Newbie 1419 - GAME OVER

[Titus]

As we should. I missed the thread opening. I hope the host messaging you didn't count as a prod.

[Brian Skies]

I didn't get a prod. Even so, Shii has way more than I do. And the game will probably end today. So there's no point in getting a replacement.

@notscience: You still have to explain most of my wall against you. You've been pretty safe in terms of giving us your reads this game. You've asked me for my reads, but never asked for Gaiden's. The activity regarding you and Gaiden when Verbs voted Gaiden looks like buddying. You haven't done much in the way of scumhunting.

@Shii: You need to explain why you were so adamant in going after Nacho instead of notscience. You had a better case against ns but still veered me and Titus towards Nacho.

There may be other issues, but those are the ones off the top of my head. I'll revisit this thread later.

[Titus]

BS, can you come up with a reason why either scum would no kill? It seems much more likely we could be dealing with inactive Shii scum who just never submitted it.

[Brian Skies]

What makes you think it was a no kill? It is very likely that one of us was targeted.

[notscience]

Why are you so sure Nacho is town? What happened to that Nacho paranoia of yours?

If this is what you mean, it's pretty simple.

If you say in-game "I will get paranoid of x if they're still alive on day y"

What do you think scum will do if they're town

like really lol

There's also /echo'd meta that nacho plays more robotic in his scum games then his town

ALSO BACK TO MY POINT OF SHII PUSHING NACHO OVER ME

If I leave you in the game and you are town, I'd find it extremely difficult to not lynch you in LYLO.

I'd find it extremely difficult to not lynch you in LYLO.

[Titus]

What makes you think it was a no kill? It is very likely that one of us was targeted.

Rational behavior suggests no kill. Shii and ns were not going to kill each other. That means either you or me would be the target. Both of them would know you cannot jail yourself. Therefore, I would b the jail target. Logically, the scums would have to kill you.

[Brian Skies]

What are you talking about? Do you know how the newbie matrix works? Verbs was the tracker, so there is no jailkeeper.

[Brian Skies]

I can only be a Doctor or a BP.

[Titus]

Late last night I didn't have the matrix in front of me. I remembered wrong. However, that makes a bit more sense now. You have clarified.

[notscience]

Brian, look at the kills, then tell me it isn't blatantly obvious which role you are.

[Titus]

Let me test something. Shii, what role do you think Brian is?

Brian, do not answer.

[Brian Skies]

@Notscience: Why are you saying that to me?

[Titus]

Sush Brian. Let the crazy woman operate.

[Titus]

Mod: Can we have a prod on Shii?

[Brian Skies]

@notscience: You still have to explain most of my wall against you. You've been pretty safe in terms of giving us your reads this game. You've asked me for my reads, but never asked for Gaiden's. The activity regarding you and Gaiden when Verbs voted Gaiden looks like buddying. You haven't done much in the way of scumhunting.

You still haven't answered these points.

@Mod: Please don't replace Shii if you can help it.

[notscience]

@notscience: You still have to explain most of my wall against you. You've been pretty safe in terms of giving us your reads this game. You've asked me for my reads, but never asked for Gaiden's. The activity regarding you and Gaiden when Verbs voted Gaiden looks like buddying. You haven't done much in the way of scumhunting.

1) That wall had points I just responded to

2) Playstyle tells much? I've stated stances on people.

3) I had a townlean on Gaiden. I had nothing on you. Therefore, I'm more interested in getting info on you so I can try to judge your alignment

4) I don't always do traditional scumhunting. Take a metadive on me.

Any others?

[Brian Skies]

So, a townlean means you don't need to hear their thoughts on the game? You just let them play safe and actively lurk? And it didn't seem your townlean on Gaiden was based on anything strong.

[Shiidaji]

aye amrun

tomorrow for this one

[Amrun]

VC 4.0

(1) notscience - Shiidaji
(1) Shiidaji - notscience

With 4 alive, it takes 3 to lynch.

Not Voting: Titus, Brian Skies

V/LA:

Deadline: Tuesday, October 18 12pm EDT

Spoiler: Vote History

Shiidaji

- notscience

Brian Skies

-

Titus

-

notscience

- Shiidaji

If you spot any mistakes, please let me know.

Obviously, Shiidaji does not need prodding because etc.

[notscience]

So, a townlean means you don't need to hear their thoughts on the game? You just let them play safe and actively lurk? And it didn't seem your townlean on Gaiden was based on anything strong.

Welcome to ns play

I focus more on reading those I havent sorted then those I have until theyre sorted.

Case you forgot, I helped lynch phok.

Go iso gaiden, shii, and phok. Tell me thats not distancing.

[Titus]

Let me test something. Shii, what role do you think Brian is?

Brian, do not answer.

Please answer this first Shii. Include your confidence level.

[Shiidaji]

Let me test something. Shii, what role do you think Brian is?

Brian, do not answer.

Please answer this first Shii. Include your confidence level.

BP, I'd bet a sweet amount of cash on it. Brian'd be smart enough to have protected Verbs if he was actually the doctor.

[Brian Skies]

Go iso gaiden, shii, and phok. Tell me thats not distancing.

You mean buddying? Distancing implies you.

[Titus]

Brian Skies, what role are you actually?

[Brian Skies]

I have a bullet in my chest and you can't tell? It was pretty obvious what I was after the Verbs death. This is why I didn't want to go there. Occam's razor is your friend, Titus. Not WIFOM.