In post 3910, Desperado wrote: In post 3907, mastin2 wrote: In post 3900, PeregrineV wrote:And, you still haven't commented on the claim itself. You've called both players in the discussion "town", but no comment on the particulars of the mechanics of the claim. If you can speculate on the makeup of the scumteam, it seems you are skipping Matt's presented "Scavenger" role.
Commenting on the players both being town itself would have been enough, but there's more. I distinctly remember mentioning in my setup spec talk of a scum backup role being possible.
This was me addressing Matt's claimed role.
And yet, you ignored that.
I'm Carol Peltier.
So are you admitting to fence sitting on Matt or what? You say Matt v NBH is Town v Town but that Matt's claimed role is a possible scum role...?
This is one giant misrep. I think MattP is town,
and that the scum might have an
equivalent
role to Matt's
. Not that MattP, himself, was scum with that role. The speculation was scum having roles to MIRROR TOWN ROLES. In other words, scum having a role equivalent to the town-MattP's role.
In post 3917, PeregrineV wrote:So, you are speculating that scum have a backup role, Matt mentions his role, which sounds like a backup role, but he is town because the argument Matt is having with No Brains is "town on town"? Clearly I was wrong. You stated your thoughts on Matt ("town"), his role ("scum may have a backup role"), and all the other implications he seemed to imply (" ").
Then let's move on to the rest of your speculation. You think scum have a herder. IIRC, NoBrains claimed herder, and AJ claimed herder. Aj flipped Town Herder. Is NoBrains still a herder? If town, what does this mean for the vig claim of OhGod?
For the first--addressed above. Scum wouldn't have a backup role if MattP were scum; scum having a backup role
is reliant on MattP being town
.
For the second--AJ never claimed herder. AJ had that role, yes. But if AJ thought that NBH was scum, he would have voted them. He didn't. Quite the opposite, he insisted that they were town. So, yes. NBH is still a herder, and still a town herder. And it's irrelevant to OGML's vig claim. OGML would be, AT ABSOLUTE WORST, a serial killer, but unless you've got an explanation for the two kills during N1, then OGML's claim is truthful in that he has the ability to shoot people. Thus, vig (what I believe) or serial killer--in either case, not scum.
For a start? The fact that you seem to be popping up in my other scumreads' lynch lists. I also remember some of your posting looking town, and potentially reminiscent of my read on Dan. I can't remember
what
posts they were, though, and that's one of the reasons you're still a scumread; if I knew what posts looked like town, I'd have already analyzed them to figure out if they held water.
I'm not going to have the time today (got a promise to fulfill that will eat up most of my time today) and will be V/LA over the weekend, but it's something I'm planning to follow through on come Monday.
In post 3945, ActionDan wrote:not strong enough. but imo the fact that peregrine is even trying that hard is points for him.
Points, yes.
Scum
points, though. This REEKS of scum jumping onto an easy mislynch.
The fact that PeregrineV is pushing it after the mod cleared it up is proof of that--it's an effort to distract us from the lynch of actual scum. Actual scum, say, such as himself and Titus.
In post 3975, PeregrineV wrote:Mastin is scum for avoiding interaction with players, avoiding game topics, and overuse of theory discussion which he is trying to disguise as content. He is also tunneling AD, but he is scum for his other actions, independent of Dan tunnel.
Except that I've interacted with all the players, addressed every single game topic, brought up theory only as a side-note, am reading ActionDan as town, and have shut down every single reason you've listed for me being scum.
