A uPick of Ice & Fire - Day 12 - #REKT?

[Garruk Relentless]

@Garruk - so...basically one head has him as strong town and the other as some degree of scum?

It's more like one head is reading him as strong town and the other I have no idea what thinks, but it's definitely not strong town. SSK and I have been running on very different wavelengths this game.

Also, in case you missed it, I've been over the Benmage thing for some time - but unlike some players I don't think the way to deal with disagreement is to refuse to interact. Besides, since I'm sure I'm right I can slowly grind him into dust and sneer at him later. I don't think you actually are reading the exchange, and your take on it feels incredibly superficial and lacking any actual reasoning behind it - feels faked...why is that?

I applaud taking the accusations and not ignoring them(a trait that is rarely found today), my implication was more that there is a point of diminishing returns and both of you have continued on with your discussion regardless. I don't deny that I am not reading the exchange at this point--it's plainly obvious that you two haven't really gotten anywhere and the amount of effort both have put into the argument is a clear indicator of town-town interactions in my book.

[macmollie]

oh thooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooor

thorthorhtorthorthorthorthorthorthor
thorthorhtorthorthorthorthorthorthor
thorthorhtorthorthorthorthorthorthor
thorthorhtorthorthorthorthorthorthor
thorthorhtorthorthorthorthorthorthor
thorthorhtorthorthorthorthorthorthor
thorthorhtorthorthorthorthorthorthor
thorthorhtorthorthorthorthorthorthor
thorthorhtorthorthorthorthorthorthor
thorthorhtorthorthorthorthorthorthor
thorthorhtorthorthorthorthorthorthor
thorthorhtorthorthorthorthorthorthor
thorthorhtorthorthorthorthorthorthor
thorthorhtorthorthorthorthorthorthor
thorthorhtorthorthorthorthorthorthor
thorthorhtorthorthorthorthorthorthor
thorthorhtorthorthorthorthorthorthor
thorthorhtorthorthorthorthorthorthor
thorthorhtorthorthorthorthorthorthor
thorthorhtorthorthorthorthorthorthor
thorthorhtorthorthorthorthorthorthor
thorthorhtorthorthorthorthorthorthor
thorthorhtorthorthorthorthorthorthor

[macmollie]

VOTE: thor[/thor]

[quadz08]

@Quadz
- My top scum read jumped on to my wagon because 'oobas flaking' and im trying to figure out if that's it and why he isn't pushing other stronger scum reads? But sure - call it filler
- i never defended Amrun and Zednek. At least read my posts before posting "cases" on me

@Quadz
- My top scum read jumped on to my wagon because 'oobas flaking' and im trying to figure out if that's it and why he isn't pushing other stronger scum reads? But sure - call it filler
- i never defended Amrun and Zednek. At least read my posts before posting "cases" on me

Point 1 is fair.
Point 2 - I misremembered and said Zdenek instead of SD. But this sure looks like defending to me:

Vibe + Your major pushes in the game have been on Amrun and SafetyDance - both of whom I'm leaning town on and looked like very easy pushes at that time.

Also, Thor should answer M&M's question.

[quadz08]

To clarify "point 1 is fair:" His explanation of

why

he was asking the questions that I thought were filler makes sense, and proves the point that they were not, in fact, filler.

[Thor665]

I'm neutral on the wagon.
I'd compromise for him - but I think there are better lynches available.
I've said this already.

[Thor665]

Also, Thor should answer M&M's question.

And as I just told her - I'd already, and without prompting, offered my views on the wagon *today* (or late last night, I'm working splits so I'll admit my internal clock is off) But...seriously, what the hell people?
Read.
Moar.

[macmollie]

I am not asking you about the wagon I am asking you about the player

stop conflating the 2

[Thor665]

Stop separating them.

[Thor665]

I mean, if I thought he was town I'd call the wagon bad.
If I thought he was scummy I'd be pleased by the wagon and would be voting it already.
If I thought a specific poster or two or three had bad votes I'd call them out specifically.

[displaced]

halfway through the read right now will have something together by tomorrow

[macmollie]

@ thor

if you are unsure about him then just say you are unsure

it would be refreshing to witness a humble thor say he did not know everything instead of feeding this fencesitting jargon that you would never accept from another player if you were town

wat. is. your. read. on. ooba.

[Benmage]

@Thor

who are your current top 3 scum reads/top 3 town reads... maybe a bullet why to please.

[Thor665]

@ thor

if you are unsure about him then just say you are unsure

...I called him neutral.
Then i called him neutral again.
Then i clarified that he was neutral.
Now you are chiding me for not stating that my read on him wasn't a town or scum vibe...whut?

it would be refreshing to witness a humble thor say he did not know everything instead of feeding this fencesitting jargon that you would never accept from another player if you were town

Whut?

wat. is. your. read. on. ooba.

N.E.U.T.R.A.L.
Which part of the word do you fail to grok?

[Thor665]

Null.
Midland.
Indifferent.
So-so.
Middle of the road.

[Thor665]

Lacking a strong read upon.
Willing to compromise on.
In stronger favor of others I have named.
Prefer to lynch other targets.
Not opposing his lynch because I do not see him as town.
Not supporting it because I do not see him as scum.

[Thor665]

Neutral?

[Thor665]

I'm neutral on the wagon.
I'd compromise for him - but I think there are better lynches available.
I've said this already.

[Thor665]

I may be down with the ooba lulz wagon, but I'll admit the copping to the misrep actually feels townish. Ooba is certainly skilled enough that might be a feint to the growing pressure...but my gut kind of says town on that one too, so I think we can do better.

[Thor665]

I'm neutral on the Ooba push.

[Thor665]

What the SMURF is my read on Ooba!?!?!

[Thor665]

@Thor

who are your current top 3 scum reads/top 3 town reads... maybe a bullet why to please.

@Garruk - If Amrun is your only scum read...why no vote on her? I'm here and alone.

I'm neutral on the Ooba push.
I'd support a Ceph push if people want to go back to that, the Amrun push is getting no love.
The Shadoweh push is bad.

Hey, look, top two - Ceph and Amrun.
I also call Shadoweh town here and I've called Elle town - so let's call them my top two.
I also called Alfred town.

[Thor665]

And the quoted post was made in the ancient days of *this morning*
When Thor wasn't addressing his reads.
Good catch, Benny.

[macmollie]

whoa 9 post meltdown

thor you did not say he was neutral before I asked you so stop trying to act like you did

VOTE: thor

[Syryana]

whoa 9 post meltdown

thor you did not say he was neutral before I asked you so stop trying to act like you did

VOTE: thor

Actually, he did.