Guyett, what were you hoping to get out of that post about how you're bad at a specific alignment
Regals, what are you even talking about?
Villager, scum and town both don't necessarily count votes properly / bother to count at all. The stuff about needing to meta people to read them reads poorly to me. Mafia is not just a game of "research people and then try to make connections from all this previous behavior to judge this game as objectively as possible." It's a subjective game.
This whole using meta to distance yourself from the reasoning for finding someone scummy thing really is a peeve of mine.
Meta is a tool but it is not the main tool you should use. If you are using it as your main scumhunting method, you are using a crutch.
Her response to me reads very disingenuous. She then only chooses to look
at her wagon
for people to vote rather than looking at the entire game. A very self-oriented perspective that runs down the vein of attack the drivers of the cart to make it lose momentum. Her reasoning? Non-existent, only thing about guyett is how guyett is able to play well as scum basically. Woopdedoo. So am I. So is singer. So is everyone else in this game, probably.
The stuff about her alignment not being joined at the hip with arc is completely valueless.
Of course not
.
RMarie, your attempt to tell me that you aren't "joined at the hip" with arc is not only insulting to my understanding of the game but also irritating in the sense that I specifically stated that I could see your post as coaching and that, in the event you flip scum, I would be more inclined to vote arcangel due to connective reasoning and you somehow blew this up to me going "RMarie scum = arc scum, RMarie town = arc town" which is absolutely not what I was saying.
So yes. I do find the reply to be rather underwhelming, as she
still
has not actually given us anything to work with. Vague comments and offers of meta and a vote with no reasoning and a "but what if!" do not make for anything that is of much interest to me.
To answer the question on what happens in the event of a RMarie-town flip: I will reassess my reads during the night phase and come up with a new set of ideas and a case in the next game day.
