone else.

VOTE: BabySpice

~SD

Also, don't be surprised if some Hydra dissonance comes up soon. That post pinged my scumdar so hard that I didn't defer to DP first.

[Saki]

What do Skull and I have to do to get this Zoid wagon going?

cookies

[Skullduggery]

What would a Scum player have to gain by faking a post restriction, though?

[Baby Spice]

I wondered that myself when I first saw it in an SC large theme bastard.

SWN II I think it was.
Of course when that player replaced out SC made it a post restricted role.
SD, we've had enough crap this day, and starting yet another one person wagon is not going to help. Hence voting the slightly lesser scum read who does have a wagon on them.
That and town reading PV.

[SalmonellaDoctor]

@Baby Spice, compromising on a lynch isn't town behavior, especially when it's an opportunistic compromise.

And who cares if you've town read PV? That doesn't mean he's automatically right.

[Baby Spice]

@Baby Spice, compromising on a lynch isn't town behavior, especially when it's an opportunistic compromise.

And who cares if you've town read PV? That doesn't mean he's automatically right.

Since when would starting the tenth wagon be town behaviour? Hell, if you ask me those people hanging out on single vote wagons should be moving their votes to lower the number of wagons.
Since when would voting a slightly lesser scumspect over a main scumspect be scum behaviour?
and exactly how would it be considered opportunistic?

Tell me why your vote isn't pure OMGUS?

As for PV, I care, and that doesn't mean that he's automatically wrong either.

Do you agree with my case on Hydro SD?

[SalmonellaDoctor]

I thought the Sakura slot was town and was being wagonned for shit reasons but that vote was bad and the reasoning was too.

"When was it town behavior to start a tenth wagon?" How is that scum behavior? How is that bad? Aren't scum supposed to be more inclined to not start new wagons and be part of the current wagons. Oh wait, you think Hydro is scummier then you vote for us? Makes complete sense. Its scum behavior because it looks like "I dont want to be on a major wagon" and its bad. Not going for the supposed higher scum read indicates that you dont want said person to be lynched

We are scum for dropping speculation on Post restrictions? I think neither of us here at SalmonellaDoctor have played with a Post Restriction or a StrangerCoug game, so we didnt think it mattered, we just wondered about it. So us dropping set up spec is null if no one else actually brings any relevance to it because we didnt think it would mattter.

DP

[Hydrochloric Hydra]

Actually both heads were doing all caps for fun, not just me. And tippy slipped
Also this head is horribly desynced from this game and will need motivation.

Also tippy think Karnage might be scum but I'm not seeing that so we're discussing.

[Belisarius]

504

UNVOTE:

Crap. Now I don't know what to think.

More time (and possibly gin) required.

[Ten_Heavens]

TH why just comment on Waynegg? There are lots more to go off this game. Thats pretty opportunistic.

DP

Because that's what the last few pages were on about? There isn't much besides rvs and fluff (mostly from Saki) to make cases about.

[Klick]

VOTE: Zoidberg

[StrangerCoug]

VOTE COUNT

boxxy (1): Hydrochloric Hydra
Baby Spice (2): Karnage, SalmonellaDoctor
JasonWazza (1): Ten_Heavens
Saki (2): boxxy, Who
SalmonellaDoctor (3): PeregrineV, Mitzi, Baby Spice
Titus (2): JasonWazza, Zoidberg
Zoidberg (6): Desperado, Titus, Skullduggery, mnemonicdevice, Saki, Klick
Not voting (2): Belisarius

With

18

players alive, it takes

10

votes to lynch.

Day 1 ends in (expired on 2013-08-19 08:25:57).

boxxy and Mitzi are prodded, and Karnage is due for a prod in (expired on 2013-08-09 20:10:43).

[Titus]

@Klick, why are you voting Zoidberg?

[mnemonicdevice]

Notice: I will be la for 2 weeks starting tomorrow. I will make every effort to post, but if I don't, then sorry.

[StrangerCoug]

Notice: I will be la for 2 weeks starting tomorrow. I will make every effort to post, but if I don't, then sorry.

Noted.

[Karnage]

Damn, 19 pages and nothing interesting has happened.

i could be jester
i could be scum fakeclaiming jester
i could be town fakeclaiming scum fakeclaiming jester
all the glorious possibilities!


VOTE: Zoidberg
<3

You posted 7 times after zoidberg posted. Why didn't you vote him initially instead of begging for votes on yourself? What changed to cause you to vote zoidberg?
VOTE: saki

[Skullduggery]

We are scum for dropping speculation on Post restrictions? I think neither of us here at SalmonellaDoctor have played with a Post Restriction or a StrangerCoug game, so we didnt think it mattered, we just wondered about it. So us dropping set up spec is null if no one else actually brings any relevance to it because we didnt think it would mattter.

I agree that speculation on post restrictions is null (heck, I've been doing it too), but if you think it doesn't matter, why have you been bringing it up so frequently?

[Baby Spice]

It's more than that Skull. It's the speculating on them whilst ignoring a player who was faking a post restriction.
Could easily be that SD knew that Hydro was faking. Also, SD's explanation for ignoring it doesn't hold water that well either.

Also, SD still seems to think that someone else has a post restriction when they don't, judging by acouple of SD's answers.

[Zoidberg]

If you don't think anything interesting has happened, then perhaps you should make something interesting happen.

That's what I'm doing.

VOTE: Zoidberg

It's working

Something's up with you, Zoidy my man. You can't expect me to believe that your disinterest in the game is caused by a boring role, like you said in 290. You were a Vanilla Townie in Calvin & Hobbes Mafia, but that didn't stop you from being one of the most active players in that game. Why is this game different?

I didn't say I was a VT this game. I said my role is pretty standard and non-bastard.

I think you'll find if you go through my recent games that this isn't close to my scumgame.

D1 in a large theme always sucks. Signal:Noise ratio is always way too low, everyone's trolololololling. I'm not attempting to conceal the fact that I'm coasting. When D2 happens, if I'm not the lynch, I'll step it up.

Meanwhile there is guaranteed to be at least 1 scum on my wagon. Lots of shitty votes.

Lynch me if you want, IDGAF. Just let me claim before hammer.