Mini 1486: Fruit Basket Mafia (Game Over)

[Elyse]

I said who are you because it's a player that joined a few days ago and is looking up my meta. Like its an alt.

[UberKang]

you keep doing this thing where you change your vote if its questioned

This is simply not the case; you're shoehorning my actions to fit your agenda. In the first post you quoted, I changed my vote as I found A Simple Plan's reaction to be fairly town, not in reaction to any questioning of my vote. In the second post you quoted, I didn't change my vote, nor was it questioned.

So I really don't like this post, it's a blatant lie. The question is why do it?

[Kid A]

desperado questioned the wagon and you quickly disassociated yourself from it and hopped off

when i questioned your vote on asp you quickly came up with reasons why they were town and hopped off

what was so different about the post that it made you want to unvote?

[Kid A]

So, Kid A-- do you still think Formerfish is "obvscum"?

i exagerrated my read on formerfish for better reactions

[Kid A]

desperado questioned the wagon and you quickly disassociated yourself from it and hopped off

when i questioned your vote on asp you quickly came up with reasons why they were town and hopped off

what was so different about the post that it made you want to unvote?

post 61 btw

[Formerfish]

Hi all
I’m not liking formerfish’s reaction to his RVS wagon, but I don’t feel strongly enough about it to put him at L-1. Will post more after work.

Where did you disappear too?

/confirm Sorry it took a while I was out of town.

I generally dislike when people post to apologize for not posting, without saying anything more.

No comments about the votes on you?

Where's your vote for Kid A?

I don't think either vote was random.

What would you want him to say about the votes on him? When I said something about mine I was told that I was scum. Shouldn't he just worry about finding scum, and forget about those against him if he's town?

I have 4 good townreads currently; Don't want to explain them right now.

Simple Plan still seems like the best vote to me.

Why isn't it a good time to expound on your reads?

[A Simple Plan]

I'm still not fond of Kid A's 56 for some reason, but Im not convinced that he's scum.

Formerfish's 80 brings up a couple solid points, and I do agree that Slandaar hiding his reads is at the least giving an anti-town vibe.

MOD:

this will be my last post before I return from my trip Sunday evening, approximately 36 hours. Just a reminder.

[Gee Gee]

@MOD:

You should have buffy and I listed as hydras.

(<name> [Hydra of X and Y])

[pdmedic]

Hmmm I see I have a vote against me by ASimplePlan not sure what I've done so this seems scummy to me.

VOTE: ASimplePlan

[Kid A]

not sure what I've done

i think thats kind of the point

[Elyse]

Oh ok GG is a hydra.

@formerfish
I didn't think ASP should have said anything about the votes against him. I was just checking to see what his response would be when I asked him.

[pdmedic]

not sure what I've done

i think thats kind of the point

Could be I'm still new at this so I guess this is the random finger pointing stage to see how people react.

[Desperado]

I'm still not fond of Kid A's 56 for some reason, but Im not convinced that he's scum.

Formerfish's 80 brings up a couple solid points, and I do agree that Slandaar hiding his reads is at the least giving an anti-town vibe.

MOD:

this will be my last post before I return from my trip Sunday evening, approximately 36 hours. Just a reminder.

No, there is no reason to out townreads. If one of them starts getting strung up I'm sure he'll take the necessary steps, otherwise outing his reads would just make the scum's NK decision easier

Elyse's #60 is an excellent illustration of why she's scum, for the reasons Fish pointed out just now.

[Desperado]

Oh ok GG is a hydra.

@formerfish
I didn't think ASP should have said anything about the votes against him. I was just checking to see what his response would be when I asked him.

Then why did you form the question accusatorially?

"No comments on the votes on you?" clearly implies that he should have commented already and that it's scummy that he hasn't.

[Kid A]

I'm still not fond of Kid A's 56 for some reason, but Im not convinced that he's scum.

Formerfish's 80 brings up a couple solid points, and I do agree that Slandaar hiding his reads is at the least giving an anti-town vibe.

MOD:

this will be my last post before I return from my trip Sunday evening, approximately 36 hours. Just a reminder.

No, there is no reason to out townreads. If one of them starts getting strung up I'm sure he'll take the necessary steps, otherwise outing his reads would just make the scum's NK decision easier

I agree with this but not outing reads is inconsistent with slandaars meta

[RadiantCowbells]

Votecount #4

Formerfish - 2 (mnemonicdevice, Elyse)
Elyse - 2 (Desperado, StubbsKVM)
pdmedic - 1 (A Simple Plan)
A Simple Plan - 2 (Slandaar, pdmedic)
UberKang - 1 (Kid A)

With

13

alive it's

7

to lynch.


The day comes to a close on

August 28th

at

noon

.

@GeeGee Who are the X and Y?

[Elyse]

Oh ok GG is a hydra.

@formerfish
I didn't think ASP should have said anything about the votes against him. I was just checking to see what his response would be when I asked him.

Then why did you form the question accusatorially?

"No comments on the votes on you?" clearly implies that he should have commented already and that it's scummy that he hasn't.

No it doesn't.

[Formerfish]

Oh ok GG is a hydra.

@formerfish
I didn't think ASP should have said anything about the votes against him. I was just checking to see what his response would be when I asked him.

Then why did you form the question accusatorially?

"No comments on the votes on you?" clearly implies that he should have commented already and that it's scummy that he hasn't.

No it doesn't.

That's pretty much exactly what I got from that. The question was phrased in a leading way. You wanted to see if he'd say anything so you could jump on him about it.

[Elyse]

No, I wanted to see if he would say anything so I could get a read on him.

[Formerfish]

No, I wanted to see if he would say anything so I could get a read on him.

So what read do you make off him saying nothing?

[Buffy vs Dracula]

So, Kid A-- do you still think Formerfish is "obvscum"?

i exagerrated my read on formerfish for better reactions

What reaction were you expecting from a guy you'd been egging on at L-2?

You (and to a lesser extent Elyse) were pushing hard for his hammer one page into the game. I would expect a false positive in that position.

/confirm Sorry it took a while I was out of town.

I generally dislike when people post to apologize for not posting, without saying anything more.

This seems suspiciously similar to ASP's 61.

Oh ok GG is a hydra.

Hey, Drac and I are a hydra too. Do you just not like vampires? Is that it? That's... actually completely understandable, but I'm still saddened.

--Buffy

[Buffy vs Dracula]

I said who are you because it's a player that joined a few days ago and is looking up my meta. Like its an alt.

I thought you didn't check join dates? With Formerfish, I mean.

[Formerfish]

Looking back I do see ASPs post Buffy. I didn't see it at the time though, I've had things come up IRL that have been keeping me mostly occupied (nothing big, fiancée and I just had our first kid is all).

I may have been parroting, unknowingly, but the sentiment still stands. If you have time to say you haven't had time to post, then you have time to post. And if you don't have time, go on LVA and catch up/post when you get off it. The non-post post has always just been a pet peeve of mine.

[Elyse]

No, I wanted to see if he would say anything so I could get a read on him.

He responded how I thought a townie would, so I got townpoints from it.
So what read do you make off him saying nothing?

I said who are you because it's a player that joined a few days ago and is looking up my meta. Like its an alt.

I thought you didn't check join dates? With Formerfish, I mean.

Where did I say that?

[Elyse]

Ok my response is in the first quote idk how it got there.