Newbie 1419 - GAME OVER

[Titus]

Meh. Same difference. It took your slot to clear me.

[Brian Skies]

And it's funny that you suspect me for being "too sure", Brian. It's one of the main reasons I'm so uneasy with ns. He's writing me off as town with no real process in doing so; yesterday, he was paranoid of me because I'm tricky. Today, he's absolutely sure that I'm town because of the N1 nightkill? That doesn't make sense, considering the N1 nightkill happened before he got paranoid, but instead he pretends like that never happened. It makes more sense for scum NS to go after me tomorrow as opposed to today; if I can get mislynched without my blood on his hands, he has a chance of making it through tomorrow against Shii. If he tries to mislynch me today and we get involved in a 1v1, he won't escape. Shii won't trap him in the same way.

Actually, I read your wall post this morning but I didn't get a chance to reply until now. I'm pretty confident that you are town. Tunneling isn't really indicative of alignment (as townies are just as likely if not more likely to do it). I was just waiting for you responses and I started WIFOM'ing myself.

I liked your responses. And even if, for whatever reason, you are scum, there is no way I'm going to lynch you today because you aren't the best lynch for me.

[Brian Skies]

Meh. Same difference. It took your slot to clear me.

Verbs cleared you when he claimed tracker. Regardless of his alignment, you were cleared Day 2 (either he's tracker which makes his statement true, or he's scum). There was no doubt in you being clear.

[Brian Skies]

I feel like I'm getting baited into making a serious mistake.

VOTE: notscience

[Titus]

For once, I actually upon review would prefer NS. Since we both feel that Shii is town, can we lynch Nacho today and then do NS tomorrow?

[notscience]

For once, I actually upon review would prefer NS. Since we both feel that Shii is town, can we lynch Nacho today and then do NS tomorrow?

This is a terrible mentality.

[Brian Skies]

For once, I actually upon review would prefer NS. Since we both feel that Shii is town, can we lynch Nacho today and then do NS tomorrow?

Why do you prefer NS? I don't think NS would stand a chance against either Shii or Nacho. Have you seen my walls?

[Nachomamma8]

For once, I actually upon review would prefer NS. Since we both feel that Shii is town, can we lynch Nacho today and then do NS tomorrow?

Why does the order matter?

[notscience]

Why does standing a chance matter if you've already made up your mind?

[Brian Skies]

Because I get the feeling Nacho might be town. And if I'm right, and notscience is town, then I have a feeling I'll get screwed by scum-Shii (which I doubt).

Either way, based on what I've seen, I still think notscience is the best lynch. At this point, I'd rather pull what I feel is the best lynch because I don't know which one is the right lynch.

[Brian Skies]

Either way, there are still three other townies, my vote can be bypassed.

[Titus]

For once, I actually upon review would prefer NS. Since we both feel that Shii is town, can we lynch Nacho today and then do NS tomorrow?

Why do you prefer NS? I don't think NS would stand a chance against either Shii or Nacho. Have you seen my walls?

I have seen your walls. NS's opening was very strong and town like. He did somethings that made me think he was scummy earlier but that's almost a requirement of town NS.

Nacho on the other hand has practically told us that we should take the slot's living as suspicious. Nacho's interactions with Bert look off and Nacho's generally been the fuel behind most of the mislynches.

Nacho, on a side note, what is your read on Shii?

[Brian Skies]

UNVOTE: notscience

As I read up.

[Brian Skies]

UNVOTE: notscience

Because I fail at life.

[Brian Skies]

Actually, instead of reading, how confident are you that Nacho is scum? What do you propose us do if Nacho flips town? Do you think Shii is worthy of a townblock at this point?

[Nachomamma8]

Why does standing a chance matter if you've already made up your mind?

No one's made up their mind, but my mind is on the fast track towards being made when all you can defend yourself with is this.

Nacho on the other hand has practically told us that we should take the slot's living as suspicious. Nacho's interactions with Bert look off and Nacho's generally been the fuel behind most of the mislynches.

Lynches*
I was also pretty much the fuel behind the phok lynch. Yes, I am the optimal kill (unless there are outted power roles), so I probably should have been shot night 1. The fact I was not means that scum was likely afraid of protection.

[Brian Skies]

Nacho, do you have any reasonable doubt of Shii being town?

[Titus]

Actually, instead of reading, how confident are you that Nacho is scum? What do you propose us do if Nacho flips town? Do you think Shii is worthy of a townblock at this point?

Quite possibly Shii is worthy of that. Notice how Nacho keeps missing the question about the read on Shii?

[Brian Skies]

@ Nacho : I want your answer, not what you think I want to hear.

[Nachomamma8]

At this point? Not really, no.

[Nachomamma8]

Of course there's always a lot of doubt in players that I'm not that familiar with, but I had a strong townread on him early on and I have a good townread on him now. I looked through his posts a while ago, and I didn't really find anything I could feasibly attack.

[Brian Skies]

VOTE: notscience

[Titus]

Of course there's always a lot of doubt in players that I'm not that familiar with, but I had a strong townread on him early on and I have a good townread on him now. I looked through his posts a while ago, and I didn't really find anything I could feasibly attack.

Why are you looking for things to attack?

[Nachomamma8]

Because that's how I reassess townreads.

[Brian Skies]

@Nacho: How do you feel about Day 3 Shii? Emphasis on 695, 696, end of 729.