Newbie 1425 Part Deux -- Game Over

[ObsessedWithCats]

If (or

when

, rather) pressed to say who's looking most scum I'd have to say Rach and ArcAngel. Ray's points were fairly convincing on Rach, but they didn't quite get me on Rach or at all on ArcAngel until the two of them started rabidly defending each other. This early on in the game no one knows for sure who is town, but scum know who they need to protect. So I'd expect that kind of behaviour from scum, not town. I know we're trying to drop the meta analysis stuff but ArcAngel's swung beyond the usual feisty and into scary. I'm going to take some serious convincing that that's normal. (Added after I saw Rach's posts - yes, it's not like her scum games, but it's not like her town games either. So at best null. Both of you are still looking pretty bad from here.)

Chaos I think leaning town, I liked #54 – he’s scumhunting though he’s not as aggressive as some, he’s prodding at holes to see if something comes unravelled. He's disappeared though, and singersigner's V/LA 'til after the end of the deadline. IV a tentative but not very helpful (I hope there's a 'yet' in here) town. And Ray back to his former glory, a little more town than Chaos. Everyone else is confusing or null.

VOTE: RachMarie

Rach is now at L - 1, don't go lynching without announcing intent and giving her a chance to say anything she want to.

[RachMarie]

Adding Cats to the town pile.

So now Town pile: Arc, Ray, Cats
Leaning town on Singer

Scum pile Guyett.

[RachMarie]

IV needs to post more.

Chaos and ER weak town reads.


I do tend to suck on D 1.

[RachMarie]

Votecount 1.05

RachMarie - 3 - RayFrost, singersigner, Guyett
ArcAngel9 - 1 - ChaosOmega
Guyett - 1 - RachMarie
RayFrost - 1 - ArcAngel9
singersigner - 1 - innocentvillager

Not Voting: Evil Regals, ObsessedWithCats

With 9 alive, it takes 5 to lynch.

Deadline: (expired on 2013-10-17 14:21:42)

V/LA: ...

Based on this, yes I could see scum IV. He is voting for Singer and that would be a good spot for a one off the wagon.

Cats has voted since this vote count. in the number 4 slot which puts me at L-1.

Note Guyett is in the number 3 slot. This is a popular place for a scum to join the wagon, L-1 is far less common. Plus compare Cats case to Guyett. So of the two of them Cats is more likely to be town than Guyett.

[RachMarie]

Ray I am analyzing my wagon, not because it is my wagon, but because it is THE wagon. All other players with votes on them only have one vote. We are 6 pages in and already ready to lynch someone? The fact that only one major wagon has happened bothers me because that limits the info that town gets to go into D 2.

I am not fussed about being mislynched, it would not be the first time, nor I suspect the last time it happens to me, I know we can still win this game even with my mislynch, I just want to be sure that you have the info you need to actually catch the scum.


I am VT.

[Guyett]

ChaosOmega - null. Not enough content to get a decent read. 54 is the only post of any length and even that doesn't have much content

ObsessedWithCats - Null with a slight town lean. 39 is good. Shows good analysis of the situation on Page 1 and 2. Not sure if I like the swing in opinion from 39 to 49. Surely if you'd expect the reaction from AA9 to be that why did you say what you did in 39? its a bit wishy washy. Why say " I'd probably expect that reaction or similar from ArcAngel regardless of alignment." if you haven't played with her as scum?

Evil Regals - town. 72 is very nice. The willingness to openly change reads on people as the game progresses is very good.

RayFrost - very town. first posts showed signs of disinterest but the recent posts have been really good and were reminiscent of some of your play last game.


ArcAngel9 - Null to scum. Don't like her reaction to the 2 votes early on. [post]71 looks like a bullshit reason to opportunistically jump onto a shite wagon to put singer at L-2
81 was decent. Not liking the town read on Rach purely based on meta


RachMarie - biggest scum read so far. Don't like the self clear due to being scum last time.
This is interesting

Ray I am analyzing my wagon, not because it is my wagon, but because it is THE wagon. All other players with votes on them only have one vote. We are 6 pages in and already ready to lynch someone? The fact that only one major wagon has happened bothers me because that limits the info that town gets to go into D 2.

Especially after this

My thoughts on this is that we are now out of RVS since we have a major wagon going.

Basically most of her early postings have been active lurking and the later ones were building a shit case against Ray which he blew away with epic town posting and then even shitter cases on me based on apparent ability to be good scum.

Claimed VT without intent being stated. I don't like this but even if she is VT it's not a loss. I am completly fine sacrificing a VT this early if it gives us a nice wagon to analyse.
My vote stays here

innocentvillager - Null with a slight scum lean. There is a lot of active lurking here with very little actual content. However 61 is decent enough.

singersigner - Null with a slight town lean. I've never played with singer before so I have no meta info or tells ect.

[Guyett]

wow I derped a tag in there :/

[RachMarie]

Way to misrep dude, yes there was an early wagon on Arc but there is not one NOW. I already analyzed that one.

Say the same thing to you Guyett, when I flip town, who will you look at?

[Guyett]

Well Chaos needs to post more. I'd prob look at either AA9 or IV

[Guyett]

And imo wagons can't really be analysed until someone flips or comes out as town PR and is not CC'd

[Guyett]

Rach you've seen scum me before... how sure are you that this is scum me?
Have you worked out scum and town tells?

[Nobody Special]

Votecount 1.06

L-1 RachMarie - 4 - RayFrost, singersigner, Guyett, ObsessedWithCats
ArcAngel9 - 1 - ChaosOmega
Guyett - 1 - RachMarie
RayFrost - 1 - ArcAngel9
singersigner - 1 - innocentvillager

Not Voting: Evil Regals

With 9 alive, it takes 5 to lynch.

Deadline: (expired on 2013-10-17 14:21:42)

V/LA: ...

[RayFrost]

Please do the proddings of chaosomega

[RayFrost]

RMarie you've had six pages and ten million pages of meta research.

Give reasons for your reads or perish and be forgotten.

[Nobody Special]

ChaosOmega has been prodded.

[Guyett]

What do you make of my reads Ray?

[RayFrost]

I will let you know after RMarie tells me her reasons for her reads.

Note that the mod changed the lynch rules so that it is no lynch if we don't get enough votes at deadline.

So... vote before deadline any of you non-voting bums.

[Guyett]

Well we have a nice L-1 wagon sitting there with 3 days left so someone should be available to drop the hammer.

[RayFrost]

Yes but if people think that the lynch goes through regardless because they didn't read the rules then things would suck major dongs.

In the meantime, i must ask: did you read any of the meta I gave you of my scum play?

[Guyett]

I did a brief read.... you make very good convincing scum. I don't know if I'd be able to tell if you are town or scum tbh.

[RayFrost]

Well I'm town this game so don't worry about it.

keheheheheheheh

[ArcAngel9]

I am getting on this game today.. Dont hammer yet!!!

[Evil Regals]

Rach I suck as scum... havn't won a game as mafia and only won as werewolf as part of a large team

Testy. ._.

@Ray this is what I was trying to say

Guyett

e

is one to watch do not let his join date fool you,

I have seen him pull off scum quite well before

. I can find the link iffen you want it.

Rach I suck as scum... havn't won a game as mafia and only won as werewolf as part of a large team

please link good scum play by me Rach

So that's the only thing you agree/disagree or decided to comment on in regards to Rach's posts. It's not like solo-ly defending yourself, but this I don't like.

VOTE: Guyett

Arc you keep sayin this is town Rach -- but you haven't bothered to explain why.

[innocentvillager]

its L-1

fuck

we have 2 days

fuck

sorry im super busy ill post more tomorrow

[Evil Regals]

I also think Rach is town by the way the votes are spread out