The Walking Dead Mafia! ( Game Over )

[MattP]

I've definitely been rolecopped actually now that I think about it

[sangres]

I don't know if I could read DGB correctly. I do know I can read mollie. They're town.

[TheIrishPope]

Oh do me do me
You know my play better than anyone I reckon

[Thor665]

Posting from an iPad so my walls are less wall-like. If I missed responding to something it is because it was so boring I forgot it.

@sugar - I see less than no reason to justify how I am treating your slot as one player. Sign your posts or don't. You are one slot and should behave and be treated as such and I find it scummy you are implying specifically otherwise. Please die.

Someone asked me about pitoli/metal. Yes, I agree my read there is weak now. There is a reason I am no longer vocally defending the slot.

I was asked to weigh in on what Sugar did as regards being asked to respond to their thoughts on a read. There is no pass for justifying an old read because it has now changed. That is my thought.

I was asked about my other scum reads even as Sugar bemoans them. Read m0ar.

Matt is still scummy, no one notices.

Someone wanted my sheep on Mastin. I think my Sugar wagon is currently bigger. I will move to the bigger one at any given point, I am a flexible guy.

That is me.

[Thor665]

For the record, I did try multi quote, but iPad no me gusts it.

[Sugar Cain]

Oh do me do me
You know my play better than anyone I reckon

that hurts...

Nacho, what is your read on Thor?

~sugar

[Metal Sonic]

if people still think im scum after i took all that time to read and post a proper reads list i am going to get very, very pissed off


calling me poison is ok -- I even agree
calling me scum is not

[Metal Sonic]

VOTE: OGML

[TheIrishPope]

Mara, you're scumreading me, so something's off

[sangres]

Nacho, what is your read on Thor?

He has a beard!
I wasn't aware you were scumreading TiP. Why is he scum and why aren't you pushing on him as hard as you are with your other reads?

[Sugar Cain]

all of TIP's recent posts feel incredibly forced and I don't have any kind of idea where his town-reads lie, Except for maybe RC (though that's based on the fact that he's voting us for voting him and I don't know why he's town-reading us) and that is usually apparent at this time. This question to us voting RC looks forced, his questioning of NBH looks forced, and his interaction with Sonic is minimal. The fact that he's voting for someone who he doesn't think is scum? is kinda strange. It's teetering the line between scum and town TIP

[No Brains Here]

VOTE: metal sonic

[Metal Sonic]

^was that mollie or dgb

[Sugar Cain]

I think it would be pretty bastardly to give only the town ways to interact with the horde. I really hate it that you are dancing around this possibility when its seems like common sense.

I also hate the fact that you are seemingly defending NBH but also arguing and calling it scum.

No, you are implying that NBH has to be a scum herder. I am saying that there could very easily be a scum herder in addition to NBH and Toog.

Thank you so much for telling me what I think. I get so scatterbrained sometimes and don't know what the fuck I write. True, my gut reaction was to vote NBH though 3017 was just a general statement that I don't think that town are the only ones with abilities to affect the horde. Now to me, herder seems like a limited vig. So you think we have atleast 2 town herders, a baiter AND a town vig.

As I've said at least three times already and will continue to say as long as I keep being misrepresented. I see NBH as town based on their claim alone, but there's also something to be said for them taking credit for the chess kill. Now, maybe they're just bsing and chess was killed by pure coincidence so they jumped on it, but you have to look at it from the perspective of "what are the odds" and make an educated decision. bork had a pretty good argument on Michonne being a fakeclaim, but that's just a tough pill for me to swallow. Michonne is pretty damn central to the plot. Arguably the fourth most important character of Season 3 behind Rick, Carl, and maybe Daryl/Glenn.

So anyone with a main character is town? I think the way you are fence sitting on NBH is scummy as all get out. You have a town read on said slot for the claim but in some post somewhere you said "I'd be all over you if you weren't voting MS." So you are paranoid about the slot. Ok that would be cool if you didn't call OUR paranoia scummy. Why would you call us scummy for something you yourself are doing?

[sangres]

Oh do me do me
You know my play better than anyone I reckon

I'm going to assume you're asking Nacho because I've been wrong about you a lot recently.

[Sugar Cain]

By the way, an Amrun kill screams Metal Sonic scum.

Amrun was killed by walkers, she was not a scum kill unless you are claiming to have sent walkers her way which is what this sounds like to me.

[Sugar Cain]

RC, can I get your reads on a few players.

Bork?
AD?
TIP?

[Sugar Cain]

oh and mastintoo?

See what I did thar?

[Desperado]

Matt: earlier you said unequivocally that you could self-confirm. Now you're hedging. Why?

[MattP]

Matt: earlier you said unequivocally that you could self-confirm. Now you're hedging. Why?

What a stupid post

Like is this rhetorical? Or do you want me to defend myself against this?

[MattP]

I haven't had the most of luck with my role and what I'd like to do given that it's already day 3. But I CAN at some point confirm my role given a specific circumstance, and perhaps other circumstances I'm unaware of. There is, however, on situation which would absolutely allow me to confirm myself

[MattP]

Not confirm myself as being town necessarily but confirm my role, because really unless I'm a damn IC you're not going to be convinced I'm town

[Desperado]

And yet, I have a confirmable power role

So Im done with the irritating exchange you've sucked me into

It's ok I respect you enough as a person to think you would not have a pathetic lynch list

@Matt - Do you think you're being illogical?
You have fear that I'm suggesting you are - why not just point out how you're not?
You still haven't explained my logical fallacy, maybe that's a place to start? I even explained to you explicitly how to answer the question when you got confused about how to go about it.

Here's my issue.

I don't like your line of questioning because I don't believe you really think it's a useful line of questioning. I think you're trying to lead me by the leash and make me subservient to you by making me feel like I have something to prove to you. It's like you're trying to shut me up and trying to prevent me from having any sort of leadership role by calling me scum and keeping me absorbed in trying to please you with roundabout questioning. Whatever, you're being incredibly technical towards me, that's one thing, but then you JUST SO HAPPEN to have every single powerful player in the game as a scum read and have tried getting every single player that has power to look bad. I am not appealing to your line of questioning because I see no benefit in continuing with it. I am not fearful of anything, I'm frustrated.

Don't worry, I don't expect you to be any less vindictive because of it, just direct your energy towards being redundant with other people about me rather than being redundant towards me. I'd rather that because at the end of the day you're powerless towards me because I know I have a confirmable role and therefore I can stop a conversation I feel is unproductive without worrying about how it changes my position in the game.

See? You're trying to make me explain myself but I'm telling you I don't have to because I have nothing to prove. So now you're in a pickle where you don't know how to continue distracting me from everything else in the game. Oh the joy of confirmable roles!

Matt: earlier you said unequivocally that you could self-confirm. Now you're hedging. Why?

What a stupid post

Like is this rhetorical? Or do you want me to defend myself against this?

No it isn't rhetorical, and why do you feel like you need to defend yourself against anything?

Your original position was your role could self-confirm, end of story--and you used that interpretation as a pretense for ending a conversation with someone (Thor?)

Now you can maybe sorta-confirm your role in the right circumstances.

So which is it? If it's the latter, why were you exaggerating your ability to self-confirm?

[MattP]

The issue is that you're either stupid or impatient for pushing me. I've said I have a role that will let me confirm myself potentially eventually, I've semi locked myself into a damning claim if scum, so why are you even wasting time on this and soft rolefishing instead of just waiting until like final 7 and seeing if I'm still around and stalling then? You're not going to actually lynch someone in my position right now given the situation, so stop wasting time

Pedit: You're annoying. I literally don't understand why you're going on with this conversation right now in the game state. Do you have ADHD?

[Desperado]

I'm not even pushing you what the fuck is wrong with you?

You've made two contradictory statements. The first statement was used to prematurely end a line of conversation, and the 2nd one calls the validity of the first into question--do you honestly think this isn't interesting or worth pursuing?

And you just said that you can't confirm your alignment, just your role, so how exactly are you locking yourself into a damning claim if scum?