Newbie 1433 - Game Over

[Mr_Ree]

Town.

[Mr_Ree]

What do YOU think of his recent posts and why do you think that?

[Nominull]

hit me with a "why do you think that" first, you've been pretty coy with the reasoning for your townreads all game

[Peabody]

Hey Peabody. Welcome to the game

While you catch up, please list your reads along with the page number you have read up to. If you do that every 10ish pages, we should be able to follow your reads and compare them to what was happening at that time.

Cheers,
Ree

You really think its helpful for me to list my reads as I read?

I personally didn't see a use for them to be listed until I'm done.

I'm on page six and have a scum read on Satan.

[Peabody]

Also on Null. Kinda.

[Skelda]

@ Skelda - right bc everyone who hammer is automatically scummy. Even if they are genuine and are acting in the best interest of the town. if that was the case the person who always hammer would get lynched the next day. Supposing you are right and I am scum.....how do you know I wont make a plausible reason for the lynch and get away with it. In other words it is it is not really a gamble to lynch you if i was scum. You rationale does not make sense.

Also how do you know I wont hammer you after all. Your assumption is that I am scum and wont hammering you bc it will make me look scummy. Its possible that I will lynch you anyways . But according to you I am scummy if I lynch you but scummy if I dont lynch you. So no matter what I do i am scummy. Sorry but your theory is not good and is full of holes and contradictions.

My god, you are frustrating me. My main reason for suspecting you isn't whether or not you hammer me. It is how you are going back and forth depending on who looks like they are going to be lynched. You jumped on 2Pac yesterday, jumped on me today, and when they go to lynch Nom, you'll probably jump on him too.

[Mr_Ree]

Hey Peabody. Welcome to the game

While you catch up, please list your reads along with the page number you have read up to. If you do that every 10ish pages, we should be able to follow your reads and compare them to what was happening at that time.

Cheers,
Ree

You really think its helpful for me to list my reads as I read?

I personally didn't see a use for them to be listed until I'm done.

I'm on page six and have a scum read on Satan.

Yes I do. Like I said, we can compare your reads to what was happening at the time.

Your predecessor is still highly suspect. I'd like as much information as possible from your slot.

[Peabody]

Will do, but give me some time to catch up.

[Mr_Ree]

hit me with a "why do you think that" first, you've been pretty coy with the reasoning for your townreads all game

I hate to pull the I asked you first card but I don't want your reasoning affected by my answers. Plus, there is still the fact that you owe me an answer for why I should think you are town.

I think I've made my reasoning behind many of my reads quite clear. You, Satan, skelda, Reg, 2pac... I've listed my thoughts on all of you.

Pedit take your time. All I ask is for those three read lists at 10 page intervals.

Just try to be caught up before deadline so you can make an informed decision.

[Mr_Ree]

Did Ranawey run away?

[SatanHellYeah]

Nice pun.

[SafetyDance]

Votecount 2.4

Skelda (3): SatanHellYeah, Ranawey, Mr_Ree ^(L-1)

Ranawey (1):

Nominull

Peabody (1):

TheFuzzylogic99

TheFuzzylogic99 (1):

Skelda

Not voting

: Peabody

Countdown to deadline: (expired on 2013-10-12 12:00:00). With 7 players, it's 4 to lynch.

Searching for a replacement for Ranawey

[TheFuzzylogic99]

Skelda...you know that the reason I jumped on the 2Pac wagon was that if I didnt vote for him we would end day 1 with a no lynch. You act likeit was still mid day and that I just jumped on his wagon bc it was the easiest lynch at the time. None which is true. Secondly its not like I had not suspected you as scum but jumped on you anyways. Like I said you are grasping at straws .

I look forward to reading Peabody reads.....also at this point I think that Ran is going to be replaced.

@ Ree what do you think about my town read on Nom.

[Nominull]

hit me with a "why do you think that" first, you've been pretty coy with the reasoning for your townreads all game

I hate to pull the I asked you first card but I don't want your reasoning affected by my answers.

I feel as though I asked you first. I asked what you thought about Fuzzy's recent posts, and "Town" is not really a sufficient answer.

You claim you're bad at scum because you can't fake reads, but if all your reads are one word it's hard to see how this can be true.

[Mr_Ree]

What I think is you and skelda are voting him for hammering the Lynch you both were pushing for. That makes it look like you are trying to shirk your own blame for being the ones to push the vote in the first place which again, looks bad on you two.

Why do you think his recent posting looks scummy?

[Mr_Ree]

And why should I be reading you as town? What have you done this game that should read as obv town?

[Nominull]

What I think is you and skelda are voting him for hammering the Lynch you both were pushing for. That makes it look like you are trying to shirk your own blame for being the ones to push the vote in the first place which again, looks bad on you two.

Why do you think his recent posting looks scummy?

I didn't ask about me, or even Skelda. Why are you deflecting away from talking about Fuzzy so hard?

Note that I am not, in fact, voting for him. There was a very recent votecount that should have made that clear to you. This is the quality of play you think is worth bragging about?

[Mr_Ree]

I'm sorry, were you not saying you found him scummy? That's what I based that on. If you in fact find him town, why don't you go ahead and explain why so we can bring Skelda into the light. You seem to be avoiding that question altogether, just like the question of why I should read you as obv town.

Yet another discredit, surprise surprise...

Are you planning on answering anything?

[Mr_Ree]

Skelda...you know that the reason I jumped on the 2Pac wagon was that if I didnt vote for him we would end day 1 with a no lynch. You act likeit was still mid day and that I just jumped on his wagon bc it was the easiest lynch at the time. None which is true. Secondly its not like I had not suspected you as scum but jumped on you anyways. Like I said you are grasping at straws .

I look forward to reading Peabody reads.....also at this point I think that Ran is going to be replaced.

@ Ree what do you think about my town read on Nom.

Go ahead, tell me why this is or isn't town

[Peabody]

This is a post detailing my thoughts on Day 1, pages 1-10 as requested.

I noted prior to reading the thread that Sthar8, 2Pac, and I are town, so you will not see me questioning any of their alignments.

Nominull:

Nominull's refusal to post content until 2Pac stops his act is silly. It's also scummy for the reason my predecessor pointed out. Additionally, 2Pac did have a good point on Nomi's vote on a lurker. It seems as if Nomi doesn't even want to find scum.

Fuzzy:

I don't like Fuzzy's taking credit for toning down 2pac. It just rubs me the wrong way.

My first thought on his accusation that Mr.Ree is a bad player is that it looks like a town move, but now I see it as more scummy. This is the definition of an OMGUS. It's kind of ironic because he accuses Mr.Ree of the same thing here.

Fuzzy's =22365#p5318780]push on Sthar8 looks fabricated. =22365#p5320249]He didn't see the fakehammer as a reaction test? Not even a little?

Oh wait, nevermind. He saw the error of his ways.

Mr.Ree:

His reaction test looks like a reaction test. I don't think it should be seen as anything else. And I certainly do love what results:

SatanHellYeah:

The following posts look like Satan unintentionally slipped his alignment. All bolded words are bolded by me for emphasis:

Nah, that can't be serious.

This is in reaction to Mr.Ree's test. It looks like Satan is trying to convince himself that Mr.Ree

couldn't have found him already

.
------------------

Yes , it is.....

Its does not nessarilly means he is scummy but it might . Sometimes townies pulls the OMGUS card especially new townies.. Cant figure out yet if Satan is scum or just a nervous newbie. At this point it could go either way.

I would feel offended but

I messed up there.

No complains.

This doesn't look right.
------------------

There's not a single way I could defend the "I'm not scum" possition. Therefore,

there is no point in denying it.

But, well, I am not scum indeed dammit. And you know it. Are you just searching for an excuse or something?

I just don't like this.
-------------------

Sorry. I thought I made it clear. I strongly think Skelda is scum.

Then why aren't you voting for him?

Because I didn't want to make any accusations while being in the spotlight.

But, well, I don't care. VOTE: Skelda

tl;dr: 10 pages in and my strongest scum read is on SatanHellYeah. If Satan is scum, there's a strong chance Nominull is scum. Those are my strongest reads so far.

[Peabody]

Though I have scum reads on both Satan and Nomi individually, the way they are interacting suggests I could be 100% right on my scum team guess.

This is suggested by Satan's straight null read on Nomi, and then this:

@Nominull
I'm afraid that you will get lynched at this rate. You need to contribute. If not, you're probably dying today.

However, this is only in case Satan is scum. I just figured I'd point this out now while I can.

Also, 10 pages in, if Satan is scum, Skelda is probably town.

[Nominull]

I'm sorry, were you not saying you found him scummy? That's what I based that on. If you in fact find him town, why don't you go ahead and explain why so we can bring Skelda into the light. You seem to be avoiding that question altogether, just like the question of why I should read you as obv town.

Why don't you just answer the question? Are you having a hard time faking a read you don't believe in?

[Mr_Ree]

And why should I be reading you as town? What have you done this game that should read as obv town?

My thoughts exactly... why are you avoiding this? I've only asked 7 times now.

I gave you an answer on fuzzy. He reads as town. I've asked several times what your read is yet you've said nothing.

[Nominull]

VOTE: Mr_Ree

[TheFuzzylogic99]

Sorry i know that you prob feel overwhelm bc you have 30+ pages to catch on and you going to be bombarded with questions

so this are your reads up to page 10

Def Town

-2Pac
- Sthar
- Regs/ You

Fuzzy( Town ?)
Skelda ( likely Town
Ree ( likely Town)

Scum Satan/Nom

just trying to get a handle on your reads