Newbie 1436 ~ Game Over

[Bert]

wrong thread ugh

[fferyllt]

That's kind of a relief because I was at a loss!

I'm in the midst of a reread, but have to leave off for a couple hours.

[Bert]

Cool. If you want to ask me questions about anything today, it will make me get off the couch and skim particular things. <3

[Sakura Hana]

Cool. If you want to ask me questions about anything today, it will make me get off the couch and skim particular things. <3

What are your updated reads after both flips?

[Bert]

I don't have the power to do more than skim a page or two at any given time, so I haven't mustered up the effort to look back at all

I'll look back at ISO's now.

[Bert]

@Sakura:

Here’s a start: skimmed isos.

Cabd – don’t like, wouldn't mind seeing him die

Notscience – town but not confident, style is transferable to both alignments

Kaze – scum (gut) - you know how often it drives me in the wrong direction

Sakura – don’t know anymore, no confidence in this read, feel the same as I did about you in 1481 - remember when I just let other people read you and see

Ffery – super super town

Agi102 – newbtown (*probably*) but newb passes………YOU know how I feel about newb passes. It cannot be trusted, right? Will remain red herring for the rest of the game, most likely. Hooray paranoia, JOY!

To be honest, I’m probably gonna cause swing today and just sheep Ffery because she’s my only 100% town solid rock solid town read. Everyone else is rather *meh*

[Bert]

What are your updated reads after both flips?

What are yours? You're gonna not be happy, but part of me is tempted to vote you because Goodmorning called you scum. If I had lived to D3 in Masons and Monks, I likely would have been tempted to vote you after Wisdom's death because Wisdom tunneled you so much and called you scum, as did Mara. It is what it is, though.

[Sakura Hana]

Cabd - This guy is innocent until proven guilty.

ffery - Super Town

notscience - Gut Scum read, but my head tells me that he's town.

Bert - The opposite of notscience, Gut Town read, but my head tells me that he's scum.

agi - Don't know

Kaze - Don't know.

And I didn't need to skim ISOs for that.

[Cabd]

Huh. Sakura that's a total 180 of your usual approach to me?

[Cabd]

Oh wait nevermind I get it. Moving on...

[Bert]

Cabd - This guy is innocent until proven guilty.

ffery - Super Town

notscience - Gut Scum read, but my head tells me that he's town.

Bert - The opposite of notscience, Gut Town read, but my head tells me that he's scum.

agi - Don't know

Kaze - Don't know.

And I didn't need to skim ISOs for that.

1. So you have no gut read on Cabd or head read?? Just curious why you go "don't know" on Kaze/agi and then go "innocent until proven guilty" on Cabd. Is there a reason for this? I must have missed it, so do refresh my memory

2. What is off about notscience's play such that he is gut scum?

[fferyllt]

I Whiteknighted Cabd pretty hard yesterday and he and me are still living, that's... kind of troubling.

Why is it troubling?

[Sakura Hana]

I Whiteknighted Cabd pretty hard yesterday and he and me are still living, that's... kind of troubling.

Why is it troubling?

I was writing a response to this, but I think I rather keep scum guessing for at least 1 more game day.

[Sakura Hana]

What is off about notscience's play such that he is gut scum?

I can't explain my gut reads, basically like something feels like it's scum but i cant put my finger on it.
Analysis of his play so far is what has led me to

think

he's town, but i

feel

he's scum.
If that's a better way to put it.

[Bert]

I was writing a response to this, but I think I rather keep scum guessing for at least 1 more game day.

What's the motivation behind being evasive about evaluating Cabd??

If you're town, you have no idea whether you'll be alive tomorrow, so what's the point in "hiding what you're thinking" until "next game day?"

Also, you missed the first part of #860.

[Sakura Hana]

If I'm dead tomorrow I'll let you wonder as I think you guys can figure it out by yourselves, just like Cabd already did.

As I said, he's innocent until proven guilty, what do you think I'm reading him then? I think that's pretty much self-explanatory.

Basically I want the analysis to come from whatever scum decides to do, giving the analysis before tomorrow would make them easily WIFOM me with their night actions.

[Bert]

Your response is weird...if you have something to say and you're already ALMOST implying what you're saying, just make it clear because I don't get why ANYTHING could be affecting your read on Cabd after you say he's "innocent until proven guilty." ALL of us are innocent until proven guilty!!!!

Kaze - Don't know

Why is Kaze completely "IDK"? No impression either way is weird, considering how aggressive she is

I asked you what your GUT read is on Cabd, and what your HEAD is telling you, since you mentioned both a gut + head read on both notscience and myself.

[Bert]

EBWOP: Oh, and your GUT and HEAD reads were scum, then town, or vice versa, on both notscience and myself. That's what I'm asking about Cabd.

[Sakura Hana]

If I dont split them up, you can figure out that I get the same read from both.

[Bert]

There's no way we can prove he's guilty. Emphasis on "prove." What does your definition of "proven guilty" here mean. Until he's lynched and flips scum, he's innocent???

[Sakura Hana]

That's for me to know and for you to figure out.

[fferyllt]

Whatever your alignment, I think I buy the read.

[TheButtonmen]

2.03

With 7 alive it's 4 votes to lynch.

Voting for:

*Cabd -
*Fferyllt -
*Bert -
*Kazekirimaru - Bert [1]
*agi102 -
*Sakura Hana -
*notscience -

Not voting: agi102, Fferyllt, notscience, Kazekirimaru, Sakura Hana, Cabd [6]

Day 2 ends in (expired on 2013-10-21 00:03:00)

[Kazekirimaru]

@Sakura - Do agree or disagree with the following statement: "Transparency is pro-town."

@Bert - Why do you keep calling me a she? ._. Also, if you yourself have naught but a gut scum read on me, why are you pressing Sakura for having a null on me?

Why is Ffery super town to everyone?

[Cabd]

Holy shit if kaze and Bert fish any harder then the fish are gonna go extinct.