Okay, catching up and keeping track of FoS's. I'll have a new FoS count up when I finish.
In post 68, Minions wrote:
I can't speak for my brothers but I have always advocated that if you elect a kingmaker you put the decision on their shoulders, it's how you get to then read them through the lynch. Yes, here we have to vote between his/her two options but if you take that decision out of thier hands you get no analysis of them through the choices.
A person willing to put that pressure on the position is a person I trust to make an intelligent one.
I can understand wanting the HoH to have the responsibility to pick the 2 lynch candidates, but that shouldn't stop anyone from scumhunting. Everyone should be held accountable in this game.
In post 68, Minions wrote:
And as for bulbazak throwing down an fos on us when I'm the only one to post and it was the RVS first posts of the game... That's either an agenda or thinking we are low hanging fruit. Either way you are on our radar even before I get to the attempt to dictate how we will all handle this unique system.
Getting RVS confused is understandable. Keeping your vote for HoH on a person you randomly selected after you realized your mistake is not. Btw, you never answered my question concerning this.
In post 80, Minions wrote:
I dont agree with the whole "PL KBW" and Im getting bad vibes of both Jake and Bulb for suggesting it.
If you'd played with KBW before, you would not be saying this.
In post 82, Imperium wrote:
In post 43, Bulbazak wrote:Except RVS is completely useless in this setup, instead of somewhat useless, making what Minions did fluff and suspect.
This is still a pretty bad attack.
How is it bad? Minions cast a random vote for HoH, and then kept it on that person after they realized their mistake, which makes me think it's not random. Therefore, I think that them forgetting the way the votes worked was fake.
In post 82, Imperium wrote:
In post 49, Bulbazak wrote:I can trust to make that tough decision for the betterment of the town by themselves.
If you trust someone enough to give them the chance to pick whatever lynch they want all by themselves, then you should probably just sheep the player you believe will be the most accurate. No?
I think you're misunderstanding my position. I still think that everyone should scumhunt as usual. However, if I have put my confidence in a person enough to elect them as HoH, then that means that I trust their judgement to make the lynch nominations on their own. Since then, though, I've had a change of heart, and I believe that we should have 1 of the nominations be made by the town based on whoever has the most FoS's or pressure votes or whatever you want to call them, and 1 of the nominations should be made by the HoH.
In post 84, Minions wrote:Explain why we should quicklynch KBW for not being active yet spare Gnomeo? Thats your only standard, right?
Very opportunistic.
~ Dave
The PL of KBW is not because of activity. Why would you even bring this up? And why are you continually interested in Gnomeo, to the point where you seem to hold him in high regard?
In post 85, Titus wrote:
Look at BB15. All the racists and other scum manipulated the house to keep them. A player who plays like Amanda would live due to the defensive wall around them. There is no accountability because "The house wanted it." It's bullshit. We are accountable by revealing our votes in the day.
This is actually a very good point.
In post 91, BBmolla wrote: In post 51, Bulbazak wrote:How about a compromise? We use FoS's, or whatever, as pseudo-votes. Whoever has the most p-votes by the end of the day is the first one to be nominated. The second one to be nominated is entirely decided by the HoH, which allows them to put one of their own scumreads on the chopping block. There is still accountability, night votes can still be a basis for scumhunting, and we get information based off of this random factor.
This would only help scum change a close lynch on their buddy to a lynch on a random.
How would it do that? You're assuming that the town nomination will be on scum and the HoH nomination won't. In fact, it could be the other way around. In fact, this way we are more likely to catch tricky scum which might slip through the town's fingers if we relied on majority.
On to page 6.
P-edit: Seriously?! You prod me while I'm typing up a post?
