In post 687, notscience wrote:AtE. "Ugh every IC always does this ;-;" And shouldn't scum be looking for crumbs moreso than town?
I don't think you understand what AtE means...
In post 692, mastin2 wrote:Broseidon's tripping my gut as scum for some odd reason, but he's solidly town via his words.
Oh I'll be getting to this...
Why? You're going to get NK'd unless the scumteams thinks you're a complete moron.
TD is obvtown can you stop being obtuse.
In post 701, Desperado wrote:Muffin's stance on TD, and the consistency of his Bro scumhunt, are both town motivated. Unlike Venmar's useless TD tunnel, Muffin's intentions are transparent and he lays his thought process out willfully.
Why is consistency town-motivated? Also, in the second quote of his you've posted, what is the town-motivation of stating theory that is wrong (his part about wagon-speed being null is just outright wrong).
In post 705, mastin2 wrote:I'm thinking at this point that BROseidon might be scum, from his iso. "Why? His words look so town!" Words, yes. A good scum player can create good words. Actions, on the other hand? Actions, I think make him scum. Macscumread, nicktownread, fakeish-looking reaction to IC, SoS scumread, general reads not seeming all too original (this may just be me, though), overall posting not screaming town even though the words themselves look town. Not much, but worrisome. (Basically: any individual sentence may look town, but their sum is less than their parts.)
Here we go!
You IIoA everything I do, except for the part where you talk about general reads not being too original. However, that ONE piece of analysis, the ONE USEFUL THING YOU DO in trying to discern my alignment, you get WRONG. I was first to call nhammen scum (if nhammen flips town whoever sheeped my read early on should be lynched btw, because the way in which that's proliferated makes me super uncomfortable). I was one of the first to call Mac scum. I am in the minority calling Nick town. I was one of the first to call TD town. Unless you define "not too original" as "holding contrarian views the entire game," you're explicitly wrong. This looks like a weak early push you can bring up later to try to force a mislynch on me.
In post 707, Desperado wrote:What did you mean "no stahp, it's nhamm?" I rolled scum with him as the IC of my first newbie and his first two posts seemed in line with my experience. I'm disappointed he replaced out because I'm much less confident in my ability to read Mala.
Both of us having experience with scumnhammen and both of us reading his first post the same way assuages my worries about the read, though.
In post 710, mastin2 wrote:Desperado's
actually quite
worrying me. I'm
kinda
used to Desp being super-active as town and having strong reads on multiple players and a very strong will. Instead, I get a singular post which is spoilered and
rather
weak. It's mostly quotes (info) and barely laden with the analysis I'd expect
(Says the guy who's doing the same thing)[/b]. I'll
obviously
wait for more from him, but right now, he's a nullish-scumread of mine. :/
1) Use fewer words.
2) Stop hedging and emphasizing. Oh wait, scum love to do those things.
In post 718, mastin2 wrote:Mac iso:
Some specific posts
may be a bit
concerning, but overall, there's strong town posting present and I
really don't
think this is scuMac.
Malakittens iso:
She's not giving me
warm fuzzy
feelings. At all. This doesn't seem like the town-her that I've come to expect, like, at all. So again,
bit
of a scumread.
She replaced nhammen,
who is
next on my iso list. There's not much to really see, there. I
can't really
have anything definitive, other than a
bit of a gut scumread with his overall approach
.
Skull iso is
basically
empty, so nothing there at all. At this point with me
not really having any really strong townreads, might
be a scumread just by virtue of being a null-read.
Everything I've bolded is scummy (hedging, emphasizing, or failure to contract).
In post 732, nickthename wrote:Could you elaborate on your nhammen read? Nhammen feels pretty null to me.
Also, you're voting SoS, and all you've said so far about her is a possible liar tell. So either you consider that one tell scummier than anything else so far this game, or there's more to that vote then you've said. Which is it?
His intro post reminded me a lot of his intro post in Inevitable Mafia, where he was scum. Generally taking non-stances and not pushing anything while appearing like he was engaging with the thread.
That vote was for town-multitasking. I think SoS is getting too many unjustified townreads, and that slot needs to be looked at seriously.
VOTE: Mastin
I am not letting this shit off the hook.
