Newbie 1420: Fireproof (Game Over)

[Cheery Dog]

Vote Count 1.2

Player	L-4 Vote	L-3 Vote	L-2 Vote	L-1 Vote	L-0 Vote (Hammer)	Total Votes
Smoker	RachMarie	A Simple Plan	notscience			3
thenewearth	thenewearth	Prophylaxis				2
Prophylaxis	Smoker	Ms Marangal				2
notscience	Super Serious Gal					1
A Simple Plan	VT					1

Not Voting

With 9 alive, it takes 5 to lynch Deadline (expired on 2013-08-29 07:00:00)

Seeking replacement for Super Serious Gal
Prophylaxis is on V/LA from 18/8 until 21/8

[A Simple Plan]

^I towntold

Actually you saying you just towntold just screams that you're scum.

I agree with this statement. Smoker seems more and more scummy to me lately; however, I'm pleased to see he is keeping activity up; he still maintains my vote until I return, however.

MOD:

this will be my last post until I return Sunday evening. Just wanted to remind about this.

[notscience]

VOTE: ASP

MAra you should join me

[Ms Marangal]

Later~~

I'm more interested in Prophy

[RachMarie]

Discussion is always good, inactives will get replaced or end up replacing out, or they will get more active after being prodded with a nice big cattle prod. So we will get more info from their slots sooner or later.

Welcome to the game tne now get that self vote off (shooing with hand) You KNOW better than that

actually the case on you is pretty good smoker.

We do not want to run everyone up to claim time, it is important to as much as possible not reveal our PRs especially this early on to the scum, just tells them who to NK. Later on a mass claim may be needed or not, depending on the situation at that time.

Mara is the IC and as far as IC stuff she will lead you correctly, however as far as her game role goes she has the exact same chance as any one else to be scum which in this setup is 2/9ths.

Mara I disagree I have seen both town and scum use OMGUS votes. And that is the least of my case and what others have put forth as the case on Smoker being scum.

However, I will take a look at prophy I dont really have a sense of him yet and that always makes me wonder.



at this point I am quite happy with my vote where it is.

[RachMarie]

well that did not take much time, no wonder I had no recollection of him. He had TWO posts an RVS vote and then voting tne for self voting...

umm I am so not seeing your case here Mara, could you elaborate?

[Smoker]

Ok, seems RM is probably town, then. Interesting, I'm running out of players here.

RM you should unvote and stop being dumb. There's no case on me. How do you know I'm not a PR for example?

[Smoker]

Oh, Ms Mangal is probably actually mafia btw, seeing as this isn't going anywhere fast.

Dunno who else, ASP maybe.

VOTE: ASP

[notscience]

Smoker you need to work on conveying why you think someone is mafia

Game going slow=/= IC is scum. Look at 1393, that was slow and the IC was town

1392 too.

[Smoker]

Let's just say I have three solid town-reads, then: one on you, notscience; one on thenewearth; and one on VA.

And then two semi-solid town-reads: one on SSG, for what I read of her; and one on RM, who's now spoken considerably more and rings townie.

Ms Marangal seems instead, upon further consideration, to have been building herself up with the earlier post I found interesting, rather than appealing to my graces for ego-building purposes. I guess that read was rather completely nonsensical, too, thinking about it :p

But yeah, so Ms Marangal for mafia, I think. Prophy might even be town, ASP is the next best choice I think.

The 'Later~~' was also incredibly scummy by the way, pushing Prophy and paying zero attention to my questions. Just seems to have been pushing some agenda to be honest.

[Ms Marangal]

umm I am so not seeing your case here Mara, could you elaborate?

I didn't make one

Other than "keeping his options open" why else is he scum, because town do give off that vibe far to frequently

[notscience]

That Later looked like it was directed to me

[thenewearth]

Yes I should remove this self-vote off

UNVOTE:

But now I will have no where to put it since it would put smoker at L-1. And I do not like page 5 L-1. IT'S MADNESS

[VT]

Well apparently I accidentally put notscience at L-1 on page 1. Whoops.

BLAHH someone please explain to me proph=scum.

Sorry if you already did and I was just too stupid to notice heh

[Smoker]

I'm currently reading Vonnegut's

Cat's Cradle

if anyone is interested in that. Otherwise, my reads haven't changed, just waiting on you guys I guess.

VT, there's nothing necessarily scummy about prophy, in fact, I'm not so sure he'd zip off so nonchalantly as he did were he mafia. I mean, as town he can come back and call us all idiots, but as mafia that doesn't really work. He'd just have bit the big one and in record time. Yeah, he seemed almost too uncaring to be scum.

Dunno though, mind you! I'm thinking I do actually have too many solid reads at the moment. Leaning towards Ms Marangal and ASP as being the only two scummy, everyone else townie.

[Ms Marangal]

The Later was directed at Notsci. I am not interested in pushing ASL currently

My current suspicions lie in

VT, Prophy, and SSG. Unfortunately I can't really do much analysis of SSG as she hasn't posted here much

The questions I dodged seem to be post 88, and 89?

I ignored 88 because answering that question will only lead to WIFOM unless you wanted me to IC answer it?

in which case, clarify what it is exactly you want me to answer but I'm not going to give a game related answer. You've already made yourself pretty clearly town and there isn't much that isn't going to change it

Rach is also in that pretty clearly town pile, as is Sci

Which means, TNE and ASL are secondary suspicions for me that I don't have interest in. Though, I can see why people suspect him, ASL has been just as useful as my other scumspect, VT and I actually get the feel that ASL is, at the very least, trying to hunt for scum

He has a decent case on you, even though I think it's wrong

[VT]

Mara how do you primary suspect the two people who haven't been posting (and me but that's different) -__-

Humph I thought ICs would make the most sense but you're making as much sense as Mr.Ashtray

Actually I don't even care why you suspect me there could be a number of reasons for that but I'm probably not getting lynched today anyways so at least answer the other two they just don't make sense.

[notscience]

VOTE: VT

lolscumslips

[Cheery Dog]

Vote Count 1.3

Player	L-4 Vote	L-3 Vote	L-2 Vote	L-1 Vote	L-0 Vote (Hammer)	Total Votes
A Simple Plan	VT	Smoker				2
Smoker	RachMarie	A Simple Plan				2
thenewearth	Prophylaxis					1
Prophylaxis	Ms Marangal					1
notscience	Super Serious Gal					1
VT	notscience					1

Not Voting thenewearth

With 9 alive, it takes 5 to lynch Deadline (expired on 2013-08-29 07:00:00)

Seeking replacement for Super Serious Gal
Prophylaxis is on V/LA from 18/8 until 21/8

[Cheery Dog]

CityElectric

replaces Super Serious Gal effective immediately.

[CityElectric]

Obligatory 'Hi I'm here, reading the thread right now ask questions if you want to I have no idea where my vote is so I'm gonna unvote' post.

UNVOTE:

[RachMarie]

yay welcome city

Still fine with my vote at this point still feel like smoker is scum, he has only 2 votes on him why so worried?

[notscience]

Dunno RM, this cockiness is bugging me.

[Smoker]

I really don't have anymore reads to take here. RM you're stupid, sorry.

[CityElectric]

VT looks like a confused newbie the first two pages. Smoker is OMGUSing like mad. Notscience looks equally as confused, but there's some buddying-but-not-really-buddying directed to Mara, which could either indicate scumteam or trying to save his ass by asking the IC player for help. It's too early to call scumteam (we haven't had any flips yet, etc), also this would be a ridiculously dumb move, so I'm putting my money on the second explanation. ASP correctly calls out Smoker on the OMGUS, good call. Smoker looks like he is role-fishing, which he probably is doing, which is bad. He'd also be a good policy lynch. Dunno if I could stand another day with that posting style. There is so much coming out that I find it hard to decide what's just noise, and what is good stuff. //endtrainofthoughts

VOTE: VT

lolscumslips

I'd love to see an explanation for that.

Aaand I feel like I didn't get much wiser reading all of that. Smoker produces a ridiculous amount of noise which makes him hard to read for me, I'm guessing VT to be newbtown, ASP's few posts look like he's scumhunting, asking questions etc, which is good, I'd absolutely love to see more out of Prophy before I make a call on that, Rach feels like she might be town, Mara looks good, but she could elaborate on her current vote some more, as she seems sure of it, but I can't tell from her posts why she is so sure, wanna see more out of tne, lot of vote-hopping from notscience, all with minimal to no explanation, do not like.