Mini 1492: Harry Potter and the Chamber of Secrets GAME OVER

[RachMarie]

Feg you can't compare this game with the one where I was the Doc and DC was the JK and mainly all I had to do was make sure I protected him every night. And I was wrong if you recall I was so sure that Hiraki was scum and once he was replaced by SD it turned out he was not scum after all

Plus in addition to my injured knee I have been sick I hate being sick.

[Toomai]

I really want to post but I have nothing to contribute. I have weak, aggregate reads on four players and doubt the correctness of all of them.

Which four players? Why do you have the reads you have on those players?

JasonWazza: Slightly scummy because of what he's done so far (i.e. nothing but claim that he has a scumread and that he'll elaborate later). To be honest I feel like I should consider him null until he actually elaborates, but I feel his attitude about it (especially early on) is anti-town at best.
LnGrrrR: Slightly town because...don't know to be honest, it's mostly an aggregate of extremely slightly town posts.
Fegelein: Slightly town for the same reason as LnGrrrR (i.e. basically gut).
Squilly: Currently of the opinion he's newbietown, since I think someone with claimed offline experience would put a bit more work into learning how to be town online.

[RachMarie]

whoops wrong game

This one was the one we were in together

http://forum.mafiascum.net/viewtopic.php?f=51&t=27888

That was before I injured my knee duh. Which limits the amount of time I am on the computer and some of that time has to be spent on work stuffs since I work from home.

[Amrun]

I don't find Jason an interesting vote at all so far (based on what I've seen of him before) but his Amrun vote needs to move.

UNVOTE: LnGrrR
VOTE: StubbsKVM

Amrun, with me. I get the impression we'll have to leave LnGrrR for later.

BLEGH BLEGH BLEGH

But okay. Let's remain united.

VOTE: Stubbs

[Amrun]

I really want to post but I have nothing to contribute. I have weak, aggregate reads on four players and doubt the correctness of all of them.

Which four players? Why do you have the reads you have on those players?

JasonWazza: Slightly scummy because of what he's done so far (i.e. nothing but claim that he has a scumread and that he'll elaborate later). To be honest I feel like I should consider him null until he actually elaborates, but I feel his attitude about it (especially early on) is anti-town at best.
LnGrrrR: Slightly town because...don't know to be honest, it's mostly an aggregate of extremely slightly town posts.
Fegelein: Slightly town for the same reason as LnGrrrR (i.e. basically gut).
Squilly: Currently of the opinion he's newbietown, since I think someone with claimed offline experience would put a bit more work into learning how to be town online.

Don't have any reads on anyone else?

[JasonWazza]

Post that contains nothing game relevant and is clearly a prod dodge cause my birthday was yesterday.

[Toomai]

I really want to post but I have nothing to contribute. I have weak, aggregate reads on four players and doubt the correctness of all of them.

Which four players? Why do you have the reads you have on those players?

JasonWazza: Slightly scummy because of what he's done so far (i.e. nothing but claim that he has a scumread and that he'll elaborate later). To be honest I feel like I should consider him null until he actually elaborates, but I feel his attitude about it (especially early on) is anti-town at best.
LnGrrrR: Slightly town because...don't know to be honest, it's mostly an aggregate of extremely slightly town posts.
Fegelein: Slightly town for the same reason as LnGrrrR (i.e. basically gut).
Squilly: Currently of the opinion he's newbietown, since I think someone with claimed offline experience would put a bit more work into learning how to be town online.

Don't have any reads on anyone else?

Nope. Everyone else is pure null or like 1% away from pure null.

[Amrun]

What are you doing about that?

[Toomai]

Hoping something happens because I don't know how to make things happen.

[LnGrrrR]

@Toomai, how many games have you played before? Any here?

[LnGrrrR]

Nevermind, saw the sig. Can you tell us what games you have played in, and whether you were scum, town or other?

[Toomai]

It's all on the wiki page.

Short version: Finished four games, was VT in all of them, felt like dead weight for about the first half of the game in all of them.

[Nexus]

Marquis replaces Squilly

oriole and penguin_alien have both been prodded.

[ChannelDelibird]

Stubbs is not genuinely hunting for scum. Can we please have more votes on him?

[Amrun]

Stubbs is trying to fit in. Can we please havenorevotes for him?

[penguin_alien]

I'll see what Squilly's replacement does.

UNVOTE: Squilly

Stubbs, what's your rationale for voting Squilly-slot over JasonWazza?

[Marquis]

Hey everyone, let's find some scum! I'm so excited~

[Marquis]

oh god this is easy

VOTE: RachMarie

[Syryana]

I won't be chivvied into voting before I'm ready to vote.

I will never understand people who approach the game this way

Welcome to feryland, we hope you enjoy your stay.

Last game I played with her, she was a little more up-front and helpful. Now it's as if she's shouting stuff from the sidelines and not getting involved. Basically a variation of backseating.

What the fuck are you talking about? Fery's town as fuck.

I don't find Jason an interesting vote at all so far (based on what I've seen of him before) but his Amrun vote needs to move.

Why isn't Jason interesting?

@Feg, what game did you recently play with Rach? In both of my completed games on this site, Rach was in them, one as scum and one as town, and in both she was pretty lurky. (The only reason she wasn't lynched in the town game was that she was the doc; she was run up the first Day.)

What do you think of Rach in this game?

Post that contains nothing game relevant and is clearly a prod dodge cause my birthday was yesterday.

Must be one hell of a hangover.

Hoping something happens because I don't know how to make things happen.

Ask questions? Prod people? Vote?

Stubbs is not genuinely hunting for scum. Can we please have more votes on him?

Why should I vote Stubbs over Jason?

Stubbs is trying to fit in. Can we please havenorevotes for him?

What are your current reads?

oh god this is easy

VOTE: RachMarie

Wat.

Fery, we need to have a get together and hash some people out. Come play wizu me plzkthx. I'll make you some peasant food n' shit.

[Amrun]

What are your current reads?

You just quoted one of them. I think I have shared enough. Don't nightkill me bro

[Nexus]

“Of all the trees we could've hit, we had to get one that hits back.” - Ron Weasley

Votecount 1.5:

Marquis (3)-

LnGrrrR, RachMarie, StubbsKVM

JasonWazza (3)-

Fegelein, Toomai, Syryana

StubbsKVM (2)-

ChannelDelibird, Amrun

Amrun (1)-

JasonWazza

RachMarie (1)-

Squilly

Not Voting (3)-

fferyllt, oriole, penguin_alien

Day 1 will end at 11pm BST on Thursday 5th September 2013. With 13 alive it takes 7 to lynch.

[ChannelDelibird]

In case I hadn't sufficiently implied it, my previous experience with Jason leads me to believe that he is not doing anything particularly differently here to when I have seen him as town before. With that in mind, Stubbs is actually scummy, so that's why you should vote for him.

Marquis, given RachMarie's pretty good reasons for not being here very much, you should probably vote for scum while you give her time to do things.

[fferyllt]

I won't be chivvied into voting before I'm ready to vote.

I will never understand people who approach the game this way

Welcome to feryland, we hope you enjoy your stay.

Heh.

Last game I played with her, she was a little more up-front and helpful. Now it's as if she's shouting stuff from the sidelines and not getting involved. Basically a variation of backseating.

What the fuck are you talking about? Fery's town as fuck.

I double-taked on that, too. But, he's saying this explanation of his read on Rach also applies to my question, not to my play. I think.

Fery, we need to have a get together and hash some people out. Come play wizu me plzkthx. I'll make you some peasant food n' shit.

What's cooking?

[Syryana]

What are your current reads?

You just quoted one of them. I think I have shared enough. Don't nightkill me bro

In case I hadn't sufficiently implied it, my previous experience with Jason leads me to believe that he is not doing anything particularly differently here to when I have seen him as town before. With that in mind, Stubbs is actually scummy, so that's why you should vote for him.

We have pretty vastly different previous experiences with him then. I nailed his scum ass for this sort of shit in Vengeball.

I'm not seeing this lack of genuine scumhunting from Stubbs you're talking about, or this trying to fit in Amrun's talking about. Show me.

Fery, we need to have a get together and hash some people out. Come play wizu me plzkthx. I'll make you some peasant food n' shit.

What's cooking?

I'm throwing CDB and Amrun in some stew but I'm not sure what seasonings to use. Your thoughts?

[Amrun]

That is a terrifying gif.

Look at Stubbs' reads list, and when it was made, and his response about oriole. LOOK AT IT