Mini 1501: We're On A Boat! (END?! results inside)

[Kazekirimaru]

fferyllt is town. I feel good about that one.

I'm pretty sold on Brian Skies's claim at this point.

CDB looks alright.

Aero needs rope.

The rest of you idk.

[Kazekirimaru]

Those of you still on Brian's wagon, why? Is it because you don't believe the claim, or some other reason?

[Kazekirimaru]

Nevermind CDB is nullish until I can ascertain why they're still on the aforementioned wagon.

[notscience]

interesting that you felt compelled to put a read in early,

Here is scum #2

Kaze I think CDB is town, why is he null for you?

[Kazekirimaru]

I liked CDB during the miller claim stuff but I'm withholding townread until I get some insights of afterwords, like why they still have their vote on Brian(if it's just chilling there because CDB hasn't checked in or something, then all the better.) I guess null leaning town would be the best way to put it.

[notscience]

Why are you not townreading me yet

[Kazekirimaru]

Because you make me uncomfortable.

Not sure what to make of it.

[notscience]

Seeing as I'm being obvtown as fuck, I make that out to be no bueno.

[Kazekirimaru]

You calling yourself obvtown isn't exactly comforting.

[Kazekirimaru]

The only reason I'd call you town thusfar would be for pegging Aero with a vote.

And even given that I'm not ruling you out just yet.

[CrashTextDummie]

Spyrex, I am disappointed. Was really hoping you'd be town this game.

Those of you still on Brian's wagon, why? Is it because you don't believe the claim, or some other reason?

Yeah, I don't believe the claim. By my count, we're up to three people now calling Brian town, when literally all he's done is claim a role that's well known for being a simple and effective fakeclaim. Oh wait, he did make one post that didn't serve the sole purpose of trying to make his claim stick:

@aeronaut: The difference is that notscience made the vote after clearly participating in the discussion. You made your vote upon your entrance.

A snipe at Aeronaut without taking any stance on his own. I see 100% self-preservatory actions and 0% scumhunting, which is classic scum behavior in a situation like this (again, check TV U-Pick mafia for reference). I maintain that he fumbled his claim with regards to the wiki and I'm quite frankly shocked at the amount of people town-reading him.

[CrashTextDummie]

Fferyllt and notscience are decent early town reads, and I'm leaning that way on Kazekirimaru as well.

Aeronaut is not exactly a town read, but not for the reasons he is being voted for. I don't think he has committed any scummy actions, but I do have some tonal issues. Regardless I dislike the wagon, particularly because of Smudger's opportunistic vote. If you guys insist on putting off dealing with Brian, I'd be happy to lynch him as well.

[Garmr]

Well I only Rvs'ed Brian and Miller claims make me shiver because i don't know what to do with them. Also another one of my games on it's first day is 21 pages with 5 or 4 more days to go and is finally slowing down. So my first serious read is this

UNVOTE: Brian skies

VOTE: Notscience

His plays appear all wrong to me. Post 30 and 33 seem to be pushing for the fact that Brian looks townish then she votes him in post 35 she also has no reason no problems with that. No one talks about his change of heart ask questions as hmm seems to answer everything. Aeronaught seems like a easy target for him to latch onto as well I have him as a null read. Also Claims Smudger is scum 2 with just one sentence asking why he has early reads. This to me isn't really the best scum sign I personally was having a hard time reading this game as well. Also post 105 and 107 make me uneasy seems to be pushing to look town. He makes me feel really uneasy.

[Garmr]

When i meant him as a null read i meant aeronaught, Notscience is scummy.

[Smudger]

interesting that you felt compelled to put a read in early,

Here is scum #2

Kaze I think CDB is town, why is he null for you?

Seeing as I'm being obvtown as fuck, I make that out to be no bueno.

As for the comment regarding my "opportunistic vote" I disagree with that for the simple reason it is not opportunistic, I am currently uncomfortable with Aeros play so far and I suggest you retread the post with my vote as I say
More than Baaaaaaahhj..

You will also note that I am now beginning to feel the same way concerning notscience and it would appear I am not the only one.

I also don't get how people are "getting town vibes" from people this early in the game. Is it that they make a lot of noise with good post content? I feel it's too early to say one way or the other. Just because someone is active and presents good arguments at this stage of the game does not make them town.

Fixed.

[Smudger]

Sorry screwed up the quotes above, am on phone, but that is no excuse.

The first quote of #107 And the second quote of #103 should not be there.

@Mod any chance you could correct that please?

Yes~

[SpyreX]

So, I want more ffery. I'm intrigued and I like the cut of that jib a lot.

Ultimately, the page 1 dance is going to come down to the great game of which is more likely:

- A wagon formed on scum off the bat and the scum went panic mode and claimed

miller

as the get out of jail free pass.
- A wagon formed on a miller, claimed miller, and the jumps on tried to push that through.

Miller claims are bad. Yes. They normally have to be dealt with before end game. However, a great way to deal with them is to to just win before it gets to that point and a scum flip HERE forces that hand because you're gonna have a haaaaard time selling me on that being a bus

[Kazekirimaru]

So, Spyre, how do you propose we approach the situation?

[SpyreX]

Like I said before. We have a talk, squeeze out whatever we can, then wash our faces in Aeronaut's blood

[Aeronaut]

Like I said before. We have a talk, squeeze out whatever we can, then wash our faces in Aeronaut's blood

Nah.


A lot of you seem to be just putting me in your scumbucket, but without any real reason besides conformity, it seems.

[Aeronaut]

I actually need to replace out

. Have a few real life things going on so I need to cut down my games by a lot. Very sorry, not a fan of replacing myself. Wish it wasn't necessary.

[Maestro]

waaaaat

[fferyllt]

Fferyllt and notscience are decent early town reads, and I'm leaning that way on Kazekirimaru as well.

Aeronaut is not exactly a town read, but not for the reasons he is being voted for. I don't think he has committed any scummy actions, but I do have some tonal issues. Regardless I dislike the wagon, particularly because of Smudger's opportunistic vote. If you guys insist on putting off dealing with Brian, I'd be happy to lynch him as well.

The Aeronaut wagon is actually all about his tone.

[fferyllt]

Like I said before. We have a talk, squeeze out whatever we can, then wash our faces in Aeronaut's blood

Nah.


A lot of you seem to be just putting me in your scumbucket, but without any real reason besides conformity, it seems.

Your naked vote wasn't such a big deal but it was worth poking at. The game was making a fast transition out of RVS mode (thank fuck for that) and your vote drew attention. Your reaction to being poked about it

was

a big deal. It was blood in the water.

Conformity has little to do with people scumreading you.

[notscience]

lol'd at someone scumreading me without so much as a push on me. Garmr, you care to or are you going to votepark on me?