Newbie 1433 - Game Over

[Nominull]

At LYLO I'm not sure freaking out under pressure is even a scumtell, since even a townie will lose if he is lynched. What does Satan think?

I really wish people wouldn't replace into games and then immediately disappear. It's really disruptive. By the time we get another replacement half the deadline will be used up already.

[TheFuzzylogic99]

What do you think of Klick being scum....Ree said he posted but it seems he has not posted here/// Not saying it is nessarily scummy but being LYLO maybe he figures he hide out and wait till we tear ourselves apart.

[Nominull]

Lurking so hard you get replaced isn't a winning strategy, because once you're replaced you can't win. Either he'll come back and we can talk to him, or he'll get replaced and we can talk to his replacement.

[SatanHellYeah]

I'm tired of replacements.

What do I think? About freaking out? Well, I find it quite normal too.

The thing is...

Saying scum must be newbie because they killed a sure lynch is kinda awkward. I mean, as a newbie, even I could see Peabody would probably be lynched. That's why I think there must be a different reason. It's just too stupid, even for a noob.

At the same time, it does look like it. So, in the end, I am eager to think it was intention to frame more than such a stupid mistake.

Don't get me wrong, it is possible, and I am not the best to argue right now, but I don't feel like that's the case.

And Klick not posting is just disturbing...why wouldn't he post? Does he think he cannot contribute or what?

[SatanHellYeah]

But, Nom, I'd be glad if you answered my question, if you don't mind.

[Klick]

I would replace out because I'm finding it difficult to make time to post here, but this game really doesn't need a replacement.

I'm going to devout some serious time to this tonight. Promise.

[SatanHellYeah]

Thanks, Klick. I'll be glad to hear anything you got to say.

[Nominull]

I don't think you understand, Satan. If you agree that Peabody was a sure thing, it makes no sense to forgo that to frame somebody. You don't need to frame anybody! You can just let the lynch on Peabody happen and then you've won the game. "Intent to frame" here

would be

a mistake.

Your question was, what, why am I alive? As I've explained, it's simple error. Killing me would have won the game, there are no good reasons for passing that up.

[Mr_Ree]

Unless they intended for me to keep attacking you and you to keep attacking me. Even then, leave PB as Lynch bait and kill one of the 3 newbies.

PB was a strange choice.

[TheFuzzylogic99]

I think argueing whether it was an odd or even the most obvious choice is pointless ..... we will just go around in circle. Almost everyone agrees on these points, even me.

Lets than assume that killing PB was not the best move.

Heres the possibilities I can see why the scum killed PB

1) as Nom said they scum did not realize that keeping PB was the best choice .
2) the scum figured that since PB was the best lynch target for day the town would think that why he was kept alive . He was a quick lynch possibilty and the town would not vote for him.
3) they had a personal grudge against PB and killing him overshadowed any other matter
4) they afraid that PB would indite them and would cause the town to lynch him....thus keeping him was more than a risk than a libility

[TheFuzzylogic99]

Edit.... should of them not him.

[Nominull]

you're killin' me here, Klick.

[SafetyDance]

Votecount 3.3

Not voting

: Klick, TheFuzzylogic99, SatanHellYeah, Nominull, Mr_Ree

Countdown to deadline: (expired on 2013-10-23 11:00:00). With 5 players, it's 3 to lynch.

[Nominull]

... can we get a prod on Klick? sigh

it'd be nice if we could get a deadline extension, it's terrible when a replacement dicks around and then replaces out, and the long prod deadline just makes it worse.

[SafetyDance]

With 3/5 alive players in lylo past the prod deadline, its mass prod time! Play the game people!

Yeah 72 hrs is probably a bit long for a 2-week gameday but not going to change it mid-game. Will extend deadline if needed.

[Nominull]

I think the problem is that we haven't heard anything from Ranawey's slot since the middle of day 2, which is making it very hard to assess his alignment at LYLO. And if he's town and we want to lynch scum, we need his vote. So there's sort of not a whole lot of playing the game we can do here.

[TheFuzzylogic99]

if Klick is an uninterested player ( since we deduced he is not doing this on purpose)

so either
a) he an uninterested townie
b) an uninterested scum

I hate that there is not much we can do.....and that Klick has the town fate in his hands. If Klick is town than I think Mods needs to reconsider him being in games bc this does not seem like the only time he jas disappeared during the game.

[Mr_Ree]

Lets say Klick is confirmed scum, who would the other one be?

Tbh, Im waiting on Klick's replacement. Why bother replacing in?

@Klick replace out if you are not going to read or post.

@Everyone: Please do a town to scum read list. lets see if that gives us anything.

[TheFuzzylogic99]

just noticed that Satan...was online today and did not post anything. I not sure if he was just trying to catch up on the posts or if he was lurking or something else.....just wanted to add this so it will be noted when the game get rolling again.

[Klick]

While I can say that I still haven't found the time to sit down and read the game fully through from the beginning, I can also say that from what I have read, Fuzzy seems very obviously scum to me. Especially due to his last post - he's claiming that I have the town's fate in my hands; if I'm scum, that's not necessarily the case. I think Fuzzy is scum making a logic jump and claiming that I'm town.

I think Satan is the other scum, but I feel pretty confident about Fuzzy.

PEdit: No need to have an attitude about it. I've had a rough, busy week, and I haven't been able to due much due to actual life.

[TheFuzzylogic99]

Im just reacting to Noms Post . Anyways how is this not the case since everyone is waiting for you to post and gives us reads and evidence.....I dont see how I am jumping logic .

[TheFuzzylogic99]

@ Klick....So either you are scum or you are town and have the town fate in your hands....I can not see another option.

and while I am glad you are posting I wish you would read and do more research before nailing someone as scum.

[Klick]

Theoretically, if I was scum, couldn't I just stall the game out to scum's advantage? In Post #941, you are only assuming that I am Town.

PEdit: That's the thing. I currently don't have the time to sit down and do a full read, and since I was asked to do that, I was unable to deliver for days.

[Klick]

And, to answer Ree:

TOWN
Nominull
Satan/Ree

Fuzzy
SCUM

[TheFuzzylogic99]

@ Rees

Town

Ree

Town??

Nom
Klick

Scum

Satan