Micro 199 Nonsensical Narnia Day 4

[RachMarie]

Vote Count 3.1


BROseidon (1) TMTOLBTWNTOF
TMTOLBTWNTOF (1) borkjerfkin



penguin_alien, BROseidon, MC RIDE


With 5 players, it takes 3 to lynch.



Deadline is in (expired on 2013-09-04 18:06:44)

[TMTOLBTWNTOF]

You just had to clear the guy that everyone thought was town. Maybe you'll track letters tonight?

Mod, theoretically, can the last member of the mafia boh action and kill on the same night?

Yes

Evidently he doesn't think I'm town. Lynch between BRO and bork, please.

You just had to clear the guy that everyone thought was town. Maybe you'll track letters tonight?

Even-night tracker, remember?

In a game with multiple X-shot roles.

A point was being made there and I'm not sure you got it.

[BROseidon]

I was only talking about the second sentence. I got the point made in the first sentence.

[penguin_alien]

I was only talking about the second sentence. I got the point made in the first sentence.

And what if I fessed up to being an odd-night cop? Bork claimed after everyone else; why would scum-bork make a claim that's out of line with the apparent mechanics? GM managed to fake X-shotness, after all. And in role madness, bork could have easily claimed he was saving his shots for when we were at likely one scum to function as a cop, eliminating the question of why he didn't use them pronto.

[BROseidon]

And what if I fessed up to being an odd-night cop? Bork claimed after everyone else; why would scum-bork make a claim that's out of line with the apparent mechanics? GM managed to fake X-shotness, after all. And in role madness, bork could have easily claimed he was saving his shots for when we were at likely one scum to function as a cop, eliminating the question of why he didn't use them pronto.

Then I would admit that bork being even-night is not a good argument against his claim.

And GM didn't fake being X-shot. He faked being town. He even claimed 1-shot, which is what he flipped.

[penguin_alien]

So GM's smart enough to blend in where bork isn't? Scum-bork has skills; I'm having a hard time seeing him do this.

Notable stuff from GM's ISO:

#116: talks about figuring out who of {MC, TMT, AS} is a legit claim
Elsewhere, GM spends a lot of time going after TMT where she doesn't anyone else like that. She answers bork's questions, but her interactions with BRO are pretty...easy?

If other town people are looking for where to go, may I request you read GM's ISO? It's 79 posts, buts many are one-liners.

[MC RIDE]

Whatever. bork is scum. If he isn't, then p_a is.

VOTE: bork

[TMTOLBTWNTOF]

Whatever. bork is scum. If he isn't, then p_a is.

VOTE: bork

p_a isn't scum. There is no universe in which p_a is scum.

Why is bro town?

Vla until THURS

dear mod

Noted....

[BROseidon]

I hate gm's interactions with both bork and letters.

MC, why do you think p_a is scum? I'm finding it very unlikely given the way that AA9 returned an innocent result after the miller claim, when scum would presumably have no way of knowing that....

Wait...

FUCK MY PARANOIA. PA IF YOU'RE SCUM I KNOW WHAT ROLE YOU ARE AND YOU'VE HAD IT BEFORE GOD DAMMIT.

I hate role cops.

[MC RIDE]

AA9 is a wildcard. A dice roll makes more sense then her actions. I mean, she really went and claimed cop with an INNOCENT result.

Also this is a 9p game. Two investigative roles is too much. Way too much for 7 town players. Especially with the Miller not existing. We can just lynch p_a and bork and win this easily.

[penguin_alien]

...and the motive for undermining a miller claim would be what, exactly? I could see cluing in my scum buddy, but the better play would be letting town policy wagon the miller and let them go down in flames when the IC reveal happened. Or, more likely, rolecop someone more useful, and I wouldn't expect goodmorning to have let AA9 get away with rolecopping AS.

So MC, two investigative avenues is crazy, but two townies who can take people out with their lynches isn't?

[MC RIDE]

Shit. I have an idea. Everybody post their three character choices. In order. Here are mine:

Tash
Prince Corin
Andrew Ketterly

[MC RIDE]

...and the motive for undermining a miller claim would be what, exactly? I could see cluing in my scum buddy, but the better play would be letting town policy wagon the miller and let them go down in flames when the IC reveal happened. Or, more likely, rolecop someone more useful, and I wouldn't expect goodmorning to have let AA9 get away with rolecopping AS.

So MC, two investigative avenues is crazy, but two townies who can take people out with their lynches isn't?

Here's the kick: AA never saw AS's Miller claim. Hell, she could be faking the cop stuff and all. She just chose to clear AS who was for lynching me which happened to be the way of skipping lylo if both me and bro were town.

I can really see this happening. VOTE: p_a

[BROseidon]

I agree with everyone posting their 3 characters:

White Witch
Caspian
Aslan

Also, PA, it could make sense as a gambit coming from a rolecop. Investigating a miller to check for auxiliary roles wouldn't be absurd, and then seeing IC would be a good place to build tons of towncred. That's what I'm paranoid about.

[BROseidon]

Still biasing towards bork, though.

[borkjerfkin]

So GM's smart enough to blend in where bork isn't? Scum-bork has skills; I'm having a hard time seeing him do this.

As much as I like the fact that you're reading me correctly, I want to know exactly what you're talking about here.

I hate gm's interactions with both bork and letters.

MC, why do you think p_a is scum? I'm finding it very unlikely given the way that AA9 returned an innocent result after the miller claim, when scum would presumably have no way of knowing that....

Wait...

FUCK MY PARANOIA. PA IF YOU'RE SCUM I KNOW WHAT ROLE YOU ARE AND YOU'VE HAD IT BEFORE GOD DAMMIT.

I hate role cops.

Point to any interaction between GM and me that looks like scum-scum; I'll wait.

Oh, and that caps line looks forced as hell - everyone should remember that it was AA and not penguin when that slot investigated AS, but there's the seam there where it makes sense for that slot to be scum because

penguin

has done this sort of thing before. It just looks like a cheap way to widen the lynch pool when up against the wall.

I really really do not think penguin is scum - I am about 90% sure that scum lies between TMT and BRO.

[BROseidon]

1) There are almost no interactions between you and GM. That's what I don't lik.

2) You reached like fuck there. I never said that PA has pulled off a gambit like I've postulated before, just that it's a role that she's had before (she was mafia rolecop in Philosopher's Stone mafia). And I'd hardly call myself "up against the wall" right now. I'm fairly sure you can read better than that

[MC RIDE]

Letters is absolutely town. We do not lynch Letters.

[BROseidon]

All right then.

VOTE: Bork

[penguin_alien]

bork, I'm saying that if one saw town with a bunch of X-shot roles, why wouldn't one claim a power as X-shot as well if one was scum faking?

I'll see if the mod will give me AA9's list of characters...

[penguin_alien]

AA9's list was Aslan, Peter, Susan (only one I'd overlap on is Susan, FTR)

[borkjerfkin]

1) There are almost no interactions between you and GM. That's what I don't lik.

2) You reached like fuck there. I never said that PA has pulled off a gambit like I've postulated before, just that it's a role that she's had before (she was mafia rolecop in Philosopher's Stone mafia). And I'd hardly call myself "up against the wall" right now. I'm fairly sure you can read better than that

1) I don't agree - she responded pretty well to my push on D1 and I left her alone a bit on D2 as I thought she was probtown.

2) Where does the paranoia come from then if you've not seen this sort of thing from her?

Whichever of you is scum IS up against the wall right now; you're up against a wall in the hypothetical case that it is you, and there is concrete scum motivation to keep the penguin lynch in your back pocket when you need to MLs to win.

bork, I'm saying that if one saw town with a bunch of X-shot roles, why wouldn't one claim a power as X-shot as well if one was scum faking?

Meh, there are a number of reasons I don't agree with this: 1) setups generally have no precedent for containing only 1-shot roles 2) general WIFOM 3) fakeclaims are generally available to scum (I doubt GM pulled her claim out of her ass). I am what I said I am.

As stated before, I have no list and told Rach to pick for me.

Letters is absolutely town. We do not lynch Letters.

Seriously, show me

[BROseidon]

1) I don't agree - she responded pretty well to my push on D1 and I left her alone a bit on D2 as I thought she was probtown.

2) Where does the paranoia come from then if you've not seen this sort of thing from her?

1) I'll reread those interactions

2) Respect for PA's scumgame. That I've seen a possible gambit makes me nervous, because I know she could see the same thing and have the balls to execute on it. Notice how my vote is still on you, though

[borkjerfkin]

Notice how my vote is still on you, though

Yes I've noticed that you're contributing to a scum win

[MC RIDE]

bork are you going to post your choices?