Open 527 - Hard Boiled: Dixon Hill's Maudlin Madness

Trolling Fairy · Post Post #700 (ISO) » Mon Sep 09, 2013 5:04 pm

In post 562, SalmonellaDoctor wrote:"Cephrir-Odd guy. I like half his posts, I don't like the other half. Null for now,
with a minor town lean.
"

- Natirasha

Translation: I'm not calling my partner town because its too obvious. I'll read him as null-town even if my statement says null because i want to a) find an easy way to potentially distance and b) subtly make people think he's town

My issue here is the fact that it was one of those "weak, not willing to give info" reads that scum LOVE to impart onto buddies

DP

This felt legitimate.

In post 598, SalmonellaDoctor wrote:Lol, its like you can never read me correctly, like, ever.

DP

In post 601, SalmonellaDoctor wrote:TIP is obvtown.

VS is town.

SOS is town.

DP keeps putting his foot in his mouth, but his point on Ceph is valid.

Yeah, we're probably lynch bait.

^I hate hate hate hate HATE it when people try to discredit a wagon on them partially in advance.

In post 666, SalmonellaDoctor wrote:
In post 661, Sound of Silence wrote:SD's disappearance after I crushed his "easy lynch" card is noted.
When exactly did you do this, anyways?

In post 669, SalmonellaDoctor wrote:Oh, yeah, he totally crushed my top tier strategy of claiming I'm lynch bait. Man, he really saw right through me. There goes my scummy for most manipulative player

^More wagon discrediting which is icky.

So yeah, I can see this being scum.

Bert · Post Post #701 (ISO) » Mon Sep 09, 2013 5:04 pm

Nacho does sound robotic, by the way

is he just trying to be methodical and just getting bored with catching up in games

or is he walling it up on purpose, or...

his defense/comments about Ceph's play sounded weird idk why gut-wise

Trolling Fairy · Post Post #702 (ISO) » Mon Sep 09, 2013 5:05 pm

In post 698, Cait Sith wrote:
In post 693, Trolling Fairy wrote:
In post 692, Cait Sith wrote:
In post 686, Trolling Fairy wrote:
In post 682, Cait Sith wrote:Ill give you a couple minutes can barely keep my eyes open. Why'd you have to draw scum?
Tell me about it. Nacho sucks like that. Total scum magnet.

He's stupid enough to not have you as instant town for the huge townslip you made.

I'd kick him upside the head, but the bastard is half the US away from me.
Uh huh uh huh...but if he did that how are you guys going to get enough mislynches to win? Too many people looking townie right now, sucks to be scum.
Heh. Your posting style amuses me. I'm sure we'll figure out a way. Probably bring tip to lylo and let him vote town out the gate or something. (LYT tippy)
Cheeky. What about my posting style is amusing?

I'm just an arrogant ass like that. I dunno, I just started laughing when reading your posts.

In post 699, Cait Sith wrote:
In post 697, Trolling Fairy wrote:Because you're here dancing with me, and I don't see you asking me about him? Lemme look.

I didn't ask you about tip either.
I clicked the ISO above you name, and saw a question about tippy asked of people who have played with him lots.
*plie*

Sound of Silence · Post Post #703 (ISO) » Mon Sep 09, 2013 5:05 pm

In post 691, Trolling Fairy wrote:
In post 654, Cait Sith wrote:I have no idea how to read TiP. I was going to leave that to Mala or you guys who have played with him a bunch.
This is town-TIP. There's a tell I have that is sitting at 100% effectiveness so far, and the only time i've mislynched him was as scum in my hydra with ffery.

GiF has some lingering concerns about TiP. He says that TiP has boasted about winning a game (Mainstream Mafia?) by acting "too dumb to be scum".

Trolling Fairy · Post Post #704 (ISO) » Mon Sep 09, 2013 5:06 pm

In post 701, Bert wrote:Nacho does sound robotic, by the way

is he just trying to be methodical and just getting bored with catching up in games

or is he walling it up on purpose, or...

his defense/comments about Ceph's play sounded weird idk why gut-wise

He's probably too busy being scum with you in Con Mafia.

Trolling Fairy · Post Post #705 (ISO) » Mon Sep 09, 2013 5:06 pm

In post 703, Sound of Silence wrote:
In post 691, Trolling Fairy wrote:
In post 654, Cait Sith wrote:I have no idea how to read TiP. I was going to leave that to Mala or you guys who have played with him a bunch.
This is town-TIP. There's a tell I have that is sitting at 100% effectiveness so far, and the only time i've mislynched him was as scum in my hydra with ffery.
GiF has some lingering concerns about TiP. He says that TiP has boasted about winning a game (Mainstream Mafia?) by acting "too dumb to be scum".

Been there, read that, the tell applied to that game too.

Cait Sith · Post Post #706 (ISO) » Mon Sep 09, 2013 5:07 pm

Oh we'll that's fine. As long as I'm not boring. I hate being boring. I don't mind being laughed at.

What I was looking at with sd was post 598. That's what struck me as kinda townish.

Cait Sith · Post Post #707 (ISO) » Mon Sep 09, 2013 5:07 pm

*pas de chat*

Trolling Fairy · Post Post #708 (ISO) » Mon Sep 09, 2013 5:08 pm

In post 705, Trolling Fairy wrote:
In post 703, Sound of Silence wrote:
In post 691, Trolling Fairy wrote:
In post 654, Cait Sith wrote:I have no idea how to read TiP. I was going to leave that to Mala or you guys who have played with him a bunch.
This is town-TIP. There's a tell I have that is sitting at 100% effectiveness so far, and the only time i've mislynched him was as scum in my hydra with ffery.
GiF has some lingering concerns about TiP. He says that TiP has boasted about winning a game (Mainstream Mafia?) by acting "too dumb to be scum".
Been there, read that, the tell applied to that game too.

Furthermore, that game was a cult game, it's not exactly the same as a scumgame. Tippy was the recruiter and allowed his recruits to do the heavy lifting for the most part. That wouldn't work here even if he were to attempt it.

Sound of Silence · Post Post #709 (ISO) » Mon Sep 09, 2013 5:09 pm

In post 705, Trolling Fairy wrote:
In post 703, Sound of Silence wrote:
In post 691, Trolling Fairy wrote:
In post 654, Cait Sith wrote:I have no idea how to read TiP. I was going to leave that to Mala or you guys who have played with him a bunch.
This is town-TIP. There's a tell I have that is sitting at 100% effectiveness so far, and the only time i've mislynched him was as scum in my hydra with ffery.
GiF has some lingering concerns about TiP. He says that TiP has boasted about winning a game (Mainstream Mafia?) by acting "too dumb to be scum".
Been there, read that, the tell applied to that game too.

I know GiF's role card.

But, even if you're scum you'd probably be happy to have a TiP bus in your hip pocket, so I will let GiF hash this out with you if he wants to.

Trolling Fairy · Post Post #710 (ISO) » Mon Sep 09, 2013 5:09 pm

598 is pretty much exactly what I said to prohawk in Xenologue mafia. I was scum, he was town. I got him mislynched.

Trolling Fairy · Post Post #711 (ISO) » Mon Sep 09, 2013 5:10 pm

In post 707, Cait Sith wrote:*pas de chat*

Feel free to get some sleep if you need it. I'm back and i'll be here all day tomorrow. Just yell at the screen until I show up.

Bert · Post Post #712 (ISO) » Mon Sep 09, 2013 5:11 pm

In post 598, SalmonellaDoctor wrote:Lol, its like you can never read me correctly, like, ever.

DP

This? Yeah, it soudned bad to me too

Cait Sith · Post Post #713 (ISO) » Mon Sep 09, 2013 5:13 pm

Yeah I can't stay awake any longer at all.

*bow*

Trolling Fairy · Post Post #714 (ISO) » Mon Sep 09, 2013 5:14 pm

In post 710, Trolling Fairy wrote:598 is pretty much exactly what I said to prohawk in Xenologue mafia. I was scum, he was town. I got him mislynched.

Here it is, found it:

In post 584, morph the cat wrote:
In post 559, Oil Tycoons wrote:Although we both wonder how well cabd can read prohawk and we'd be appreciative if you could clear that up for us.
I can't read prohawk for shit until a few days have gone by usually. Also, our hydra game was a scumgame, so my reads there were all faked. (And well faked if I do say so myself) The "Cabd: Arceus of Meta" thing is something I developed here and is very different from my approach to the game on our shared home site (Sixprizes)

He does have a history of reading me incorrectly, however,
so the lack of being able to read the other thing is mutual.

Cait Sith · Post Post #715 (ISO) » Mon Sep 09, 2013 5:14 pm

In post 712, Bert wrote:
In post 598, SalmonellaDoctor wrote:Lol, its like you can never read me correctly, like, ever.

DP
This? Yeah, it soudned bad to me too

I liked that post. It's the thing that has me holding back on them.

And

*sleep*

ISO · Post Post #716 (ISO) » Mon Sep 09, 2013 5:15 pm

In post 668, Trolling Fairy wrote:
In post 634, Cephrir wrote:I want to agree with this, but it would be slightly hypocritical.
Hypocrisy is a shit scumtell anyways. You agree that I should have stopped that wagon?

Given your alleged opinion, yes.

Assuming I'm not confusing said opinion with someone else's.

Cait Sith · Post Post #717 (ISO) » Mon Sep 09, 2013 5:16 pm

Okay see the thing I liked about it is that I've only ever made a statement like that as town. I don't think to as scum. Posts like that are one of my mafia weaknesses though, I'll readily admit that, but it gives me pause.

ISO · Post Post #718 (ISO) » Mon Sep 09, 2013 5:26 pm

TF wrote:He is pretty distressed about his towngame, has a good scumgame. I liked his metashift comments earlier and his "I'm gonna try something new this game", but I don't like that we haven't seen anything from it. That's probably due to the crackheaded pace this game has, but I'll revisit it in the morning.

I was going to try acting all confident and aggressive. Maybe I should have tried harder but being honest is too strong a compulsion.

I'll have to cut my teeth (or something like that) on a worse playerlist at some point.

Though it might not be a shift for the better in terms of my win rate to do that- I'd cause more mislynches but not get lynched as much myself. Guess I have to learn to catch scum first. Though if I haven't managed that in all the mafia I've played... *shrug*

ISO · Post Post #719 (ISO) » Mon Sep 09, 2013 5:26 pm

In post 717, Cait Sith wrote:Okay see the thing I liked about it is that I've only ever made a statement like that as town. I don't think to as scum. Posts like that are one of my mafia weaknesses though, I'll readily admit that, but it gives me pause.

I feel like you're getting too hung up on this sort of thing.

Bert · Post Post #720 (ISO) » Mon Sep 09, 2013 5:27 pm

It's okay, Im not a scum catcher either Cephrir

Mala/Tammy (whoever you are) hope tomorrow is better than today!

I have an early morning class...fun stuff

Sound of Silence · Post Post #721 (ISO) » Mon Sep 09, 2013 5:32 pm

Also whenever I played with DP-Town, he felt more aggressive than defensive. He had a strong conviction and he push them hard.
This game, no. I'm not seeing it.

Cait Sith · Post Post #722 (ISO) » Mon Sep 09, 2013 5:33 pm

In post 719, Cephrir wrote:
In post 717, Cait Sith wrote:Okay see the thing I liked about it is that I've only ever made a statement like that as town. I don't think to as scum. Posts like that are one of my mafia weaknesses though, I'll readily admit that, but it gives me pause.
I feel like you're getting too hung up on this sort of thing.

I feel like that's the story of my mafia life, unfortunately.

-------------

Thanks Bert! It's all been Tammy, but mala has the flu so she needs to have a better day too!

Okay I'm really going to sleep now.

Sound of Silence · Post Post #723 (ISO) » Mon Sep 09, 2013 5:36 pm

Anyway so if this is tippy's towngame...
SD/TF scumteam!
Game solved.

Bert · Post Post #724 (ISO) » Mon Sep 09, 2013 5:44 pm

In post 721, Sound of Silence wrote:Also whenever I played with DP-Town, he felt more aggressive than defensive. He had a strong conviction and he push them hard.
This game, no. I'm not seeing it.

You're right. If you're GIF, you were in mini 1481 and this is nothing like what I rememebrr

Yeah he's playing more passive like his scum game I was in, as opposed to his recklessly aggressive, wagon-happy town style