Open 527 - Hard Boiled: Dixon Hill's Maudlin Madness

[Sound of Silence]

TF gets a scumread for not saying I'm obvtown

Yeah yeah whatevs.

Any reads?

[Syryana]

Votecount 1.5

SalmonellaDoctor ( 5 ): Sound of Silence, Cephrir, Shodan, 1baldeagle1, Mac (L-2)
Trolling Fairy ( 1 ): Cait Sith
Natirasha ( 1 ): Natirasha
Shodan ( 1 ): Trolling Fairy
Not Voting ( 5 ): Violent Saxophone, BROseidon, SalmonellaDoctor, TheIrishPope, notscience

With 13 alive, it takes 7 to lynch.

Deadline is in (expired on 2013-09-15 11:54:00)

[Natirasha]

TF gets a scumread for not saying I'm obvtown

Yeah yeah whatevs.

Any reads?

Yeah, sorry. This game's been low on my priority list whatwith the nine other games I'm in right now. It's late, I'll get back to you tomorrow. Feel free to violently prod me if I don't.

[Mac]

oh.

ns is obvtown?

vote: notscience

[VioleNt Saxophone]

Hi MAjiffy tell Mara I'm obvtown

lol, that was me

Jiffy hasn't done anything yet

he won't even talk to me

Mala, you're scum and Tammy's town and I don't talk to scum

(on a serious note)

I did touch up on your post, but I didn't have the time to comment on it however I did take it into consideration or, at least the differing opinions you have on me

hence my unvote

I don't remember you being around earlygame for HD2

I do remember you doing most of the late game posting though

TF: I think ns is town, but not god-town (mostlycuzIlikeseeinghimcryaboutit)

[Trolling Fairy]

Re: metashift: I'm not going to talk about the direction yet because I might still do it. Suffice to say I've been waiting for a town role PM though.

I look forward to witnessing it!

I like the Dreams part of SD. The DP part set off a few alarms. We decided to put our vote there.

I thought DP's attack on NS left him smelling like roses, personally.

TF gets a scumread for not saying I'm obvtown

Yeah yeah whatevs.

Any reads?

Yeah, sorry. This game's been low on my priority list whatwith the nine other games I'm in right now. It's late, I'll get back to you tomorrow. Feel free to violently prod me if I don't.

[Sound of Silence]

I thought DP's attack on NS left him smelling like roses, personally.

How so?

[Sound of Silence]

And what did you think of 222?

[Shodan]

Xegarus and I are currently in talks about the game state and who we find suspicious. Stay tuned for a post in the next 12 hours.

Love, Bert

[Trolling Fairy]

TiP is town.
NS is town.
Violent Saxophone is town.
1baldeagle1 is town.

Still reading other players.

~SD

Lol.

Hey ns, remember when we were the hider and we got quicklynched day 1. and we did not claim in the previous iteration of Hard Boiled?
We were against the breaking tactic. I was against it because I thought Amrun was saying it for town cred. And where did that get us?

Remember Mala's Assassin in the Palace where YOU yourself suggested the breaking mechanic? And when I voted you for it, you said you were playing to win? What gives?

Not to mention you mention why I havent been here to discuss this when its pretty clear that we live on two different timezones. Its almost as if you were trying to imply something here.

Nonetheless, I think your reaction to the notion was bad.

VOTE: notscience

Yah dont waste your votes. Sheep me on ns. (No idea why Sal saying that warrants votes)

DP

I thought that the immediate attack on NS right after his partner declared a townread on him was pretty townish because I'd expect them to have some sort of coordination while scum, but DP's NS scumread would trump Sal's townread on him since DP and NS have hydra'ed together before. I also thought that the attack itself seemed like something scumDP would have trouble faking; he and NS were pretty much lynched last hardboiled because they were against gamebreaking and thought that Amrun was scum and pushed it in an extremely passionate way; NS lacking that same passion here is a red flag that makes sense and picking up on that would be immensely impressive for DP.

And what did you think of 222?

It wasn't that interesting to me. Why didn't you like it?

Xegarus and I are currently in talks about the game state and who we find suspicious. Stay tuned for a post in the next 12 hours.

Love, Bert

I'll be waiting, love!

[Sound of Silence]

It wasn't that interesting to me. Why didn't you like it?

Neither of us liked it It looked overworked. If you're town and you have your vote on someone who subsequently outs as a PR in an open game, do you really point out that it's an un-CC'd PR claim when you take your vote off?

Compared to the other unvotes, it sticks out.

[1baldeagle1]

TF, I didn't like SD's unvote, it was a bit weird and fishy.

Eagerly awaiting Shodan's post.

Sorry about the inactivity, school started up for me and I'll be posting less.

[SalmonellaDoctor]

baldeagle, have you ever played with a hydra before?

[1baldeagle1]

No. I'm new.

[SalmonellaDoctor]

No. I'm new.

So, essentially, a hydra is two people playing on the same account. This account is a hydra. So, when I unvoted, it's because I disagreed with the other guy using this account, which is DoctorPepper.

[Sound of Silence]

No. I'm new.

So, essentially, a hydra is two people playing on the same account. This account is a hydra. So, when I unvoted, it's because I disagreed with the other guy using this account, which is DoctorPepper.

I thought you unvoted because of the counter claim.

Does DP disbelieve the counteer claim?

[1baldeagle1]

I know what a hydra is, but your question was "Have you ever played with one?"

And, I would like an answer on SoS's question.

[SalmonellaDoctor]

I know what a hydra is, but your question was "Have you ever played with one?"

And, I would like an answer on SoS's question.

Anyways, why do you find hydra dissonance fishy?

No. I'm new.

So, essentially, a hydra is two people playing on the same account. This account is a hydra. So, when I unvoted, it's because I disagreed with the other guy using this account, which is DoctorPepper.

I thought you unvoted because of the counter claim.

Does DP disbelieve the counteer claim?

Counter claim?

And I don't know. Our communication hasn't been too great so far.

But I unvoted because I started out with a town read on NS, and if he's been against set up breaking before as town, then I don't see how it makes him scum in this game.

[Sound of Silence]

Sorry, not the counter claim. The claim.

[Sound of Silence]

I can go with that

VOTE: baldeagle

OH SHUT UP, THIS IS WAAAAAYYY MORE SERIOUS

UNVOTE:
Not voting soft claimed role.

I'm talking about this vote/unvote, not the NS vote/unvote.

I see where the confusion lies

[SalmonellaDoctor]

Oh.

All DP has said so far is that he didn't see the crumb originally, and that bubba is a VI.

Honestly, the crumb makes me think it's more legit, rather than an instance of scum claiming a power role in order to try to survive.

[Sound of Silence]

Oh.

All DP has said so far is that he didn't see the crumb originally, and that bubba is a VI.

Honestly, the crumb makes me think it's more legit, rather than an instance of scum claiming a power role in order to try to survive.

Who posted the unvote?

[SalmonellaDoctor]

Me (SD).

[notscience]

@Nacho because you seem strung up over the lack of passion

I was the one who would HAVE to claim

Who would HAVE to do a great job

Now I don't have that pressure

[Natirasha]

Kay, time for some reads, I guess.

Sound of Silence-ffery always seems very town to me, this game is no exception. Trying to lead the town and generally being an inquisitor of sorts. I wanna hear from the easier-to-read half of the hydra.
Cephrir-Odd guy. I like half his posts, I don't like the other half. Null for now, with a minor town lean.
Shodan-He said I didn't know about his retardedness when I clearly do VERY defensive vs baldeagle, pinged my scumdar some. Hasn't done much otherwise. Probscum.
1baldeagle1-Claimed psych, no counter. NoobTown via default.
Mac-Claimed hider, no counter. Town via default.
Trolling Fairy-I always have trouble reading Cabd when he's not obv town. I like what I've seen, but it's not to obv-town status like in some games. I have next to zero experience with nacho, but Cabd as usual appears to be the primary head. I'm going to say null for now.
Cait Sith-I have little experience with either of these players. Contributions otherwise are solidish. #199 is probably the most town post in game. Otherwise, strong town read.
Violent Saxophone-by which I mean Mara. Contributions are mildly weak in comparison to some, but overall I'm getting a town vibe from the posting. nulltown.
BROseidon-I liked his entrance to the thread. Hasn't done much otherwise. Null.
SalmonellaDoctor-Others mentioned #222's oddness. Reading through his posts, the hydra has deceptively little content, mostly tunneling notscience--which is something I can get behind, but notscience is also a fucking fantastic bus target so that's like null or something. nullscum
TheIrishPope-He has a tell that he always does as town. I'm not pointing it out because I want to utilize in future games. An idiot, but unequivocally town.
notscience-He does this "I'm obvtown" thing every game. He's really hamming up on it this game though. Has about as little content as I do otherwise. His anti-setup gaming is anti-town at best and scummy at worse. Also, channelling his inner-Saki this game and shitting up the place. My current favorite scum.
Syryana-My role PM says that he's actually a serial killer/mod. We should lynch him.

That puts my reads at
conftown{Eagle, Mac}
Probtown{SoS, Cait Sith, TIP}
null{Cabd, Cephrir, BRO, Saxaphone}
Probscum{SD, ns, Shodan}
ConfScum{Syr}