Mini 1486: Fruit Basket Mafia (Game Over)

[RadiantCowbells]

Because of complaints made to the moderator, I will hereby refrain from making attempts at being funny.

[zMuffinMan]

well kid A and slandaar are likely town for their reactions to the (actual lack of) night kill, even if i weren't already reading both of them as town. (lol at kid A's five cookes = v cookies = bvd scum)

and i'm inclined to agree that godfather is very unlikely if peabody is a 1-shot cop.

and i still think desperado could be scum.

Vote: Desperado

[Peabody]

well kid A and slandaar are likely town for their reactions to the (actual lack of) night kill, even if i weren't already reading both of them as town. (lol at kid A's five cookes = v cookies = bvd scum)

Why can't a scum be confused whether or not their kill went through?

[zMuffinMan]

it's not so much about being confused on whether a kill went through, but what they said about it.

i thought kid A's reaction looked like town thinking he's figured out what the amazing last will meant.

[Peabody]

Whether he thought I was dead or not, I don't see how that clears him as town. Again, scum could have thought their kill went through.

[zMuffinMan]

i don't think it clears him as town, i just think it points towards him being town more than it does scum.

[Slandaar]

You can't be serious.

About which part in particular?

[don_johnson]

i'm so confused.

[Kid A]

i think it was another nk

Why assume no kill when we had a claimed cop live through the night?

i meant nk as in nobody was killed rather than mafia not submitting a kill

[Kid A]

btw uberkang using his report on bvd makes even less sense than it did before if hes a one shot cop lol

[Desperado]

You can't be serious.

About which part in particular?

About the part where you thought the kill was legit and it somehow meant BvD was scum.

@muffin: I disagree completely. Kid A was obviously joking and slandaar was obviously taking it seriously and his confusion does not read like town trying to figure something out.

Why did you decide to stay in the game?

Vote: Kid A

^Dude is still trying to scumpaint Peabody and needs to die.

Mod: V/LA from 9/20-9/23

[Kid A]

VOTE: peabody

[zMuffinMan]

btw uberkang using his report on bvd makes even less sense than it did before if hes a one shot cop lol

why? what was the optimal play for using his report?

Why did you decide to stay in the game?

i told the mod when i requested replacement that if he didn't have replacement offers by the end of the night i'd stay in the game because it wasn't fair on him or the playerlist. *shrug*

[Desperado]

I'm glad you didn't, fwiw.

[Slandaar]

About the part where you thought the kill was legit and it somehow meant BvD was scum.

Kay.

To clarify, nobody died.

Ha. I thought I was dead too.

Strange.

Is Peabody scum Desp? apparently not based on your case on Kid.

[Desperado]

If you guys had been paying attention to the flips you would understand that Peabody's Imaginary Friend (not a real player!) flipping in

white

, just as the Jester had D2, was a joke and meant that no one had died. Or you could have seen that we had 12 players yesterday, lynched someone, and now have 11 players.

[Viera Assassin]

I don't know whether to say RC is annoying or funny.
Prolly both. Annie is still cute.

Weird how mod announced Pb's one-shot cop.
Pb, what other mechanics are there to your role?

[Slandaar]

If you guys had been paying attention to the flips you would understand that Peabody's Imaginary Friend (not a real player!) flipping in

white

, just as the Jester had D2, was a joke and meant that no one had died. Or you could have seen that we had 12 players yesterday, lynched someone, and now have 11 players.

Uh I don't see how I would know that considering there hasn't been an actual night kill to compare it to. Then considering Peabody is an actual player coloured in green and the flip was some kind of investigative role which is what he claimed.

But that is somewhat irrelevant, what isn't it you explaining why I would understand what is going on as scum but not town.

[Peabody]

There are no other mechanics to my role.

I'm just a one shot cop. Also, the reason the mod made that cookie joke is that because I knew I didn't have another shot, I told him I'd like to use my investigation on the cookie jar to see if there are any cookies inside. That's all. You're not missing anything else.

[Peabody]

I'm actually really proud my gambit worked.

[Slandaar]

You shouldn't have posted the thing about knowing tomorrow why no gf as that gave it away but it worked.

[StubbsKVM]

I'm going to catch up tomorrow. I've missed quite a lot.

[mnemonicdevice]

So either scum isn't killing anyone, or someone else has a power role to protect people. Which I would have regarded as unbalanced because with both a cop and a doctor follow the cop could have been used. However now that we know that Peabody is a one-shot cop, and thus town would still be balanced if it had a doctor.
Is anyone a doctor?

[Peabody]

So either scum isn't killing anyone, or someone else has a power role to protect people. Which I would have regarded as unbalanced because with both a cop and a doctor follow the cop could have been used. However now that we know that Peabody is a one-shot cop, and thus town would still be balanced if it had a doctor.
Is anyone a doctor?

Doctor. Please don't claim.

Rolefishing is bad. Tsk. Tsk.

[Peabody]

I'm going to look over the thread more tomorrow. Tonight I'm busy.

Kid A's vote on me looks town.